Quantcast
Channel: iPleaders
Viewing all 14289 articles
Browse latest View live

Essential Features of a Valid Contract

$
0
0

This article is written by Manvendra Shekhawat. Here he has discussed on essential features of a contract.                 

Every day, people enter into agreements; too often these individuals enter into agreements without bearing in mind the essential provisions which are necessary to create an enforceable contract. A contract is formed or intended to form an agreement between two or more parties. There exist mainly two types of contract or we can say that contracts can be formed in two ways i.e. oral and written. A contract can be formed between two parties by the words only or orally and such type of contracts is known as the oral type of contracts. These types of contracts are hard to enforce as there is no proof of the agreement between the parties before the law and parties can change their statement frequently to save themselves from the penalties by the court. On the other hand, the signed or written contracts are mostly used by the people these days as these type of contracts are more secured as the contract already have the essential provisions of the contracts and what can be the consequences if any of the party does not complete its part. It is easy to enforce written contracts in courts as there is a strong proof of an agreement between them, easy to proof by the parties and reduces the risk which exists in the oral contracts.

A law called the “Statute of Frauds” necessitates those specific kinds of agreements be recorded as a hard copy to keep a person from offering evidence of a non-existent understanding through extortion or prevarication. All in all, the Statute of Frauds says that an agreement for the deal or exchange of land, or an agreement that, by its terms, can’t be performed inside one year of its execution, are just enforceable in the event that it is recorded as a hard copy and marked by the gatherings. Land contracts must distinguish the purchaser and vendor, recognize and depict the property being sold, and express the deal cost and terms of the understanding.

Despite the necessities of the Statute of Frauds, an understanding might be maintained in court if the gathering being sued concedes after swearing to tell the truth to the presence of an agreement. On the off chance that the vendor has acknowledged instalment or the purchaser has acknowledged conveyance of the merchandise or property secured by the oral contract, it might likewise be ruled substantial.

A contract has been defined as “an agreement enforceable by law.” For an agreement to be enforceable by law, it must contain the essential elements which are important for a valid contract.

Section 10 in The Indian Contract Act, 1872 tells about what agreements can constitute to a contract. “All agreements are contracts if they are made by the free consent of parties competent to contract, for a lawful consideration and with a lawful object, and are not hereby expressly declared to be void. Nothing herein contained shall affect any law in force in India, and not hereby expressly repealed, by which any contract is required to be made in writing or in the presence of witnesses, or any law relating to the registration of documents.”

https://lawsikho.com/course/diploma-advanced-contract-drafting-negotiation-dispute-resolution

Click Here

For a contract to be valid both the parties should have given their consent and that consent must be free. Both parties should behave in such a way that they can make an impression for the other party that other party is ready to make a contract and a legal relation, not a social relation. Thus a person who is casually saying that he/she is accepting an offer usually cannot be considered as a contract. On the other hand, a person who has no intention of making and completing a contract but acts that it makes people believe that he/she really wants to enter into a contract can be termed as a contract. Legally, it is the external appearance which is important in determining whether one is considered to a contract or not. Agreements which are of religious, social nature and moral e.g. a friend’s promise to other to go on a walk or picnic with him does not amount to a contract as both the parties didn’t intende on forming a legal relation and were neither intended to face legal consequences.

A contract comes into existence only when all the terms and conditions are satisfied and fulfilled by the parties to the contract. If any of the condition is not fulfilled by any of the party that agreement will be void. We can also say that contracts are self-regulated and no one else other than yourself is forcing you to enter into a contract. It’s upon your discretion that you want to enter into a contract or not and no one in any condition can force you to enter into any contract and if does so that agreement will be void. Later, the duties after entering into an agreement are defined by the state and if not followed be punished but entering into a contract is not forced by anyone else other than yourself. According to the Section 10 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 there are mainly four conditions which have to be satisfied to form a valid contract, i.e. free consent of parties to the contracts, competent to contract, for a lawful consideration and with a lawful object.

  • Free consent

A contract formed between two or more parties will be valid only when the consent given by the parties is free. A contract is based on the principle of consensus-ad-idem which says that all the parties who are entering into a contract should agree upon all the things related to the agreement in the same offence. The contracting parties should also possess the same understanding related to all the subject material of the contract. The consent given by the parties should be free and be given voluntarily and a mere consent by the parties does not form a contract or we can say that not enough to be a contract in the eyes of law. “The definition of free consent under the Indian Contracts Act is Consent that is free from Coercion, Undue Influence, Fraud, Misrepresentation or Mistake. Consent is said to be so caused when it would not have been given but for the existence of such coercion, undue influence, fraud, misrepresentation or mistake.” If at any point the assent given by the parties is influenced by any of the component stated above in the definition, it always creates a doubt if the consent was free or not.

  • Competence to contract

While the formation of a contract, contractual capacity is often spoken of as either capacity or competency. When it comes to forming a valid contract certain people or section of people are there who are not competent enough to form a contract. In short, both the parties to an agreement must have the capacity to contract to make an agreement legally enforceable by law. Contractual competency implies that both the parties are able to realize that a contract has been formed and the parties should also understand the basic needs and the consequences of the agreement in which they have given their assent. In short, we can say that when parties don’t apprehend the basis of the agreement they have entered, the law defines this type of agreement to be void because of the lacking of the party or both the parties to form a contract which is legally binding. It is also important that the contractual competence has no relation to a person’s individual ability to negotiate the nature of the contract. So, just for a reason that a person is not able to understand every provision of the contract does imply that he/she is not competent to form a legally binding contract. “The Indian Contract Act of 1872 defines who is of the age of majority, who is of sound mind and who is not disqualified from contracting by law.”

  • Legality of object and consideration

Another essential feature of a valid contract is that the object and the consideration must be lawful and not against the provisions by law. The object and the consideration of the object need to be lawful otherwise the contract will be declared void. In some cases, the object for which the parties entered into an agreement is lawful but the consideration for the same is defeating the provisions of a lawful consideration and which will lead the agreement to be termed as void and vice versa. So, for an agreement to be a valid one both the object and consideration should be lawful. The court will not enforce any agreement if its object and consideration are not lawful. The term “object of an agreement” is used to define the purpose of design. Section 23 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 clearly states about what object and consideration are lawful and what are not. These are:-

  • If that object or consideration is forbidden by law specifically
  • Are of that nature which will defeat the very basic purpose of the law
  • If the object or consideration is fraudulent
  • If that involves or result in injury to any living person or the property of the person
  • If the court has regarded any special objects and considerations as immoral
  • Those object and considerations which are against the policy of the public and can cause harm to the public.

As our project work is mainly going in and around with consideration part, so from here onwards, we will mainly rely on the consideration and focusing on the part which includes the contracts without any type of consideration, i.e. NUDUM PACTUM. These types of contracts are included in the exceptions of consideration where there is no requirement of consideration to form a valid contract which is enforceable by law.

The post Essential Features of a Valid Contract appeared first on iPleaders.


Discharge of Contract by Agreement

$
0
0

This article is written by Anurag Mohan Bhatnagar, here he has discussed on the discharge of contract by agreement.

Introduction

To discharge a contract is to end it. There are therefore as many kinds of the discharge as there are different ways of ending a contractual obligation. Discharge of a contract refers to the way in which it comes to an end. Contracts can come to an end in the following ways:

  • By Performance
  • By agreement or by consent
  • By promise failing to offer facilities for performance
  • By breach of contract
  • By impossibility of performance
  • By death
  • By refusing tender of performance
  • By unauthorized material alteration of the contract
  • Discharge by lapse of time
  • By operation of law

When the contract is formed by agreement, it may also be discharged or terminated through agreement, subject to the conditions of the contract. The agreement to extinguish or terminate the contract itself becomes a binding contract if supported by consideration or made under seal. The following are three main types of discharges:

  • Bilateral Discharge: The contract will be mutually discharged where the parties agree to release one another from any further obligations existing from the original contract. The contract is discharged despite the parties failing to fully or partially discharge all their obligations.
  • Accord and Satisfaction: Accord and satisfaction occurs where one party accords the release of another party, who is in breach of the original agreement, from its obligations in return for the satisfaction for the performance of another obligation.
  • Unilateral Discharge: Unilateral Discharge occurs where one party has completed its part of the bargain and agrees to release the other party from its outstanding obligations under the contract. The agreement is only binding if supported by consideration or made under seal.

In this article, however, we are going to deal with Discharge of Contract by Agreement in detail.

Types of Discharge by Agreement or Consent

As per Section 62 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 whose heading is – Effect of novation, rescission, and alteration of contract, “If the parties to a contract agree to substitute a new contract for it, or to rescind or alter it, the original contract need not be performed.

The 6 types through which discharge of contract through agreement or consent could take place are:

  • Novation
  • Rescission
  • Alteration
  • Remission
  • Waiver
  • Merger

Novation

Novation takes place when either a new contract is substituted for an existing one between the same parties, or, a contract between two parties is rescinded in consideration of a new contract being entered into on the same terms between one of the parties and a third party. In the famous case of Scarf v Jardine18 Lord Selborne explained the meaning and effect of novation in the following words:

There being a contract in existence, some new contract is substituted for it either between the same parties or between different parties, the consideration mutually being the discharge of the old contract. A common instance of it in partnership cases is whereupon the dissolution of a partnership the persons who are going to continue in business agree and undertake as between themselves and the retiring partner, that they will assume and discharge the whole liabilities of the business, usually taking over the assets and if in case they give notice of their arrangement to a creditor and ask for his accession to it there becomes a contract between the creditor who accedes and the new firm to the affect that he will accept the liability instead of the old liability and on the other hand that they promise to pay him for that consideration hence novation is of two kinds, namely:

  • A novation involving a change of parties
  • A novation involving the substitution of the new contract in the place of old

Change of Parties

The first illustration to Section 62 is a case of novation by the change of parties. The illustration is, A owes money to B under a contract. It is agreed between A, B and C, that B shall henceforth accept C as his debtor, instead of A. The old debt of A to B is at the end, and a new debt from C to B has been contracted. If A is a debtor and the creditor agrees to accept B in his place as the debtor, the original contract between the creditor and A is at the end.

https://lawsikho.com/course/diploma-advanced-contract-drafting-negotiation-dispute-resolution

Click Above

Substitution of New Agreement

When the parties to a contract agree to substitute a new contract for it, the original contract is discharged and need not be performed. It is necessary for the application of this principle that the original contract must be subsisting and unbroken. The substitution of a new contract is not possible after there has been breach of the original contract. An early illustration is Manohur Koyal v Thakur Das Naskar, the plaintiff sued to recover the sum of Rs. 1173 due on a bond. After the due date of the bond, the plaintiff agreed to accept Rs. 400 in cash and a new bond of Rs. 700 payable by instalments. Subsequently, the defendant neither gave Rs. 400 nor the bond.

The plaintiff thereupon sued him on the original bond. The Calcutta High Court held that the original contract was discharged, not by novation, but by breach, and the plaintiff was entitled to sue for the breach of the original contract.

Rescission

Section 62 of the Indian Contract Act also permits the parties to rescind their contract. The Supreme Court allowed the parties to rescind under this section a contract for sale of forest coupes because of substantial variance between the particulars of quantity and quality of timber held out at the time of the auction and the timber actually available. The contractor was allowed to refund of his deposit. But no compensation was allowed to him for his loss because the contract contained a clause against compensation in such circumstances. This was decided in the famous case law, namely Syed Isar Masood v State of MP.

Where an old contract is rescinded and is replaced by a new one, the old one will not revive only for the reason that has been a failure to keep the new promise. The parties may, however, by mutual consent, restore the original and then the original will revive and become binding on the parties.

Mode of Communicating or Revoking Rescission

The rescission of a voidable contract may be communicated or revoked in the same manner, and the subject to the same rules, as apply to the communication, or revocation, of a proposal. This is mentioned in Section 66 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872.

As per Section 64 of the Act, the party rescinding the voidable contract shall, if he has received any benefit thereunder from another party to such contract, restore such benefit, so far as may be, to the person from whom it was received.

Alteration

Section 62 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 defines alteration. Alteration of a contract may take place when one or more of the terms of the contract is/are altered by mutual consent of the parties to the contract. In such a case the old contract is discharged.

In the case of United India Insurance Co Ltd v M.K.J. Corpn it was delivered in the judgement that “Good faith is a continuing obligation inasmuch as even after entering into the contract, no material alteration can be made by a party in the terms of the contract without the consent of the other.

Where a contract is embodied in a deed and the party who has the custody of the deed alters it without the consent of the other in a material particular, the effect would exactly be the same as that of cancelling the deed. Both parties will be discharged from their respective obligations. The meaning of the expression “material alteration” was considered by the Supreme Court in Kalianna Gounder v Palani Gounder.

In the particular case, a memorandum of agreement for the sale of land under which Rs. 2000 were paid in advance was with the plaintiff. The defendant refused to convey the land and pleaded that the plaintiff had alerted the deed by adding the words that the seller shall “clear the debts and execute the sale deed free from encumbrance.

The plea was dismissed because the alleged alteration could not be proved, but Shah J took opportunity to point out: “Even if it be assumed that the sentence regarding encumbrances was written after the deed was executed it will not invalidate the deed, Ordinarily, when property is agreed to be sold for a price, it would be the duty of the vendor to clear it of all encumbrances before executing the sale deed. The alteration, if any, cannot, therefore, be regarded as material.

Remission

A promisee can forgo or transmit the execution of guarantee of an agreement, completely or to some degree. He can likewise expand the time concurred for the execution of the equivalent.

A remission is ordinary when it comes to fruition through an express concede to the account holder by a bank. It is inferred when the leaser makes a willful surrender of the first title to the indebted person under private mark comprising the commitment.  The term remission is additionally utilized in reference to the absolution or approbation of damage or offence, or the demonstration through which a Forfeiture or punishment is excused.

Reduction implies acknowledgement of a lesser exhibition that what was in reality due under the agreement. As per area 63, a gathering may shed or transmit, entirely or to a limited extent, the execution of the guarantee made to him. He can likewise broaden the season of such execution or acknowledge, rather than it, any fulfillment which he considers fit. A guarantee to do as such will tie despite the fact that there is no thought for it.

Waiver

Waiver signifies “Surrendering” the rights. At the point when involved with the agreement relinquishes or postpones his rights, the agreement is released. Here, both the gatherings commonly concur that they will never again be bound by the agreement. It adds up to an arrival of gatherings from their legally binding commitments.

What is a Waiver?

Waiver implies an individual surrendering a few or the majority of their legitimate rights under an agreement. There is more than one path by which a privilege might be postponed, and a waiver can happen either deliberately or unexpectedly.

  1. Waiver by contract or deed:

This happens where a gathering explicitly consents to surrender their lawful rights. Such an understanding will tie gave the ordinary prerequisites of an agreement have been met. Instances of this sort of waiver incorporate settlement or bargain understandings, varieties to a current contract, or another agreement supplanting a more seasoned one.

  1. Waiver by the decision:

This applies where a rupture of the agreement has happened and the “honest party” has a decision between two elective rights or cures. Waiver by race, as a rule, happens where the agreement contains an express right or alternative to end or repeal it in specific circumstances, or where one gathering submits a genuine rupture which gives the “blameless” party the privilege to end the agreement right away. In such cases, the “honest” party may pick either to end the agreement promptly or to forgo the rupture and proceed with the agreement.

Merger

An agreement additionally stands released through a merger that happens when a substandard right accumulating to party in an argument amalgamates into the better right resulting than a similar gathering. For example, contracts an industrial facility premises from B for assembling movement for a year, yet 3 months in front of the expiry of rent buys that very premises. Presently since A has turned into the proprietor of the structure, his rights related with the rent (substandard rights) in this manner converge into the privileges of possession (unrivaled rights). The past rental contract stops to exist. In certain circumstances, it is conceivable that substandard and predominant right corresponds in a similar individual. In such cases, both the rights join prompting a release of the agreement administering the sub-par rights.

Conclusion

In the Law of contracts, there is a great deal of misunderstanding or lack of understanding in regard to certain topics connected with the subject of discharge. It is due to the fact that few people use such terms as condition and warranty in the same sense, the rest is due to faulty reasoning concerning matters that are admittedly difficult. The best way of discharging a contract is based on performance. As this way both the parties follow all the terms of the contract and afterwards go for its discharge. On the other hand discharge by the breach is the most unpleasant way to release you from duties. Therefore, discharge by breach results in damages too.

Where there is no instrument that can be regarded as the obligation, there is great difficulty in proving the execution of a deed, for the obligation itself, cannot be physically delivered. But the surrender or cancellation of evidential documents may even in these latter cases prevent proof of the obligation or may be given evidence of mutual recession .but the recession and substitution are interwoven into one body and one breath neither one having power of separate existence . in pleading such a discharge the defendant must allege the very same things that must be alleged by a plaintiff who sues upon a contract except that it has to show a breach . The defendant is not seeking a remedy and hence he does not have to establish the existence of any secondary obligation. He must alleged merely the agreement, showing that it includes a recession of the former obligation. No technical language is required. The facts must be so stated that the court can determine whether or not there was an agreement and what were its terms.

 

The post Discharge of Contract by Agreement appeared first on iPleaders.

Presumptions in the Indian Evidence Act

$
0
0

This article is written by Sparsh Mali, a fourth-year law student at the School of Law, UPES, Dehradun. The article explains the various provisions of the Indian Evidence Act related to the concept of Presumption by Indian Judicial System.

Introduction

Presumption generally means a process of ascertaining few facts on the basis of possibility or it is the consequence of some acts in general which strengthen the possibility and when such possibility has great substantiate value then generally facts can be ascertained. A presumption in law means inferences which are concluded by the court with respect to the existence of certain facts. The inferences can either be affirmative or negative drawn from circumstance by using a process of best probable reasoning of such circumstances. The basic rule of presumption is when one fact of the case or circumstances are considered as primary facts and if they are proving the other facts related to it, then the facts can be presumed as if they are proved until disproved. Section 114 of Indian Evidence Act specifically deals with the concept that ‘the court may presume the existence of any fact which it thinks likely to have happened, regard being had to the common course of (a) natural events, (b) human conduct, and (c) public and private business, in their relation to the facts of the particular case’. 

Difference between Presumption of Facts and Presumption of Law

 

Topic

Presumption of Facts

Presumption of Law

Definition

When presumptions are established on the basis of facts or groups of facts or from the collection of facts.

When presumptions are acknowledged without the help of proof in certain situations or circumstances where court me presumes some facts itself.

Position of Presumption

Uncertain position.

Certain and uniform position.

Performance

They are always rebuttable and can be challenged after establishing probative evidence.

They are conclusive presumption unless proven with probative evidence.

 

Discretionary Power of Court

Court enjoys discretionary power, either to presume any facts or not.

Court has no discretionary power, and they are bound to presume some facts as such facts are presumed itself by the law.

Source of Presumption

They are derived on the basis of natural law, customary practices, and general mankind experiences.

Judicial customs & practices, the law under the statues are the only sources of presumption of law.

Examples

Presumption of Foreign Judicial Records, Presumptions of Abetment as to Suicide by a Married Women etc.

Presumption of Innocence, Presumption of declared death in absentia etc.

Difference between May Presume Shall Presume and Conclusive proof

May presume is a condition when the court enjoys its discretion power to presume any/ certain/ few facts and recognize it either proved or may ask for corroborative evidence to confirm or reconfirm the presumption set by the court in its discretion. Section 4 of the Indian Evidence Act provides that a fact or a group of facts may be regarded as proved, until and unless they are disapproved. The concept is defined under Section 4 of this act that ‘May Presume’ deals with rebuttable presumption and is not a branch of jurisprudence.

Whereas, shall presume denotes a strong assertion or intention to determine any fact.Section 4 of Indian evidence Act explains the principle of ‘Shall Presume’ that the court does not have any discretionary power in the course of presumption of ‘Shall Presume’, rather the court has presumed facts or groups of facts and regard them as if they are proved until they are disproved by the other party. Section 4 of the Indian Evidence Act explains that the concept of ‘Shall Presume’ may also be called ‘Presumption of Law’ or ‘Artificial Presumption’ or ‘Obligatory Presumption’ or ‘Rebuttable Presumption of Law’ and tells that it is a branch of jurisprudence.

While, Conclusive Presumptions/ Proofs, this can be considered as one of the strongest presumptions a court may assume but at the same time the presumptions are not completely based on logic rather court believes that such presumptions are for the welfare or upbringing of the society. With regards to Conclusive proofs, the law has absolute power and shall not allow any proofs contrary to the presumption which means if the facts presumed under conclusive proofs cannot be challenged even if the presumption is challenged on the basis of probative evidence. This is the strongest kind of all the existing presumptions whereas Section 41, 112 and 113 of the Evidence Act and S. 82 of the Indian Penal Code are one of the most important provisions related to the irrebuttable form of presumptions or Conclusive Presumption.

The general definition of Conclusive Proof is a condition when one fact is established, then the other facts or conditions become conclusive proof of another as declared by this Act. The Court in its consideration shall regard all other facts to be proved, only if one fact of the case is proven without any reasonable doubt. And if the other facts are proved on the basis of proving of one fact that the court shall not allow any evidence contrary to other facts which are presumed as conclusive proofs.

Illustration- A and B married on June 1 and the husband left home to his work for 6 months later he discovered that her wife is pregnant he divorced the wife and challenges that he is not liable for paying damages either to his wife or to his illegitimate son. And also explains that he never consumed his marriage as just after one day of marriage he left his home for his work. But in this case, the court will conclusively presumed that the son born out of his wife is legitimate because he was with his wife for at least 1 day and shall not allow any proof contrary to the conclusive proof even if he provides probative evidence. 

General Classification of Presumption

The traditional approach of common law system has classified presumption only under two categories that are a presumption of law and presumption of facts but to avoid any ambiguity in deciding any case the Indian legal system has adopted the third classification that is mixed presumptions which includes both the aspects of facts as well as law. Hence the existing legal system has three types of presumptions which are as follows:

1) Presumption of Facts- Presumptions of facts are those inferences that are naturally and reasonably concluded on the basis of observations and circumstances in the course of basic human conduct. These are also known as material or natural presumptions. Natural Presumptions are basically instances of circumstantial evidence as it is believed that it is very good to act in the course of reasoning where much inferences can be easily concluded from other evidence otherwise it will keep much ambiguity on the legal system because it will be much more difficult because of the legal system to prove every fact to capture the offenders or law conflicted member of the society. Natural Presumptions are generally rebuttable in nature.

There are few provisions that are directly expressing about Natural Presumptions such as Section 86- 88, Section 90, Section 113A, Section 113 B of Indian Evidence Act. Where Section 113A & 113 B are one of the most important provisions of presumptions under this Act, whereas Section 86 talk about certified copies of foreign judicial records, Section 87 expresses presumption of Books, Maps and Charts, Section 88 deals with presumption related to Telegraphic Messages, Section 90 deals with documents aged thirty years old, whereas Section 113 A deals with hardcore crime that is Presumption as to abatement of suicide by a married women and Section 113 B deals with the presumption as to dowry death. Under the Presumptions of Facts, the concept of ‘shall presume’ is utilized. And by the concept, the court will presume that a fact ascertained before them are proven facts until and unless they are proven disproved by the accused. The concept of ‘shall presume’ expresses that the courts are bound to maintain and recognise some facts as proven by making a mandatory presumption and the court has to consider them as completely proven until such presumption are challenged and disapproved. When these presumptions are disproved by the challenging party then the court has no discretion on maintaining such presumptions.

1.1) Few Conditions Where Court May Use the Presumption of Facts To Ascertain Some Facts:-

Foreign Judicial Records- Section 86 explains the principle that the court has the discretionary power to make presumptions with respect to the originality and accuracy of the certified copies of a different foreign country’s judicial records and the called document should be consistent with the local or domestic rules. The presumption explained under this Section has a very significant role, therefore, should be complied with it. It is also observed that if the court does not feel that the foreign judgments are not consistent with the local laws then these judgments lose the evidentiary values in the court.

Abetment as to Suicide by a Married Women- Section 113A deals with the presumptions of abetment of suicide of a married woman either by her husband or any of his relatives. The court has mentioned few essentials to check that whether a suicide executed by married women is inconsistent with the essentials mentioned under the provision, and if they are consistent to it then the court in such cases will presume that such suicide has been abetted either by the husband or his relative. The essentials of this provision are:

(i) The incident of suicide was committed within a period of seven years from the date of her marriage; and

(ii) Her husband, or his relative, has subjected her to cruelty as according to the Section 498A of IPC.

In Chhagan Singh v State of Madhya Pradesh, the victim was badly beaten by the accused at some place and for such guilty act the accused explains the reasons that the victim was stealing rice and because of it, he has beaten the victim. But just after the few days of the incident victim committed suicide. The court in this matter acquitted the accused or discharged the accused of offence mentioned under Section 113A of Indian Evidence Act as the court didn’t find any evidence subject to cruelty and also mentioned that the essentials of Section 113A are not fulfilled with the facts of the cases, hence in the case of murder legal presumptions of Section 113A is not a part of it. Because the death of the person is caused due to other reasons and the legal principles of 113A cannot be just applied blindly as one has to see the nexus of it. The advantage of the presumption of Section 113A can only be granted if either her husband or any of his relative has treated the women with cruelty in any sense.

In, Nilakantha Pati v State of Orissa, in this case, the accused married the victim in April 1982 and has been benefited with a dowry. But later the accused desired to purchase a house, and of the purpose, he asked the victim to get Rs 70,00 from her parents. When she could not get the amount she was tortured and in 1986 she died. The accused supported his arguments with proper reasoning and logic that the court found the presumption to be of rebuttable nature. As the arguments advanced by the accused have enough relevance, the accused was acquitted of Section 113A. The High Court said that they presumption exited here is rebuttable and such presumption can be escalated whenever the circumstances of the case match the essentials or the interpretation of the legal provisions. And here, in this case, the accused has disproved all the presumptions of the court hence, the accused was released.

In, Mangal Ram & Anor v State of Madhya Pradesh, in this case, the wife of the accused was living with her parents for many years and has no visited her matrimonial home for a long time. But within one month of returning to her matrimonial home, she committed suicide. Therefore the court presumed the circumstance that the accused is responsible for the death of the lady and the case comes under Section 113B of Indian Evidence Act. But the husband and her in-laws proved that the death was not caused because of the reasons subjected to cruelty. The court in that matter said that the presumption was of rebuttable nature and the presumption can’t be sustained anymore, hence the accused acquitted.

  1. Abetment of Suicide to married Women for the purpose of Dowry- Section 114B of Indian Evidence Act deals with the principles of presumption related to abetment of suicide to married women for the purpose of dowry. This Section empowers the court to presume that the husband and his relative are the abettors of suicide and the wife was subjected to cruelty or any torture related to demand of dowry. While explaining the concept of Section 113B the court explains certain essentials which are to be fulfilled for raising any presumption related to abetment of dowry death. The essentials of Section 113B are completely the same as of essentials of Section 113A of Indian Evidence Act.

But a thin line difference between Section 113A & 114B is that the presumption of Section 114B only comes to the picture if the prosecution has certain proofs that the cause of death was cruelty or maltreatment or harassment for dowry demand. Hence, under this Section, the presumption is carried only when the prosecution proves the case.

In, Hem Chand v State of Haryana [1] the couple married on 24 May of 1962. The wife left her husband’s home just after 2 months of her marriage and explained the reason to her parents that her husband is demanding for a TV and a refrigerator. After listening to such demands her father out of his hard money gave her around Rs. 6,000 and she left for her matrimonial home. But the husband’s desire was not finishing and he again asked her to get twenty-five thousand rupees from her home as he is willing to buy some real estate property. Thereafter the accused took his wife to her parents’ home and said that he’ll take back her only if he will be paid Rs. 25,000. One year after she came back to her matrimonial home with Rs. 15,000 and promised the balance amount will be paid soon. But on the same day, she died of strangulation in her husband’s home. The trial court and both Supreme Court found accused to be guilty and convicted on carrying the presumptions that her husband has performed cruelty against her and the reason for her death could be the husband’s cruelty for the purpose of dowry.

In Shanti v State of Haryana [2], The Supreme Court held that the victim’s death should be soon after the victim was subjected to cruelty or harassment for the purpose of dowry. But in this matter, the wife was taken back to her home as the dispute was solved by the local panchayat and this incident happened before 10-15 days of her death. However, the facts seem to be so clear but the presumption cannot be made as there was no evidence which indicates that she was treated with cruelty for the purpose of raising dowry when she was taken back to her matrimonial home. Hence in these circumstances, the presumption for dowry death cannot be raised and Section 113B of the Indian Evidence Act cannot be brought into action.

In, Baijnath & Others v. State of Madhya Pradesh [3], Supreme Court expounded that, “One of the essential ingredients of dowry death under Section 304B of the Penal Code is that the women must have subjected to cruelty either by the husband or his relatives for the purpose of dowry soon before her death and bring it as an essential ingredient of Section 304B of IPC the prosecution has to prove the connection of the victim’s death with the act of cruelty by the husband or by his relative for the purpose of demanding dowry and the connection must be proved beyond reasonable doubt then only the court will put the case into the window of Section 113B of Indian Evidence Act.

https://lawsikho.com/course/diploma-companies-act-corporate-governance
               Click Above

May Presume- Section 114 of the Indian Evidence Act deals with the concept ‘presumption of certain facts by the court’. The Court may presume the existence of any fact which it thinks likely to have happened, regard being had to the common course of natural events, human conduct and public and private business, in their relation to the facts of the particular case.

Illustrations-

  • Every negotiable instrument is presumed that it is drawn for the purpose of good consideration.
  • There shall be continuity of things unless proven contrary like if a property is considered to be an ancestral property, it shall be presumed that it is so until it is proven contrary to the presumption (Chito Mahtoo v Lila Mahto).
  •  If a person refuses to answer a question, which is not compelled by the law to answer, the court may presume that if he answers the question then the answer would be unfavourable to him.
  •  That if a man possesses some stolen goods soon after the theft then it is believed that he is either the thief or has received the goods knowing the nature of the goods unless he can account for his possession.

2) Presumption of Law-

Presumptions of law are such inferences and beliefs which are established or assumed by the law itself. It can further be divided into rebuttable presumptions of law and irrebuttable presumptions of law.

Rebuttable Presumptions (praesumptio iuris tantum): Rebuttable Presumptions are certain presumption which is regarded as evidence of good quality and does not lose their quality until proven contrary to the presumption. Although it does not easily measure the extent of such presumption as their validity only exists until they are not proven wrong. The basic example of rebuttable presumptions can be- if a person who is in possession of some stolen property than it is quite obvious that he can either be a thief or a receiver.

Matrimonial offences are one of the best examples to explain any presumption because in such offence the possibility of getting evidence is nearly low as these offences that take place within the closed area of matrimonial house. Hence the presumption is very important in such cases/offences. There are broadly three important provisions regarding the presumption in matrimonial offences which are:

  • Presumption as to abetment of suicide by a married woman within seven years of marriage covered under Section 113A of Indian Evidence Act.
  • Presumption as to dowry death within seven years of marriage covered under Section 113B of Indian Evidence Act.
  • Birth during the marriage is the conclusive proof of legitimacy covered under Section 112 of the Indian Evidence Act.

In, Shantiv. State of Haryana [4], the in-laws of the bride did not allow her to visit her maternal house to meet her parents, and when the bride’s parents came to meet her they were not permitted to enter the house and complained to them about the amount of dowry that the demand of scooter & TV was not fulfilled. Soon after the incident, the wife of the accused suffered an unnatural death. The Supreme Court allowed the presumption stated under Section 113B of Indian Evidence Act as the death was caused within seven years of marriage and that too just after such incident prohibited under this Act, and on the basis of applications of this Section one of the in-laws was convicted for causing dowry death.

In State of M.P. v. Sk. Lallu [5], a newly wedded wife was facing severe beating regularly by her in-laws from the very first day of her marriage, and at last, she ends up dying with 100% of burn injuries. The Court executed the application of presumption stated under Section 113A and explained that such presumption can be invoked to punish the accused.

Ir-rebuttable Presumption (praesumptio iuris et de iure)- Such presumptions cannot be ruled out by any additional probative evidence or argument. Therefore the presumption explained comes under the roof of conclusive presumption which cannot be proven contrary. Eg. A child under the age of seven years is presumed that he is not capable of committing any crime.

2.1) Few Conditions Where Court May Use the Presumption of Law To Ascertain Some Facts:

Presumption of Innocence (ei incumbit probatio qui dicit, non qui negat)- According to this legal maxim, the burden of proof is with the person who declares the facts, not the person who denies the fact. The presumption of innocence is the legal principle which means every person should be considered as an innocent person unless it is proven guilty or until court believes that the person is in charge of acts prohibited under law.

In, Chandra Shekhar v. State of Himachal Pradesh the High Court made great observations and mentioned that freedom of any individual is the prime objective of the constitution and such right cannot be dissolved by any means unless provided by the law itself. It is concluded that unless the person is proved guilty he must be presumed as innocent.

In, Dataram Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh & anr., the Supreme Court said that a person should be presumed and believed to be innocent unless proven guilty.

Birth During Marriage- The Latin maxim ‘pater est quem muptice demonstrat’, explains a basic assumption that the person who marries women is the father of son/ daughter out of wife. Section 112 of the Indian Evidence Act deals with the legitimacy of a child born during the marriage. The Section implies that if a child is born during the continuance of a valid marriage between the couple then it is conclusive proof of that the child is legitimate and the only ground which is available to either of the parties to prove the illegitimacy is to prove any access to each other in such a way that their marriage was not consumed. The main objective of the lawmaker institute is to provide legitimacy to the child born during a valid marriage and the legislature also explains that such presumption is not only limited to provide legitimacy to the child but also it is to maintain the public morality so that the legitimacy of the child cannot be questioned.

It must be noted that the application used under the Section 112 derives from Section 4 of the same Act and must be read together to understand the general applicability Section 4 which expresses that wherever there is a doubt of the legitimacy of children born during a valid marriage the court will presume, fact that the person whom the mother married the father of that child. Hence to achieve the objective of the legislature the court must assume it to be a case of ‘conclusive proof’. Just like all laws, no law is absolute therefore the legitimacy of such a child can only be rebutted the party proves no non-access to each other or if no marriage was consumed. Which means even the DNA test other such tests are not capable of disproving the presumption.

In Revanasiddappa v. Mallikarjun [6] the Supreme Court opined that: the objective of the Constitution is broadly expressed in the Preamble of our Constitution which focuses on equality, equity, equal opportunity and separate individual’s dignity. The Court while adjudicating such cases must remember the objectives of the constitution that everybody has separate and individual dignity of his own, therefore the court has to look into the matter that illegal or immoral or illegitimate relationships of parent do not hinder the dignity of the child born out of such relationships. As a child born out of such a relationship is innocent and has all the rights empowered to him under the Constitution and the status of the child must be as equal to as of child born out of valid marriage.

In Shanta Ram v. Smt. Dargubai, the Bombay High Court expressed its view that the child born out of void marriages would be deemed to be legitimate child irrespective of any nullity, although such child would not acquire the same right of succession as the original successor will enjoy.

Gautam Kundu v. State of West Bengal [7] the Supreme Court in its observations expresses that-

  • Courts have no authority to direct blood test to challenge the legitimacy of the child.
  • The husband has only one possibility to get rid of such presumption and for that, he must satisfy the court by proving no- access to consume the marriage.
  • The Court should carefully examine the fact that what will be the consequences if the blood test comes in favour of a husband who is challenging the legitimacy of the child. And what if the further consequence has a serious impact on the child’s legitimacy or makes the mother as an impure/ unchaste woman.
  1. Presumption of Death- The presumption of death is explained under Section 107 and 108 of Indian Evidence Act which refers to a situation when a person has disappeared for many years, and after such situations the law presumes him to be dead.Section 108 of this Act describes the amount or the tenure i.e. 7 years, where, there should be no proof of the existence of the person in the society.

In Balambal v. Kannammal [8], the court held that the presumption of death could only be invoked if the death or inexistence of that person is proved when the presumption is raised in the court and no person can utilise such presumption for generating any type of death record of the called person.

In T.K Rathnam v. K. Varadarajulu [9], the dissenting opinion of the learned judge explains in his judgment that the presumption of the existence of the person or death of the person is always rebuttable. He also observed that the accurate timing of death is not a matter of presumption rather it is a matter of evidence.

  1. Presumption of Sanity- It refers to the mental state of a person facing a criminal trial. Specifically, the court assumes that every person is sane and is fit to his mental capacity until someone proves contrary to the assumptions of the court.
  2. Presumption of Constitutionality- The presumption of constitutionality refers to a concept that all statutes, bills, policies, guidelines etc., drafted by different levels of governments are consistent with the constitutional requirements. The court generally presumes that the statues are meeting the constitutional requirements’ and are helping in achieving the constitutional objective. But the person, who interprets these statues in such a manner which makes such statues contrary to constitutional requirements, then has to prove the same.
  3. Presumption of Possession- Section 110 deals with such presumption and explains it as when a person who is enjoying the possession of anything and he claims himself as the owner then the court inferences that he is the real owner. These are generally rebuttable presumptions and do not lose their substantiality until they are proven contrary by the affecting party.

3) Mixed Presumptions (Presumption of Fact and law both): 

Mixed presumptions is a blend of different concepts explained above in this article. When the court in its inferences uses such blend consists of different classification of presumption i.e., Presumption of Facts and Presumption of Law then the presumption is considered to be a Mixed Presumption. The principles of such presumptions are only reflected in the English which specifically deals with statute of real property. But in the Indian legal system, the principles of presumptions are expressed specifically and The Indian Evidence Act deals with such principles. The Indian Evidence Act has mentioned few provisions both for the presumption of law and for presumptions of facts. The scope of this statute just does not end here rather it also has different provisions which deal with the discretionary power of Indian Court in raising presumption such as­- Principles of May Presume, Shall Presume and Conclusive Proof.

Conclusion

In Tukaram v State of Maharashtra [10], This case was decided on considering the facts of Mathura Rape Case and while adjudicating the case the Court justified the need and necessities of such presumptions. The Court also explained that Presumptions has a wider scope as they don’t only help the victim in the fast trial but it also helps in giving direction to the case. Therefore such presumption can effectively help the judiciary in providing quick and complete justice to the society. According to Stephen presumption is mandatory, not permissive presumption and especially permissive is dealt in Section 90 of the evidence act. Permissive presumption means it is on the court discretion whether to believe or not to believe.

References

  1. (1994) 3 Crimes 608 (SC)
  2. AIR 1991 SC 1226
  3. (2017) 1 SCC 101
  4. A.I.R. S.C. 1126
  5. 1990 Cri. L.J. 129
  6. (2011, 11 SCC 1)
  7. (AIR 1993 SC 2295) 
  8. A.I.R 1989 Madras 248 = 1989-1-L.W. 306)
  9. (1970 A.P 246)
  10. 1979 2 SCC 143

 

 

 

 

 

The post Presumptions in the Indian Evidence Act appeared first on iPleaders.

Shakti Mills Gang Rape Case of 2013

$
0
0

This article is written by Amandeep Kaur, a student of Symbiosis Law School, Pune. The author in this article has discussed the Shakti Mills Gang Rape Case.

Facts of the case

The State of Maharashtra v. Vijay Mohan Jadhav and Ors. 2013

On 22 August 2013 at about 5 pm the victim, who was a Photojournalist aged 22, and was interning under the English Magazine went to the premises of Shakti Mills along with her colleague namely Anurag for a project which involved capturing old articles and deserted premises of Mumbai.

There they encountered Vijay Jadhav and Salim who were later identified as accused. Both of them initially helped the victim and his colleague to enter the premises of Shakti Mills but later called their partners i.e. the other three accused, one of them was a juvenile and tied Anurag and dragged the victim to an isolated room where they one by one brutally raped the victim and also took her photographs for threatening her that if she complains about them, they will circulate those photographs. This case is also called the Mumbai Gang Rape case of 2013.   

Issues

  1. Whether the accused are liable for disrobing the victim?
  2. Whether the accused can be held liable for committing unnatural acts?
  3. Whether the accused can be held liable for raping a woman?

Rules

 

  • Section 354B of the Indian Penal Code, 1860.

 

Assault or use of criminal force to woman with intent to disrobeAny man who assaults or uses criminal force to any woman or abets such act with the intention of disrobing or compelling her to be naked, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which shall not be less than three years but which may extend to seven years, and shall also be liable to fine.

  1.   Section 377 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860.

Unnatural offencesWhoever voluntarily has carnal intercourse against the order of nature with any man, woman or animal, shall be punished with imprisonment for life or with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to ten years, and shall also be liable to fine.

  1.   Section 376D of the Indian Penal Code, 1860.

Gang rapeWhere a woman is raped by one or more persons constituting a group or acting in furtherance of a common intention, each of those persons shall be deemed to have committed the offence of rape and shall be punished with rigorous imprisonment for a term which shall not be less than twenty years, but which may extend to life which shall mean imprisonment for the remainder of that person’s natural life, and with fine.

  • Provided that such fine shall be just and reasonable to meet the medical expenses and rehabilitation of the victim.
  • Further, provided that any fine imposed under this section shall be paid to the victim.

Analysis

Disrobing a woman according to Sec 354B of IPC

Disrobing means forcing the woman to be naked. In the present case if this judgment is interpreted the accused forced her to be disrobed and later raped her which does amount to an offence both under Section 354 and 375. They forced the victim by keeping a broken glass bottle on her neck and threatening her that they will kill her if she does not remove all her clothes along with her shoes. One of the accused himself removed her underwear and bra. 

In the majority of the cases, disrobing is done with an intention either to rape the victim or with an attempt to rape. It can be found in the case of Mukesh and Ors. v. State for NCT of Delhi and Ors. [2] where the gang forcibly disrobed the victim and then committed the brutal offence of raping her and then leading her to death. Even in the case of Dalveer v. State of U.P.[3] the victim was disrobed first and then raped by the accused. The present case is also an example of disrobing and then raping the victim.

https://lawsikho.com/course/certificate-criminal-litigation-trial-advocacy

Click here

Unnatural offences according to Section 377 of IPC

Unnatural offences here means which are against the order of nature for instance- anal sex or sodomy which is usually present in a majority of the rape cases. In the case of Sanil Kumar v. State of Kerala and Ors.[4] the accused who promised the victim to marry her committed rape which included unnatural offences too. In the case of  Raju v. State of Haryana[5] the appellant was found guilty of committing sodomy upon a female of nine years and sentenced to three years imprisonment, considering the nature of offence and age of the appellant, the court ordered the authorities to keep the accused in an institution rather than imprisoning him in a cell so that the accused can regret and consider what he did and it is to be considered as adequate punishment which can be given under such circumstances.

Unnatural offences existed in both the Mughal and British era. Moreover, at that time there was no legislation which criminalized unnatural acts. It was during the British period that such acts were penalised. This theory of criminalizing unnatural acts was based on morals and ethical standards of Judeo-Christian. The legislation which criminalized unnatural acts can still be seen under section-377 of IPC and is now a part of Indian morals and values.[6] 

Even in the famous Nirbhaya case i.e. State vs. Ram Singh and anr., the deceased Jyoti Singh faced the brutish behaviour of the accused of being forced to have anal sex, the accused inserted iron rod to her private parts and anal region which ultimately led to the death of the deceased.[7] In the present case of Shakti mills, the victim was assaulted by the five rapists who did vaginal, anal and oral penetration with her and also showed her pornographic clips and forced her to perform accordingly. The accused Mohd. Salim, Mohd. Siraj and  Vijay ravished her by doing unnatural sex with her. Not only this after having raped her once accused Mohd. Kasim again came to rape her but when the victim requested that she is already suffering pain and to let her go he forcefully started having unnatural sex with her.

Gang rape according to Sec 376D of IPC

As the section clearly reflects when a woman is raped by two or more persons it is called as gang rape. Gang rapes are considered as the most brutal behaviour one can see in a human being against another human being. India has witnessed a huge number of gang rapes some of which were highlighted by the media leading into high-profile cases whereas some weren’t given any attention. 

In the case of Bhupinder Sharma v. State of Himachal Pradesh,[8] the Supreme Court held the appellant who was one of the accomplices of gang rape, guilty under section-376(2) of IPC even though he, unlike other members of the group, could not sexually assault the victim as she escaped from the place of incident before he could execute the act. However, the trial court convicted and ordered him, without giving any adequate and special reasons, to undergo rigorous imprisonment for four years while it sentenced the penetrators of actual rape to rigorous imprisonment for 10 years. 

The Supreme Court, in the case of  Priya Patel v. State of Madhya Pradesh, ruled out that every member of such a group, acting in furtherance of the common intention of the group, by virtue of the deeming explanation, per se deserves the minimum sentence stipulated in section 376(2). [9] In the case of Saleem and Ors. v. State, [10] which is a recent case, decided on 16-07-2018 the father and the brother of the victim were charged for committing gang rape on her. But later it was found by the court that one of the accused which is brother of the victim was below the age of 18 during the time of the incident and has already served more than 3years of imprisonment till the date of decision and was therefore released whereas the other accused was given punishment according to the section. 

In the case of Jyotish Bhowmick and Ors. v. The State of West Bengal[11] the High Court ruled out that mere absence of injuries on the back of the victim or absence of sperms in the vaginal swab which may have occurred due to the delayed examination of the vaginal swab or the bathing of the victim prior to the medical examination does not in condition can be considered in the favor of the appellants and could not go against the victim that she was forcibly gang raped by the appellants. In the present case, the victim was harshly gang raped by 5 accused one by one which was medically proved by the doctors and her colleague who was with her at the time of the incident.

Judgment given 

In this case, it was ruled out that all the accused were liable for several offences including gang rape, disrobing and unnatural offences. Three of the accused who were adults were hanged till death whereas the minor one was tried by the Juvenile Justice Board and was convicted on 15 July 2015, and sentenced to three years (including time in custody) in a Nashik reform school, the maximum punishment that a juvenile offender can receive under Indian law. 

Rarest of Rare case

This case was described as the ‘rarest of rare’ case after the formula evolved by the first landmark decision on the point which summarizes the law on the question of capital punishment in Bachan Singh V State of Punjab[12] in which the Apex court has upheld the Constitutional validity of the death penalty for the first time. It was the first time in the country that rape convicts have been sentenced to death under this section that was brought in by the new Criminal Law (Amendment) Act in 2013 after the brutal Delhi gang-rape case also known as Nirbhaya gang-rape case. 

The judgement and the punishment, in my opinion, are morally just and will help in the deterrence of crime in the future. Such a judgement would instil fear in the minds of rapists, which would prevent the happening of such a crime in the future, which in turn would protect the innocent. A few years back after a couple of High Courts allowed mediation to take place between the Rape Victim and the accused, the Supreme Court in the case of State of M.P. v. Madanlal in a strong-worded judgment held that in a case of rape or attempt to rape, the conception of compromise under no circumstances can be really thought of. [13]

Conclusion 

Rape not only leaves a scar on the mind of the victim but also makes her life a hell to live. The judgment leaves a twofold impact: 

  • It gave justice to the victim who will have to live with the fact of having been raped, forever. 
  • It ensured that the criminal got appropriate punishment for not only indulging in the heinous crime once but several times. Such an inhuman person is of no use to society and they only are danger and burden for the society. 

The judgement given in the present case sent a positive message to the public who were losing faith in this regard, this judgement somewhat restored the faith of the common masses in the system and sent a message that whoever commits rape will not be spared. It cannot match with the suffering of the survivor or the family, but it will restore their faith and the faith of others in humanity and justice. It is about time when the Supreme court shall amend the law and declare death penalty or life imprisonment as minimum punishment for harsh and inhumane crimes such as gang-rape.

The only way to bring down the number of rape incidents in our country is deterrence, which can be done only by imposing some strict punishments. Creating some kind of fear in the minds of criminals can also be used to decrease the crime rate in the area of sexual offences. 

References

Bibliography

  1. Criminal Law, PSA Pillai’s
  2. Criminal Law, KD Gaur
  3. Indian Penal Code, KD Gaur

Webliography

  1.  www.scribd.com
  2. SCC Online
  3. Manupatra

[1] Sheikh Shamim v. The State of Bihar,

[2] AIR 2017 SC 2161

[3]  MANU/UP/2866/2017

[4] 2018 SCC Ker 1353.

[5] Raju v. State of Haryana (1998) Cr Lj 2583, p2592.

[6] Nimeshbhai Bharatbhai Desai vs. State of Gujarat, 2017 SCC Guj 1386.

[7] State v. Ram Singh & ors., 2014 SCC Del 1138.

[8] AIR 2003 SC 4684, (2003) 8 SCC 551.

[9] Priya Patel v. State of Madhya Pradesh (2006) 6 SCC 263.

[10] MANU/DE/2500/2018.

[11] MANU/WB/0556/2018.

[12] (1980) 2 S.C.C. 684

[13] State of M.P. v. Madanlal, 2015

 

The post Shakti Mills Gang Rape Case of 2013 appeared first on iPleaders.

Torts relating to immovable property

$
0
0

This article is written by Amandeep Kaur, a student of Symbiosis Law School, Pune. The author in this article has discussed in brief the various categories of torts relating to the immovable property along with the remedies and defences available to the plaintiff and defendant respectively.   

Introduction 

A is a farmer and his farm is next to the land of B who has cows. One day, B’s cows enter the farm of A and cause damage to his farms. Here the owner of cows i.e. B will be liable for the tort of trespass which is a tort relating to immovable property. In order to show that a tort of immovable property has been caused, one needs to fulfil the following conditions:-

  1. There is a right to hold or possess
  2. There is either disturbance or usurpation(seize) of such right
  3. Such disturbance or usurpation may be caused by actual physical damage to property or by interference with or impairing of the enjoyment of it

Torts relating to immovable property consist of the following categories:

  1. Trespass
  2. Injury to reversionary rights
  3. Waste
  4. Dispossession
  5. Wrongs to natural rights and easement
  6. Nuisance 

Trespass 

There are two kinds of trespass:

  1. Trespass quare clausum fregit- unlawful entry upon land
  2. Trespass de bonis asportatis- the wrongful taking of goods

In order to constitute the tort of trespass one does not need to prove-

  • Force 
  • Unlawful detention
  • Actual damage
  • Breaking of an enclosure 

Trespass is actionable per se which means it does not need any proof of actual damage caused to the property.

Trespass may be committed by any of the following ways-

  • By entering wrongfully upon the land of the plaintiff– the slightest crossing of the boundary is sufficient for committing trespass. A man is not liable for trespass committed involuntarily, for instance when he is thrown upon the land by someone else (Smith v. Stone). Moreover, it is presumed that if a person owns the surface of a piece of land then he owns all the underlying strata.   
  • By remaining there in the land– if a person has lawfully entered on the land of the plaintiff but remains there even after his right of living there has ceased commits trespass; for instance, a tenant living on the land of the plaintiff even after the time period of the agreement is over.
  • By interfering with the land or by constructive entry– every interference with the land of the another is deemed to be a constructive entry which amounts to trespass. For instance, throwing a stone upon the plaintiff’s land or piling of garbage against his wall is a trespass to land. 

Remedies available to the plaintiff

A person whose land is trespassed has the following remedies:

  1. An action can be brought by him against the wrongdoer.
  2. Force can also be used by the plaintiff in order to defend his possession or eject the trespasser from his land.
  3. An injunction can also be obtained by the plaintiff from the court under the Specific Relief Act, 1963 to restrain a continuing or threatened trespass. 

https://lawsikho.com/course/diploma-advanced-contract-drafting-negotiation-dispute-resolution

Click here

Defences available to the defendant or the wrongdoer

  1. Prescription
  2. Leave and license
  3. Authority of law
  4. Act of public necessity
  5. Self-defence
  6. Re-entry on land
  7. Re-taking of goods and chattels
  8. Abatement of nuisance
  9. Special property or easement

 Trespass ab-initio

When a person has the authority of the law to enter upon the land of the another but later is guilty of an act such as misfeasance or misconduct making his original entry tortuous. Here he is liable for damages for both entering the land and further misconduct. 

The following conditions must be fulfilled in order to apply the doctrine of trespass ab initio-

  1. The authority must be given by law.
  2. The subsequent act must be misfeasance. 

The Six Carpenters’ Case 1610

In this case, the six carpenters entered an inn by the authority of law and consumed food and had fine but refused to pay. They were held not liable under this doctrine and the court laid down three major principles

  • If a man abuses an authority given to him by law, he becomes a trespasser ab initio.
  • In an action of trespass, if an authority is pleaded, the subsequent abuse of that authority may be removed.
  • A mere non-feasance does not account to such abuse as renders a man a trespasser ab initio

Injury to Reversionary Rights

A reversioner is a person who has a lawful interest in land but not its present possession, e.g. landlord and a reversioner interest is any interest, vested or contingent, the enjoyment of which is postponed. Reversionary interests are injured by either the strangers or by tenants.

Waste 

It is spoil or destruction of houses, gardens, trees or unlawful damage caused to the immovable property by the person who was just given lawful possession of that property. Such damage must be of permanent nature and should cause prejudice to the owner or the reversioner. 

Essentials of waste

  1. An act or omission
  2. Such act/omission must be done by the tenant or anyone in possession 
  3. It must cause prejudice to the owner/reversioner

Damages & Injunction for waste

In a suit against waste, the plaintiff may recover the actual damage caused to the immovable property and can also obtain an injunction on the actions of the wrongdoer of the defendant.

Dispossession

An owner is said to be dispossessed of his immovable property when the defendant does an act which declines the overall dominion of the plaintiff over the property. An owner can also be said to be dispossessed of his property when the defendant acquires settled possession of the land with the intention of acquiring exclusive control over the immovable property of the owner (Sundara Sastrial v. Govinda Mandaroyan, 1908). 

Remedies available to the owner for the dispossession caused

  • To recover possession of the land– action can be brought by the owner of the immovable property against the defendant to recover the possession of the land. In  India, one can file a suit under S.6 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963 for recovering the possession which was dispossessed because of the acts of the defendant within a period of six months. 
  • Jus tertii– the owner can also recover the possession of the immovable property through the doctrine of jus tertii i.e. by showing that the plaintiff has a better right than the defendant to acquire the possession of the property.

Defences available to the defendant in a suit filed by the owner

  • Jus tertii– that the defendant has a better title than the plaintiff
  • That the plaintiff’s title over the immovable property comes to an end as the defendant has held or enjoyed the interest in the immovable property for twelve years or more.
  • The defendant can also plead under S.5 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963 that the plaintiff was not in possession within six months of the date of filing the suit or he himself was dispossessed in due course of law. 

Wrongs to Natural Rights and Easements

An easement right is a non-possessory right to use the property of others without having the possession of such property. When any such right is infringed or interfered by any stranger or owner of that property then that amounts to tort and is actionable. 

Remedies available for infringing the right of easement

  1. Damages to compensate for the injury or the loss
  2. The injunction obtained from the court to prevent such repetition. 

There are certain natural rights which are attached to every land and are necessary for the peaceful enjoyment of the immovable property. One can enjoy his property in any way he wants but cannot infringe the legal rights of the other by making such use of his property. Such natural rights are:-

  1. Right to support 
  2. Right to water
  3. Right to light
  4. Right to air
  5. Right of way
  6. Right of privacy
  7. Right of prospect
  8. Right of common
  9. Profits-a-Prendre  

Right to support

This right can be divided into three categories:

  • Right to support land by land – each and every part of the land has a natural right to be supported by the adjacent or subjacent land. A right to be supported by an adjacent land is known as the right to lateral support and a right of support by the subjacent land is known as the vertical support. Every owner of a property is entitled to a right of lateral support to the extent it is necessary to sustain his own land in a natural land. 
  • Right to support of buildings by land- if the land is not expressly granted for building purposes but is weighted with buildings then the surface owner has no right to additional support which is necessary for the maintenance of buildings. Support of buildings by land may be either:
  1. Laterally by adjacent soil
  2. Vertically by subjacent soil
  • Right to support buildings by buildings– this right is not a natural right but can be acquired by either grant or prescription or when both the buildings are owned by one person. Damage is necessary to give the right of action to the person.  

Right to water

The right to water of a person having possession of the immovable property can be infringed by any of the following ways-

  1. Wrongful obstruction of water
  2. Wrongful pollution of water
  3. Wrongful obstruction by a stream 

Right to light

An owner of a house is entitled to sufficient light as may be necessary for the enjoyment of his house. In order to bring an action against a person, it must be proved that he has caused substantial deprivation of light to the house of the plaintiff. The rule of 45 degrees is usually applied here by the courts. According to this rule when the height of the wall of obstruction which is built opposite to the ancient lights (house of the plaintiff) is not greater than the distance between it and the ancient lights then in the eyes of law no such right is infringed. 

Right to air

The right to air is an easement and in order to file a suit against the defendant for obstruction of air, the plaintiff must show that there is some danger to his health. Such right is not violated until the obstruction is such that it is obstructing more air than needed for the ordinary purpose.

Right of way

A right of way is not a natural right but it can be acquired by-

  1. Grant
  2. Prescription
  3. Immemorial custom
  4. Necessity. 

Right of privacy

Right to privacy is not an inherent right as right to light and right to air. English law does not even recognize such right but in India, under Article 21 of the Constitution of India, Right to privacy is recognized as the fundamental right of each and every citizen of India. 

Right of prospect 

In India, the law does not recognize a view or prospect from a house as an easement right. No period of enjoyment over an immovable property will give a person right of action against another who on his land erects a structure or plants trees which obstruct the view or prospect of the other. Where obstruction does not affect the right of access or any other damage to his building or business; it was held that the suit was not maintainable (Gopalkrishna v. Narsimham, 1958). 

Right of common

A right of taking some natural part of the produce of land belonging to another by the person who is not the owner of that land such as right to pasture or right to fish. Any infringement or disturbance of such right is an actionable wrong. 

Profits-a-Prendre 

The right to take some part of the soil or some part of the natural produce or animals existing upon it from the servient tenement by another is referred to as the Profits-a-Pendre. In India, such right is categorized into the following categories-

  1. Right of common
  2. Right of ferry
  3. Right of market 

Nuisance

Nuisance is broadly categorized into two categories:-

  1. Public Nuisance– it is an act or omission which causes any common injury, danger or annoyance to the public or to the people in general who dwell or occupy the property. To make nuisance an actionable tort one must satisfy the following two essentials-
  •  Wrongful act
  • Damage or loss or inconvenience or annoyance caused by such act to another.
  1. Private Nuisance– it is unauthorized use of one’s own property causing damage to the property of another or some unauthorized interference with the property or the propriety rights of another.  

Remedies available to the plaintiff

  • Abatement- it means the removal of a nuisance by the party injured or the plaintiff. The removal must be peaceful and without danger to the limb and if it is necessary to enter another’s land or property prior notice should be given to that person.
  • Damages– it is to be noticed that every day the nuisance continues, a fresh cause of action arises for which future damages may be recovered. If the injury is caused to the neighbour while a person is making use of his property is such way then he is eligible to damages from that person for the injury caused.
  • Injunction– in order to obtain an injunction from a court it must be shown by the person that the injury caused cannot be measured in terms of damages or cannot be compensated through damages. 

Defences available to an action for nuisance

  • Grant- it is a valid defence to an action for the nuisance that the said nuisance is under the terms of the grant.
  • Prescription– the right to continue private nuisance may be acquired as an easement of prescription if it has been peacefully and openly enjoyed as an easement or as a right without interruption for 20 years. 
  • Statutory Authority– when the statute has authorized doing a particular act or the use of land in a reasonable way provided that reasonable precaution has been taken in exercising such statutory authority. 

Conclusion 

Torts relating to the immovable property has been categorized into different categories and all of them are dealt in different ways. Some of them are interrelated to each other and therefore they are needed to be read together with such as trespass and nuisance. Each of the tort mentioned above has defences and therefore the defendant can avoid the suit if he falls under those defences. Though the remedies and defences given under every tort are given considering that no party is prejudiced by the act of another. 

The post Torts relating to immovable property appeared first on iPleaders.

Interpretation of Statutes and its Rules

$
0
0

This article has been written by Pooja Kapur, a fifth-year law student of Amity Law School, Noida. She has discussed the meaning and rules of interpretation of statutes with relevant case laws.

Interpretation meaning

The term has been derived from the Latin term ‘interpretari’, which means to explain, expound, understand, or to translate. Interpretation is the process of explaining, expounding and translating any text or anything in written form. This basically involves an act of discovering the true meaning of the language which has been used in the statute. Various sources used are only limited to explore the written text and clarify what exactly has been indicated by the words used in the written text or the statutes.

Interpretation of statutes is the correct understanding of the law. This process is commonly adopted by the courts for determining the exact intention of the legislature. Because the objective of the court is not only merely to read the law but is also to apply it in a meaningful manner to suit from case to case. It is also used for ascertaining the actual connotation of any Act or document with the actual intention of the legislature.

There can be mischief in the statute which is required to be cured, and this can be done by applying various norms and theories of interpretation which might go against the literal meaning at times. The purpose behind interpretation is to clarify the meaning of the words used in the statutes which might not be that clear.

According to Salmond,Interpretation”  is the process by which the court seeks to ascertain the meaning of the legislature through the medium of authoritative forms in which it is expressed.

https://lawsikho.com/course/diploma-entrepreneurship-administration-business-laws

Click Here

Construction meaning

In simple words, construction is the process of drawing conclusions of the subjects which are beyond the direct expression of the text. The courts draw findings after analysing the meaning of the words used in the text or the statutes. This process is known as legal exposition. There are a certain set of facts pending before the court and construction is the application of the conclusion of these facts.

The objective is to assist the judicial body in determining the real intention of the legislature. Its aim is also to ascertain the legal effect of the legal text.

Difference between Interpretation and Construction

 

Interpretation

Construction

  1. In law, interpretation refers to exposing the true sense of the provisions of the statutes and to understand the exact meaning of the words used in any text.
  2. Interpretation refers to the linguistic meaning of the legal text.
  3. In the case where the simple meaning of the text is to be adopted then the concept of interpretation is being referred to.
  1. Construction, on the other hand, refers to drawing conclusions from the written texts which are beyond the outright expression of the legal text.
  2. The purpose of construction is to determine the legal effect of words and the written text of the statute.
  3. In the case where the literal meaning of the legal text results in ambiguity then the concept of construction is adopted.

 

Classification of Statutes

Codified statutory law can be categorized as follows-

Codifying statutes

The purpose of this kind of statute is to give an authoritative statement of the rules of the law on a particular subject, which is customary laws. For example- The Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 and The Hindu Succession Act, 1956.

Consolidating statutes

This kind of statute covers and combines all law on a particular subject at one place which was scattered and lying at different places. Here, the entire law is constituted in one place. For example- Indian Penal Code or Code of Criminal Procedure.

Declaratory statutes

This kind of statute does an act of removing doubts, clarifying and improving the law based on the interpretation given by the court, which might not be suitable from the point of view of the parliament. For example- the definition of house property has been amended under the Income Tax (Amendment) Act, 1985 through the judgement of the supreme court.

Remedial statutes

Granting of new remedies for enforcing one’s rights can be done through the remedial statutes. The purpose of these kinds of statutes is to promote the general welfare for bringing social reforms through the system. These statutes have liberal interpretation and thus, are not interpreted through strict means. For example- The Maternity Benefits Act, 1961, The Workmen’s Compensation Act, 1923 etc.

Enabling statutes

The purpose of this statute is to enlarge a particular common law. For example- Land Acquisition Act enables the government to acquire the public property for the purpose of the public, which is otherwise not permissible.

Disabling statutes

It is the opposite of what is provided under the enabling statute. Here the rights conferred by common law are being cut down and are being restrained.

Penal statutes

The offences for various types of offences are provided through these statutes, and these provisions have to be imposed strictly. For example- Indian Penal Code, 1860.

Taxing statutes

Tax is a form of revenue which is to be paid to the government. It can either be on income that an individual earns or on any other transaction. A taxing statute thus, levies taxes on all such transactions. There can be income tax, wealth tax, sales tax, gift tax, etc. Therefore, a tax can be levied only when it has been specifically expressed and provided by any statute.

Explanatory statutes

The term explanatory itself indicates that this type of statute explains the law and rectifies any omission left earlier in the enactment of the statutes. Further, ambiguities in the text are also clarified and checked upon the previous statutes.

Amending statutes

The statutes which operate to make changes in the provisions of the enactment to change the original law for making an improvement therein and for carrying out the provisions effectively for which the original law was passed are referred to as amending statutes. For example- Code of Criminal Procedure 1973 amended the code of 1898.

Repealing statutes

A repealing statute is one which terminates an earlier statute and may be done in the express or explicit language of the statute. For example- Competition Act, 2002 repealed the MRTP Act.

Curative or repealing statutes

Through these statutes, certain acts which would otherwise be illegal are validated by curing the illegality and enables a particular line of action.

Rules of Interpretation

Literal or Grammatical Rule

It is the first rule of interpretation. According to this rule, the words used in this text are to be given or interpreted in their natural or ordinary meaning. After the interpretation, if the meaning is completely clear and unambiguous then the effect shall be given to a provision of a statute regardless of what may be the consequences.

The basic rule is that whatever the intention legislature had while making any provision it has been expressed through words and thus, are to be interpreted according to the rules of grammar. It is the safest rule of interpretation of statutes because the intention of the legislature is deduced from the words and the language used.

According to this rule, the only duty of the court is to give effect if the language of the statute is plain and has no business to look into the consequences which might arise. The only obligation of the court is to expound the law as it is and if any harsh consequences arise then the remedy for it shall be sought and looked out by the legislature.

Case Laws

Maqbool Hussain v. State of Bombay,  In this case, the appellant, a citizen of India after arriving at the airport did not declare that he was carrying gold with him. During his search was carried on, gold was found in his possession as it was against the notification of the government and was confiscated under section 167(8) of Sea Customs Act.  

Later on, he was also charged under section 8 of the Foreign Exchange Regulations Act, 1947.  The appellant challenged this trial to be violative under Article 20(2) of the Indian Constitution. According to this article, no person shall be punished or prosecuted more than once for the same offence. This is considered as double jeopardy.

It was held by the court that the Seas Act neither a court nor any judicial tribunal. Thus, accordingly, he was not prosecuted earlier. Hence, his trial was held to be valid.

Manmohan Das versus Bishan Das, AIR 1967 SC 643

The issue in the case was regarding the interpretation of section 3(1)(c) of U.P Control of Rent and Eviction Act, 1947. In this case, a tenant was liable for evidence if he has made addition and alternate in the building without proper authority and unauthorized perception as materially altered the accommodation or is likely to diminish its value.  The appellant stated that only the constitution can be covered, which diminishes the value of the property and the word ‘or’ should be read as land.

It was held that as per the rule of literal interpretation, the word ‘or’ should be given the meaning that a prudent man understands the grounds of the event are alternative and not combined.

State of Kerala v. Mathai Verghese and others, 1987 AIR 33 SCR(1) 317, in this case a person was caught along with the counterfeit currency “dollars” and he was charged under section 120B, 498A, 498C and 420  read with section 511 and 34 of Indian Penal Code for possessing counterfeit currency. The accused contended before the court that a charge under section 498A and 498B of Indian Penal Code can only be levied in the case of counterfeiting of Indian currency notes and not in the case of counterfeiting of foreign currency notes. The court held that the word currency notes or bank note cannot be prefixed. The person was held liable to be charge-sheeted.

The Mischief Rule

Mischief Rule was originated in Heydon’s case in 1584. It is the rule of purposive construction because the purpose of this statute is most important while applying this rule. It is known as Heydon’s rule because it was given by Lord Poke in Heydon’s case in 1584. It is called as mischief rule because the focus is on curing the mischief.

In the Heydon’s case, it was held that there are four things which have to be followed for true and sure interpretation of all the statutes in general, which are as follows-

  1. What was the common law before the making of an act.
  2. What was the mischief for which the present statute was enacted.
  3. What remedy did the Parliament sought or had resolved and appointed to cure the disease of the commonwealth.
  4. The true reason of the remedy.

The purpose of this rule is to suppress the mischief and advance the remedy.

Case laws

Smith v. Huges, 1960 WLR 830, in this case around the 1960s, the prostitutes were soliciting in the streets of London and it was creating a huge problem in London. This was causing a great problem in maintaining law and order. To prevent this problem, Street Offences Act, 1959 was enacted. After the enactment of this act, the prostitutes started soliciting from windows and balconies.

Further, the prostitutes who were carrying on to solicit from the streets and balconies were charged under section 1(1) of the said Act. But the prostitutes pleaded that they were not solicited from the streets.

The court held that although they were not soliciting from the streets yet the mischief rule must be applied to prevent the soliciting by prostitutes and shall look into this issue. Thus, by applying this rule, the court held that the windows and balconies were taken to be an extension of the word street and charge sheet was held to be correct.

Pyare Lal v. Ram Chandra, the accused in this case, was prosecuted for selling the sweeten supari which was sweetened with the help of an artificial sweetener. He was prosecuted under the Food Adulteration Act. It was contended by Pyare Lal that supari is not a food item. The court held that the dictionary meaning is not always the correct meaning, thereby, the mischief rule must be applicable, and the interpretation which advances the remedy shall be taken into consideration. Therefore, the court held that the word ‘food’ is consumable by mouth and orally. Thus, his prosecution was held to be valid.

Kanwar Singh v. Delhi Administration, AIR 1965 SC 871.

Issues of the case were as follows- section 418 of Delhi Corporation Act, 1902 authorised the corporation to round up the cattle grazing on the government land. The MCD rounded up the cattle belonging to Kanwar Singh. The words used in the statute authorised the corporation to round up the abandoned cattle. It was contended by Kanwar Singh that the word abandoned means the loss of ownership and those cattle which were round up belonged to him and hence, was not abandoned. The court held that the mischief rule had to be applied and the word abandoned must be interpreted to mean let loose or left unattended and even the temporary loss of ownership would be covered as abandoned.

Regional Provident Fund Commissioner v. Sri Krishna Manufacturing Company, AIR 1962 SC 1526, Issue, in this Case, was that the respondent concerned was running a factory where four units were for manufacturing. Out of these four units one was for paddy mill, other three consisted of flour mill, saw mill and copper sheet units. The number of employees there were more than 50. The RPFC applied the provisions of Employees Provident Fund Act, 1952 thereby directing the factory to give the benefits to the employees.

The person concerned segregated the entire factory into four separate units wherein the number of employees had fallen below 50, and he argued that the provisions were not applicable to him because the number is more than 50 in each unit. It was held by the court that the mischief rule has to be applied and all the four units must be taken to be one industry, and therefore, the applicability of PFA was upheld.

The Golden Rule

It is known as the golden rule because it solves all the problems of interpretation. The rule says that to start with we shall go by the literal rule, however, if the interpretation given through the literal rule leads to some or any kind of ambiguity, injustice, inconvenience, hardship, inequity, then in all such events the literal meaning shall be discarded and interpretation shall be done in such a manner that the purpose of the legislation is fulfilled.

The literal rule follows the concept of interpreting the natural meaning of the words used in the statute. But if interpreting natural meaning leads to any sought of repugnance, absurdity or hardship, then the court must modify the meaning to the extent of injustice or absurdity caused and no further to prevent the consequence.

This rule suggests that the consequences and effects of interpretation deserve a lot more important because they are the clues of the true meaning of the words used by the legislature and its intention. At times, while applying this rule, the interpretation done may entirely be opposite of the literal rule, but it shall be justified because of the golden rule.  The presumption here is that the legislature does not intend certain objects. Thus, any such interpretation which leads to unintended objects shall be rejected.

Case laws

Tirath Singh v. Bachittar Singh, AIR 1955 SC 850

In this case, there was an issue with regard to issuing of the notice under section 99 of Representation of People’s Act, 1951, with regard to corrupt practices involved in the election.

According to the rule, the notice shall be issued to all those persons who are a party to the election petition and at the same time to those who are not a party to it. Tirath Singh contended that no such notice was issued to him under the said provision. The notices were only issued to those who were non-parties to the election petition. This was challenged to be invalid on this particular ground.

The court held that what is contemplated is giving of the information and the information even if it is given twice remains the same. The party to the petition is already having the notice regarding the petition, therefore, section 99 shall be so interpreted by applying the golden rule that notice is required against non-parties only.

State of Madhya Pradesh v. Azad Bharat Financial Company, AIR 1967 SC 276, Issues of the case are as follows.

A transporting company was carrying a parcel of apples was challenged and charge-sheeted. The truck of the transporting company was impounded as the parcel contained opium along with the apples. At the same time, the invoice shown for the transport consisted of apples only.

Section 11 of the opium act 1878, all the vehicles which transport the contraband articles shall be impounded and articles shall be confiscated. It was confiscated by the transport company that they were unaware of the fact that opium was loaded along with the apples in the truck.

The court held that although the words contained in section 11 of the said act provided that the vehicle shall be confiscated but by applying the literal rule of interpretation for this provision it is leading to injustice and inequity and therefore, this interpretation shall be avoided. The words ‘shall be confiscated’ should be interpreted as ‘may be confiscated’.

State of Punjab v. Quiser Jehan Begum, AIR 1963 SC 1604, a period of limitation was prescribed for, under section 18 of land acquisition act, 1844, that an appeal shall be filed for the announcement of the award within 6 months of the announcement of the compensation. Award was passed in the name of Quiser Jehan. It was intimated to her after the period of six months about this by her counsel. The appeal was filed beyond the period of six months. The appeal was rejected by the lower courts.

It was held by the court that the period of six months shall be counted from the time when Quiser Jehan had the knowledge because the interpretation was leading to absurdity. The court by applying the golden rule allowed the appeal.

Harmonious Construction

According to this rule of interpretation, when two or more provisions of the same statute are repugnant to each other, then in such a situation the court, if possible, will try to construe the provisions in such a manner as to give effect to both the provisions by maintaining harmony between the two. The question that the two provisions of the same statute are overlapping or mutually exclusive may be difficult to determine.

The legislature clarifies its intention through the words used in the provision of the statute. So, here the basic principle of harmonious construction is that the legislature could not have tried to contradict itself. In the cases of interpretation of the Constitution, the rule of harmonious construction is applied many times.

It can be assumed that if the legislature has intended to give something by one, it would not intend to take it away with the other hand as both the provisions have been framed by the legislature and absorbed the equal force of law. One provision of the same act cannot make the other provision useless. Thus, in no circumstances, the legislature can be expected to contradict itself.

Cases

Ishwari Khaitan Sugar Mills v. State of Uttar Pradesh,  in this case, the State Government proposed to acquire sugar industries under U.P Sugar Undertakings (Acquisition) Act,  1971. This was challenged on the ground that these sugar industries were declared to be a controlled one by the union under Industries (Development and Regulation) Act, 1951. And accordingly, the state did not have the power of acquisition of requisition of property which was under the control of the union. The Supreme Court held that the power of acquisition was not occupied by Industries (Development and Regulation) Act, 1951. The state had a separate power under Entry 42 List III.

M.S.M Sharma v. Krishna Sinha, AIR 1959 SC 395.

Facts of the case are as follows- Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution provides for freedom of speech and expression. Article 194(3) provides to the Parliament for punishing for its contempt and it is known as the Parliamentary Privilege. In this case, an editor of a newspaper published the word -for- word record of the proceedings of the Parliament including those portions which were expunged from the record. He was called for the breach of parliamentary privilege.

He contended that he had a fundamental right to speech and expression. It was held by the court that article 19(1)(a) itself talks about reasonable freedom and therefore freedom of speech and expression shall pertain only to those portions which have not been expunged on the record but not beyond that.

Conclusion

Every nation has its own judicial system, the purpose of which to grant justice to all. The court aims to interpret the law in such a manner that every citizen is ensured justice to all. To ensure justice to all the concept of canons of interpretation was expounded. These are the rules which are evolved for determining the real intention of the legislature.

It is not necessary that the words used in a statute are always clear, explicit and unambiguous and thus, in such cases it is very essential for courts to determine a clear and explicit meaning of the words or phrases used by the legislature and at the same time remove all the doubts if any. Hence, all the rules mentioned in the article are important for providing justice.

The post Interpretation of Statutes and its Rules appeared first on iPleaders.

A Brief Capsule of a Decree under CPC

$
0
0

This article has been written by Pankhuri Anand, a student of Banasthali Vidyapith, Rajasthan. This article discusses the meaning and types of the decree with illustrations and case laws.

A decree is one of the most frequently heard terms in Civil Matters. The adjudication of a court of law is divided into decree and orders.  In this article, are going to discuss the decree. The term “decree” has been defined under section 2(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure,1908. The decree is a formal expression of adjudication by which the court determines the rights of parties regarding the matter in controversy or dispute.

Essentials elements of a Decree

The decree is a decision of the court. For any decision of the court to be a decree,  the following essential elements are required:

  1. There must be an adjudication.
  2. The adjudication should be done in a suit.
  3. It must determine the rights of parties regarding the matter in dispute.
  4. The determination of the right should be of conclusive nature.
  5. There must be a formal expression of such adjudication.

https://lawsikho.com/course/certificate-course-in-advanced-civil-litigation-practice-procedure-and-drafting

Click Here

Adjudication

For a decision of the court to a decree, there must be an adjudication. The matter in dispute should be judicially determined. As held in the case of Madan Naik v. Hansubala Devi, if the matter is not judicially determined then, it is not a decree.

So, if the decision is of administrative nature then it can not be considered as a decree. Also, any order for dismissal of suit due to default in the appearance of parties or order for dismissal of an appeal cannot be considered as a decree.

As held in the Deep Chand v. Land Acquisition Officer, the adjudication should be made by the officer of the Court and if it is not passed by an officer of the court then it is not a decree.

Suit

For any decision to be considered as a decree, the adjudication must have been done in suit. The term “suit” for this context can be understood as “any civil procedure which has been instituted by the presentation of a plaint”. The decree can only be in a civil suit. If there is no civil suit, there can be no decree.

There are several specific provisions which enable certain applications to be treated as suits such as proceedings under the Hindu Marriage Act, the Indian Succession Act etc. and the decisions therein are to be considered as a decree. To know more about the decree in redemption suit Click Here.

 Rights in controversy

The rights of parties which are in controversy must be determined by a formal adjudication.  The rights determined under this circumstance are substantial rights and not procedural rights. The parties to the rights in controversy should be the plaintiffs and defendants and, if an order is passed upon the application made by a third party who is a stranger to suit then it is not a decree.

The matter in controversy should be the subject matter of the suit regarding which the relief is sought. Any question regarding the status and characters of party suing, the jurisdiction of the court, maintainability of suit or any other preliminary matter is covered under this.

Conclusive determination

The determination of rights in controversy in an adjudication should be conclusive in nature. As held in the case of Narayan Chandra v. Pratirodh Sahini, the determination should be final and conclusive regarding the court which passes it. That’s why an interlocutory order which does not finally determine the rights of parties is not considered as a decree.

The main point to be kept in mind is that whether the decision made is final and conclusive in essence as well as substance. If it is so, then the decision will be considered as a decree, else not.

Formal Expression

The adjudication should be expressed formally and such formal expression should be given in the manner prescribed by law. The decree should be drawn separately and it should follow the judgement. No appeal lies the judgement if the decree is not formally drawn upon the judgement.

Illustrations

After a detailed study of section 2(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure which defines a decree  and then analysing the procedures laid down in civil proceedings and applying the test for a decision to be a decree as laid down in the case of Venkata Reddy v. Pethi Reddy, there are certain instances when decisions of the Court are considered as decree and there are instances when the decisions are not considered as decree as stated below in the following illustrations:

Decisions considered as a decree

The decisions held to be decree are as follows:

  • Order of abetment of suit
  • Dismissal of appeal as time-barred;
  • Dismissal of suit or appeal due to the requirement of evidence or proof;
  • Rejection of plant due to non-payment of court fees;
  • Order granting costs and instalments;
  • An order refusing costs or instalments;
  • An order refusing maintainability of appeal;
  • Order denying the survival of right to sue;
  • Order stating that there is no cause of action;
  • An order refusing to grant one or several reliefs;

Decisions not considered as a decree

The decisions which are not considered as a decree are as follows:

  • Dismissal of appeal for default;
  • Appointment of Commissioner in order to take accounts;
  • Order for remand;
  • Order granting interim relief;
  • An order refusing the grant of interim relief;
  • Rejection of plaint in order to present it to the proper court;
  • Application rejected for condonation of delay;
  • Order holding an application to be maintainable;
  • Order of refusal to set aside the sale;
  • The order issuing directions for the assessment of mesne profit.

Types of Decree

The Code of Civil Procedure recognises the following three types of decrees.

  1. Preliminary Decree
  2. Final decree
  3. A partly preliminary and partly final decree

Preliminary Decree

A decree is stated as a preliminary decree when the rights of parties regarding all or any of the matter in dispute are determined in the adjudication but it does not dispose of the suit completely. The preliminary decree is only a prior stage 

A preliminary decree is passed by the courts mainly when the court has to adjudicate upon the rights of the parties and then, it has put the matter on hold unless the final decree of that suit is passed 

As held in the case of Mool Chand v. Director, Consolidation, a preliminary decree is only a stage to work out the rights of parties until the matter is finally decided by the Court and adjudicated by a final decree.

The Supreme Court in the case of Shankar v. Chandrakant held that the preliminary decree is a decree in which the rights and liabilities of parties are declared but the actual result is left to be decided in further proceedings.

A preliminary decree can be passed by the court in the following suits as provided by the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908

Order 20 Rule 12: Suit for possession and Mesne profit

When there is a suit related to possession of immovable property or for rent or mesne profit then in such cases preliminary decree can be passed.

Order 20 Rule 13: Administration Suits

When a suit is of the nature of administration suit, then a court is empowered to pass a preliminary decree.

Order 20 Rule 14: Suits of pre-emption

When there is a suit for claiming pre-emption regarding sale or purchase of a particular property then the court can pass a preliminary decree.

Order 20 Rule 15: Suit filed for dissolution of a partnership

When there is a suit for dissolution of the partnership or for the partnership account to be taken, then the court may pass a preliminary decree.

Order 20 Rule 16: Suits related to accounts between the principal and agent

In a suit related to the pecuniary transaction between the principal and agent or any other matter, if required, the court may pass a preliminary decree.

Order 20 Rule 18: Suit for partition and separate possession

When the suit is related to partition or for separate possession of share then the court may pass a preliminary decree.

Order 34 Rule 2: Suits related to the foreclosure of a mortgage

When there is a suit related to the foreclosure of mortgage then under Rule 2 of Order 34, a court is empowered to pass a preliminary decree.

Order 34 Rule 4: Suits related to the sale of the mortgaged property

In suits related to the sale of the mortgaged property, the court is empowered under Rule 4 of order 34 to pass a preliminary decree.

Order 34 Rule 7: Suits for the redemption of a mortgage

When a suit is filed before the court regarding the matter of redemption of the mortgaged property, the court is empowered under Rule 7 of Order 34 to pass a preliminary decree.

Civil Procedure code
Image Source: https://bit.ly/2Xw13xl

Can there be more than one preliminary decree?

There is a conflict of opinion regarding this question that whether there can be more than one preliminary decree in the same suit or not. Some High Courts are of the view that there can be more than one preliminary decree while some of the High Courts are against this view.

The Supreme Court in the case of Phoolchand v. Gopal Lal, held that nothing in the Code of Civil Procedure prohibits passing of more than one preliminary decree if the circumstance requires or if required by the Court. But, it should be noted that this decision was given by the Court regarding partition suits.

Final Decree

The final decree is a decree which disposes of a suit completely and settles all the matter in dispute between the parties. The final decree does not leave any matter to be decided further.

It is considered as a final decree in the following ways.

  1. When no appeal is filed against the decree within a prescribed time period.
  2. Matter in the decree has been decided by the highest court.
  3. When the decree passed by the court disposes of the suit completely.

Can there be more than one final decree?

Ordinarily, in one suit there is one preliminary and one final decree.  In the case of Gulusam Bivi v. Ahamadasa Rowther, the Madras High Court in the light of Order 20 Rule 12 and 18 stated that the code nowhere contemplates more than one preliminary or final decree. 

In the case of Shankar v. Chandrakant, the Supreme Court finally settled the conflict of opinion and stated that more than one final decree can be passed.

Partly preliminary and partly final decree

A decree passed under the Code of Civil Procedure may be partly preliminary and partly final. This happens some part of the decree is preliminary decree while the rest is a final decree.

Illustrations

If there is a suit of possession of an immovable property along with the issue of mesne profit, and the court is obliged.

  1. Passes a decree deciding the possession of the property.
  2. Directs for an enquiry of mesne profit.

The first part deciding the possession of the property is final while the part regarding the mesne profit is preliminary.

Deemed decree

An adjudication which does not formally fall under the definition of decree stated under section 2(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure but due to a legal fiction, they are deemed to be decrees are considered as deemed decrees.

Rejection of plaint and determination of the issue of restitution of decree are deemed decree. Also, an adjudication under order 21 Rule 58, Rule 98 and Rule 100 are also deemed decrees.

Distinctions

Order and Decree

S. No.

Decree

Order 

1.

The decree is passed only in a suit which is commenced by the presentation of the plaint. 

An order can be passed in a suit instituted on plaint as well as from a proceeding commenced on a petition application.

2.

Decree determines the right of parties in dispute conclusively.

An order may or may not finally and conclusively determine such rights.

3.

A decree can be preliminary or final.

An order cannot be preliminary.

4.

In a suit, there can be only one decree except for the suits where a preliminary and final decree is passed.

A number of orders can be passed in a suit or proceeding.

5.

Every decree is appealable unless expressly provided.

Only the orders specified in this code are appealable.

6.

The second appeal lies to the High Court against the first appeal of a decree.

There is no provision of the second appeal in case of appealable orders,

 

Judgement and Decree

S.No.

Judgement

Decree

1.

Judgement is the statement of the judge on the ground of a decree or an order.

For decree, a statement of the ground is not required to be given by the judge.

2.

The judgement does not require to have a formal expression.

A decree must be a formal expression.

3

The relief granted is required to be stated preciously in the Judgement.

A decree determines the rights in dispute between the parties.

4.

A judgement is passed in a stage prior to passing a decree.

A decree is passed after issuing the judgement.

5.

Judgement is pronounced in civil as well as criminal matters.

A decree can be passed only in a civil suit.

 

Conclusion

The Code of Civil Procedure lays down provisions to pronounce and issue the decision of the Court and decree is one of them. A decree in the decision of a court which determines the rights in dispute between the parties to suit. A decree can be preliminary, final or partly preliminary and partly final. There is also a concept of the deemed decree. A decree is different from order and judgement in many ways.

For the execution of decree Order XXI of the Code lays down the provisions and procedure. A decree is appealable and even second appeal lies to High Court after the first appeal of a decree. A decree is passed only in civil suits and not in criminal matters.

References

  1. Takawani, C.K. Civil Procedure, 8th Edition, (Reprint) 2018, Eastern Book Company.
  2. The Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.

The post A Brief Capsule of a Decree under CPC appeared first on iPleaders.

The Hub and Spoke Conspiracy in Competition Law

$
0
0

This article is written by Suryansh Verma, a 3rd-year student at Dr Ram Manohar Lohiya National Law University, Lucknow. In this article, he throws light on the Hub and Spoke Conspiracies that conspire between firms in the respective competitive markets in the form of cartels. He has also referred to case laws concerned with the same. 

Introduction

The Hub and Spoke model is a doctrine of the US Antitrust law in cases of Competition Law and Criminal Law. In antitrust law, it is a cartel in which a firm colludes amongst the upstream firms or the downstream firms through vertical restraints.

There are no definitions of the concept in European Law as well.

However, the US Court of Appeals for the First Circuit explained the basic concept behind this conspiracy. In such a conspiracy, there is a central mastermind which controls several spokes or co-conspirators. The co-conspirators usually participate in certain transactions with the individual or a group of individuals at the “Hub”. Such an agreement collectively furthers a single, illegal enterprise for achieving a specific object.

For example – There are three companies A, B, and C dealing in pharmaceuticals. B, in this case, will be used as the hub by A to implement a price increase. This will be done if C does the same. B will communicate to C, A’s intention to increase its prices. C will confirm this to B that it will be following A’s intention to increase the price. Finally, B will pass on C’s confirmation to A. B’s function is that of a hatch between the parties to the cartel.

https://lawsikho.com/course/diploma-m-a-institutional-finance-investment-laws

Click Above

Elements of the Hub and Spoke conspiracy 

The Hub and Spoke Conspiracy is said to have four elements i.e. –

  • The Hub, which is the dominant purchaser.
  • The Spokes, which are the competitors in the market which enter into vertical agreements with the hub.
  • The Rim, which connects the hubs and spokes resulting in horizontal agreements between the two.
  • Vertical restraints which connect the hub and the spokes.

What does The Hub do?

The hub is the facilitator and enforcer of the collusion between the spokes. The hub is basically, an upstream supplier or a downstream customer that facilitates cartelization. Not all, but some of the cartel functions are centralized at the hub. A hub functions by the vertical or horizontal relationships with its spokes. The hub is the key player in coordinating the collusive scheme.

It is often the Hub that has an object to achieve by way of the hub and spoke collusion. The hub helps in achieving a mutual understanding between the Spokes. 

A hub can reprimand the spokes if they do not comply with its policies. This, in turn, makes the enforcement of hub and spokes arrangement quite efficient. The hub performs its own monitoring of the collusion, collects reports from the spokes and worked accordingly with the non-compliant spokes. The hub also needs to convince each Spoke that the other Spokes are participating in the collusion.

How do the Spokes function?

The firms or the colluding competitors which are at the end of the rims are the Spokes. The Rim is the horizontal or the vertical agreement between the Hub and the Spokes. For a hub and spoke cartel, the existence of a Rim is of paramount importance. Without the rim, the cartel is just an arrangement of vertical relationships between the Spokes. The Spokes usually function via the Hubs. They convey their messages to the Hub which further conveys it to the other spokes in the collusion.

The requirement of Rim

In the hub and spoke cartels, the rim is very pertinent. Without, the rim, the hub and spoke cartel cannot exist. The alleged hub and spoke cartel, is just a set of vertical relationships which result in parallel conduct and do not establish a horizontal conspiracy.

For proving a hub and spoke conspiracy, there needs to be evidence that there is a rim which connects the spokes.

It has been held in various judgments of the US Supreme Court that rimless wheel theories do not establish the existence of an antitrust violation.

Cartels are facilitated through vertical relationships

Less use of horizontal coordination 

Hub and Spoke cartels collude with either upstream firms or the downstream ones. Cartels make use of various mechanisms to collude such as using third parties to indulge in collusive activities. The hub enforces the cartel by using its vertical relationship with the spokes. This, in turn, reduces the need for horizontal coordination. The enforcement of these cartels is effective because the hub can reprimand the spokes in cases of non-compliance.

Ambiguity

Practices such as certain geographic restraints, exclusivity clauses or the Most Favoured Nation Clause divide the territory among competitors. Such arrangements may generate both, competitive or anti-competitive effects. The proof of a set of vertical relationships which give rise to parallel conduct cannot be conclusive proof of an antitrust violation. 

This creates ambiguity in identifying such cartels. There needs to be proof that such an action will hinder the competitors from taking any independent action. There is rarely any proof of direct communication among the colluders. 

The courts, however, take into account the set of vertical relationships that would have facilitated the horizontal relationships. The vertical relationships are very much ambiguous as there is no standard proof of existence. The courts take into account other necessary factors as well for proving the existence of a cartel. To know more about cartels Click Here.

Why the Hub and Spoke Cartels are Less Effective?

 Collusion between competitors requires a mutual understanding between them and also direct contact between them. In a hub and spoke cartel, this mutual understanding is achieved by indirect communication through the Hub.

Comparing direct communication with indirect communication, hub and spoke cartels are less effective.

The first reason being the indirect communication between the competitors. The messages between the spokes lose information whilst going through the hub. Collusion requires each and every competitor to achieve the trust of other cartel members. This would, in turn, help them to take the cartel members in confidence and also that they will abide by the collusive outcome.

While making direct communication with the competitors, this trust can be gained not only by words but also by the facial expressions, body language, etc. In the hub and spoke cartels, indirect communication does away with all of these.

In addition to this, the hub may sometimes forget to convey the message said by a spoke or insert something else which the spoke did not say. Summing it all up, the messages conveyed by a hub are less informative which makes it difficult to coordinate on a collusive arrangement.

Secondly, the hub can intentionally contort the messages or control the communication between the spokes in any way. The hub cannot be presumed to be a neutral Third Party. The Hub might have a different objective when compared to the Spokes. Even though the Hub and Spokes all want collusion to exist, the desired collusion might differ between them. It is totally possible that even in direct communication some firms may try to mislead the others by convoluting the material facts.

Some illustrative cases

 The article shall encompass the nine landmark cases on Hub and Spoke Cartels –

Interstate Circuit, Inc., et al v. the United States

The case is concerned with the propagation of movies. The market consisted of first-run theatres where the movies which were released were shown first. The market also consisted of second-run theatres where the movie was shown a little later at a lower price. There were two chains which dominated this whole arena. They were – the Interstate Circuit and the Texas Consolidated. The Interstate Circuit exercised a monopoly over forty-three theatres whereas the Texas Consolidated did on sixty-six theatres.

The first run theatres were showing a movie for a price of 40 cents, whereas the same movie was shown by the subsequent theatres showed two films sometimes at an extremely low price.

In 17 out of 18 subsequent-run theatres, the price of the ticket was even less than twenty-five cents. In the majority of those, the price was fifteen cents.

The tough competition forced Interstate to coordinate with the movie distributors in order to control the subsequent-run theatres. The manager of Interstate started to engage in communications with the branch managers of the eight distributors.

The plan was that the subsequent-run theatres should not charge less than twenty-five cents per ticket. The same was conveyed to the movie distributors. This arrangement would accrue benefit to Interstate. This plan would raise the price of the ticket and lower the quality of experience provided by the other theatres. 

For this scheme, Interstate would need to inform each and every movie distributor about such a scheme. A letter was sent by the manager to the 8 distributors. This letter had the contents related to the scheme. After the letter, meetings were conducted between the manager and each of the distributors bilaterally.

The Supreme Court of the US considered this letter as instrumental in achieving the understanding between the distributors. The Court was of the view that even though there was a lack of direct communication between the movie distributors, there was a mutual understanding between them. All the distributors had given their adherence to the scheme.

The Court apparently found this conduct to be illegal as the arrangement went ahead of a vertical contract between one upstream firm and one downstream firm. The downstream firm achieved collusion by way of upstream firms. In this, the downstream firm i.e. Interstate was the Hub whereas the movie distributors were the Spokes. They were told that the other distributors were complying as well.

In re Toys “R” Us, 126 F.T.C. 415

In the 1900s, the dominant toy retailer in the U.S. market was Toys “R” Us (20% market share). There were certain upstream firms such as Mattel, Hasbro, Tyco and Little Tikes with 18%, 17%, 3.2% and 2.8% market shares respectively. Toys “R” Us was one of the most important customers of the upstream firms.

There existed warehouse clubs which sold at a lower rate as compared to Toys “R” Us(hereinafter referred to as TRU). The divisions of Walmart, K-mart, etc. These clubs sold lesser toys as compared to TRU. They also worked with the manufacturers to get some specially-packaged products which were sold at a higher price. However, the value of the unit was very less which created a huge margin of profit.

The clubs used to sell the toys at a price lower than that of TRU. TRU was no more the lower price seller. There was an alternative of cutting down on the prices of the toys but it would have ultimately led to stiff competition amongst the clubs. Moreover, it would also affect the profits of TRU.

The other way was by colluding with the toy manufacturers and limit the supply of toys to the clubs. The strategy adopted by TRU was pretty simple. It involved the exclusion of the rival firms by curbing down the variety of products being offered to them.

The toy manufacturers were sceptical about this arrangement. A toy manufacturer was willing to comply only if other manufacturers were willing to do so. Also, this collusive scheme would also be executable only when all the manufacturers were bought into it. Manufacturers such as Mattel, Hasbro and others wanted to know the reaction of their competitors with regards to the action of TRU.

All of them wanted to be assured that they are being treated the same as other competitors. TRU indulged into bilateral meetings with each of the toy manufacturers. TRU went to each of these manufacturers and communicated to them about the compliance by other manufacturers. TRU used the acceptance given by one toy manufacturer to bring others on board.

TRU did this for over a period of 12 months and surpassed many obstacles in the way. In this case, also, TRU was the Hub being the downstream supplier whereas the toy manufacturers were the Spokes. There was always apprehension on the part of the manufacturers of deviation by rival firms. TRU also used to monitor compliance by each and every manufacturer. The manufacturers who did not comply with TRU’s policies were punished for such non-compliance.

TRU had organized a horizontal agreement among the toy manufacturers. The executives at TRU were operating at the centre of the hub and spoke conspiracy. They were hurling commitments at the manufacturers as well. 

This collusive strategy was actually effective in bringing down the sales of the clubs. The sale stats of Hasbro and Mattel to the clubs dropped from a whopping 32.5 million dollars in 1991 to 10.7 million dollars in 1993. This was a considerable drop that too within a period of 2 years.

TRU was successful in achieving the object of the Hub and Spoke conspiracy.

United States v. Parke, Davis & Company, 164 F. Supp. 827 (D.D.C. 1958)

This case is concerned with the manufacturing and selling of pharmaceutical products by Parke, Davis & Company to its retailers and drug wholesalers. Parke Davis used to have a suggested minimum retail price. In 1956, some of the drug shop chains in Washington D.C. began to price the drugs below the SMRP. There was one retailer, especially who was engaged in pricing the drugs below the SMRP at a very low cost.

Parke, Davis decided to refuse the drugs to the retailers who would price them below the SMRP. All the wholesalers and retailers were informed of this policy in July 1956. After this, Parke, Davis stopped the supply of five retailers who were still pricing the drugs below the SMRP. Parke decided to modify the policy by stating that if the retailer advertised a price below SMRP, then only the sales shall be cut off.

After some time, Drug Dart and the other retailers started to advertise lower prices of the drugs. Parke Davis did not refuse to sell to them because of an inquiry pending before the Antitrust Division of the U.S. on a complaint by Drug Dart.

The communications that Parke Davis had with the retailers and the wholesalers were bilateral, or with a single retailer or wholesaler. The Department of Justice held Parke Davis to be in violation of section 1 of the Sherman Act.

As the communications between Parke Davis and the wholesalers/retailers was always one on one, it was able to coordinate a plan through the hub and spoke arrangement. In such an arrangement, Parke Davis acted like the Hub whereas the wholesalers or retailers were the Spokes. The plan was to convince the retailers not to price the drugs below the SMRP.

Department of Justice’s complaint was dismissed by the District Court on the basis of evidence that there was none where Parke, Davis discussed its sales policies with any of the wholesalers or retailers.

The Supreme Court held the conduct of Parke, Davis to be in violation of sections 1 and 3 of the Sherman Act.

The United States v. Apple Inc.

Amazon used to dominate the e-book market back in 2007 by the introduction of Kindle. Amazon used to charge $9.99 for a typical $30 hardcover. Amazon had a 90% share in the e-book market. This is the famous e-book case wherein Apple was launching the iPad in January 2010. The goal of Apple was to stock the iBookstore.

This would help the iPad users in purchasing and downloading them by the time of the launch. For this, Apple had to work out an arrangement with the six big shots of the book publishing department – Hachette, HarperCollins, Penguin, Random House, Macmillan, and Simon & Schuster.

The CEOs of the Big Six used to discuss amongst themselves in meetings matters pertaining to the industry and also Amazon’s pricing policy and joint strategy for raising these prices. The publishing houses had to adopt a unified front to bring about a change in Amazon’s pricing policy.

The Big Six wanted to raise the price of the e-books from $9.99. The objective of Apple was to compete with Amazon and the publishers wanted to reduce the power of Amazon in the market. This made them allies. Amazon used to set the retail price of every e-book i.e. at $9.99 (known as the wholesale model). The director of Apple’s digital content stores, Eddy Cue was in negotiations with the Big Six.

He suggested another wholesale model but with higher prices of the e-books. Two of the big six companies suggested an agency model in which the retail prices would be decided by the publishing companies. And, the revenue would be shared by Apple and the companies. This model was accepted by Apple with some control over deciding the retail prices.

The retail prices suggested by Apple were $9.99, 12.99$ and $14.99. The price of the e-books was dependent on the price of the Hardcover of the same book. These prices would not benefit the publishers if Amazon continued with its price of $9.99.

Thus, Apple adopted a strategy where the publishers would compel Amazon to adopt the agency model. Furthermore, it added a clause to the contracts with publishers wherein if any publisher offered a lower price for the e-book to Amazon, it will do the same for the price at iBookstore. All of this would have done three things i.e.

  • The high prices of e-books will increase the sale of hardcover where the margin of profit is more. 
  • Control over retail prices is going to be profitable for Apple. How? Once the e-book market is well established, Apple could raise the prices of the books. 
  • Apple will be able to enter the market more easily which would weaken Amazon’s position.

This plan of Apple was accepted by the publishers. As you’ve read in the previous case wherein Toys R Us made sure that every other toy manufacturer was complying with the collusive scheme, Apple also made sure that all the competitors i.e. the Big Six were on the same page.

The Department of Justice in the complaint against Apple said that this adoption of the Agency Model will raise the prices of e-books. It takes away the authority from the publishers to set the retail prices.

This, in turn, would result in higher prices of the e-books. The clause added to the contract also ensures that nobody could lower the prices of e-books except for Apple. Amazon was dominant in the e-book market. Both, Apple and the publishing houses wanted to decrease this dominance of Amazon in the market of e-books.

Eddy Cue was the Hub in this arrangement whereas the CEOs of the publishing houses were the Spokes. There was a direct communication between the hub and spokes.

Finally, after a series of negotiations, and collusions between Apple and the Big Six, Amazon finally adopted the Agency Model. This led to the rise in the retail prices of the e-books.

Apple was found guilty of violating section 1 of the Sherman Act by the District Court. Apple also lost when it preferred an appeal before the Court of the Second Circuit which supported the judgment of the District Court. The Supreme Court also denied the petition filed by Apple for Certiorari.

A horizontal price-fixing conspiracy was crafted by Apple in the instant case

The PepsiCo case

This case involved a high-profile hub and spoke conspiracy. Emphasis was laid down on the requirement of the existence of the rim to prove such cartel. In this case, what happened was that Coca Cola entered into vertical agreements with distributors which included loyalty clauses. These clauses forced the distributors to decide between Coca Cola and Pepsi Co. The legal validity of these clauses was challenged by Pepsi Co. wherein the judgment was given in favour of Coca Cola. The Courts of the Second and Fourth Circuit stressed the requirement of the rim.

Similarly, in the Dickson case wherein, certain distribution agreements were disputed. The district courts said that without the rim, an action cannot be taken against the plaintiffs. This contention was rejected by the Court of the Fourth Circuit that even rimless wheel theories can establish a violation of the antitrust conspiracies.

 Conclusion

A hub and spoke cartel is like a wheel. The hub plays the most important role in executing such cartels. In the above-mentioned cases, it has been specified how the hub functions giving directions to the Spokes. And, also how the Spokes convey their messages to other spokes via the Hub. Such cartels are executed for achieving a certain objective. For example, Apple wanted to raise the retail prices of the e-books that is why it colluded with the publishers. Such cartels are easy to crack. Most of the cartels are caught within a minimum period of 3 months (in the Parke Davis Case).

 This short duration shows the rapidity with which such cartels are caught. Such cartels involve the exchange of information in which the firm collects and distributes the information. This type of cartel is a method that firms use frequently to restrain competition in markets.

It is extremely difficult to achieve a mutual understanding by way of Hub and Spoke collusion because of indirect communication. However, once such an understanding is achieved, it becomes very easy to control the market. 

 

The post The Hub and Spoke Conspiracy in Competition Law appeared first on iPleaders.


Litigation is Harder than It should be – Because There is a Tremendous Lack of Resources

$
0
0

This article is written by Ramanuj Mukherjee, CEO, LawSikho

If you want to become a doctor, what will you rely on?

First of all, you will not qualify as a doctor until you have worked for thousands of hours in hospitals, attending to actual patients, assisting doctors saving lives, doing surgeries, trying to figure out what treatment may work against a virulent disease.

Then there is a lot of research happening on new medicines, new methods of treatment, and doctors who are developing new protocols are sharing them through peer reviewed journals. There are scientists who do not practice medicine but just dedicate their careers to coming up with new medicines or methodologies or treatment. There is a lot available for a doctor to keep learning and stay at the cutting edge of medical sciences.

And how is it for lawyers? Let’s take a look.

Law schools fail at giving basic legal education, forget continuous legal education

Compared to that, in case of a lawyer, the first point of failure is the law college (or law school, if you will) itself. Law colleges are mostly scammy places which in 5 years completely fail to produce a lawyer who can actually get any legal work done. Employers are expected to instead recruit these law graduates and train them on the job. Or the graduates are expected to join practice and figure out on their own how to do what.

All they know at the time of graduation are some case laws and sections from statutes in the name of legal education. For example, one may know all the sections of the Contract Act, but does that train them on how to draft a Shareholders Agreement? Law students are expected to read sections after sections of company law but even after they would not know how to draft even a board resolution or Articles of Association, or for that matter how to advice a company executive on related party transactions.

What would I teach law students in a company law course? Here are a few things to start with, as we do in our 50 classes, one year course targeted at teaching 100 practical skills.

Let me share a few:

  • Learn how to comprehensively analyse different business structures and advise clients on which is the best structure for their businesses
  • Learn how to draft the Memorandum and Articles of Association of a Company in stages where the company is going for an investment transaction / conversion / initial public offering 
  • Learn what are the pitfalls or redflags you should take care of while incorporating different types of companies, so to avoid delay and costs
  • Learn how to advise a client on what is the best non profit structure for him and how to use a Section 8 company to the maximum advantage
  • Learn how to start a company law practice and draft opinions
  • Learn how to advise a foreign client on the incorporation of subsidiary company in India
  • Learn how to advise the board of directors of large sized companies about installing corporate governance mechanisms in the company
  • Learn how to efficiently manage the processes before, during and after a board meeting and be able to advise the management during the board meeting
  • Learn how to advise the Chairman on managing the proceedings at Annual General Meetings and how to ensure minimal disruptions by shareholders
  • Learn how to frame internal company policies and set up reporting and escalation mechanisms at group and individual entity levels including where the group is multinational
  • Learn how to implement contract management and litigation management systems in a company which will help in minimising legal risk to a significant extent
  • Learn how to develop induction processes for directors and advise them on their liabilities and responsibilities
  • Learn how to draft CXO employment agreements including severance payments and clawback provisions
  • Learn how to draft comprehensive employee stock option plans and letters of grant
  • Learn how to handle and manage rights issues and private placements in unlisted entities
  • Learn how to strategise, plan and carry out buybacks in unlisted entities

Do you think law schools should teach such skills? If yes, respond to this and let me know.

However, the vast majority of law teachers have no clue about such skills themselves! Which means they are in no position to teach real practical skills to the law students.

So they pretend to teach law students to think like lawyers. They claim that by reading some case laws and sections, the law students are learning to work as lawyers.

Oh yeah sure, you teach law students to think like a lawyer by making them do the tasks that lawyers today are expected to do, and not by making them read 300 judgments delivered by some judges half a century back! If you want a law student to learn to think like a lawyer, please give her the tasks that lawyers face day in and day out, and hand-hold her while she does those things! Give feedback on mistakes and encourage when they get it right.

That’s what we do at LawSikho and it works wonderfully well. If any teacher is interested in learning the method, do get in touch, we are happy to share our learnings.

Finally, most lawyers had quite a bad time in law college during their law degree. They had to mug up a lot, most of which was not at all useful when they graduated and looked for work. They had to struggle a lot to get even basic tasks done in the absence of any systematic training. Hence, they lost faith in legal education altogether and have no intention of engaging in any kind of continuous learning.

This means, they are left alone to figure out their training and development and most lawyers never manage to. The current situation is depressing to say the least.

The question is, how many lawyers who otherwise fail, would have done really well had they got the right kind of training and development opportunity? Do you have any answer to that?

https://lawsikho.com/course/diploma-companies-act-corporate-governance
Click Above

The internship system for lawyers are near farcical

The lack of useful skills of law students could be remedied a bit through long term internships, like the doctors must work in hospitals and health centers as interns for a year or two before they can get their degree.

Lawyers however get no such exposure. In a few colleges, where classes are scarce or happen early in the morning or in the evening, students manage to attend long term internships under some lawyers. Evidently, these colleges have far better placement records and these students tend to do much better than the rest. 

However, there are very few such colleges. Most colleges believe that their classes are infinitely important and try to make sure that students are tied up in classes morning to evening. After sitting in mind numbing useless classes these students are not left in any state to even do any useful self learning. Going to such colleges mean ruining your 5 years.

Most law students therefore get to go for one or maximum 2 internships that are just one month long. One month long internships are of no use, because just as one begins to get adjusted to a workplace, they have to leave. This means no meaningful learning is possible, and the seniors are not at all invested in teaching or involving a law student into any serious work when such person is going to stay in their office for no more than a month or 6 weeks.

Of course, the Bar Council could change this easily by requiring a 12 month or 24 month mandatory internship period, just like CA and CS professionals also have, but can we expect the BCI to do such a thoughtful thing? When has it done anything in the interest of the law students or the legal profession for the last time in history, can anyone remember? 

Books do not address the real issues and publication industry is immature

It may seem strange but the publication industry in the legal world is also seriously skewed. They are interested in producing text books because those sell in volumes, catering to the already dysfunctional legal academia. 

Then, the legal academia is seriously far removed from the practice, writing about things that have little consequence in real life practice. In any case, they have no idea what is happening in practice and their only goal behind producing any literature at all is to get some points in the UGC system so that they can get higher pay grade or at best get to travel to a foreign country for a conference on someone else’s dime.

There are of course some honourable exceptions, but most people will agree that India’s ability to produce legal literature is seriously lamentable. 

Lawyers are busy creatures and do not have the time to put down their learnings and new developments into thoughtful lessons and practice notes suitable for publication. They simply do not have the time, and definitely not any incentive to do so. Many of them would prefer to monopolize the knowledge if that was possible.

Publishers are mute spectators in this scenario. They perhaps know that there is a great scope to create amazing training material and books that will go a long way and help young lawyers to build their career, but because there are no such manuscripts walking through their door, most of them do not take any extra initiative.

So we do not even have the right books that could help a budding lawyer to accelerate his career in litigation!

Yes, it is true that there are amazing opportunities in the legal publication sector, for those who are ready to put in the effort and capital, given the terrible inertia in that market at present. It is totally waiting to be disrupted.

So what do we do?

This is the backdrop of the rise of LawSikho. We work with lawyers who are at the cutting edge of practice to discover legal insights and processes, and build exactly the kind of literature, training process and templates you need to cut the process of learning by several years. 

Imagine, it takes a law graduate years of toiling in a seniors chamber to learn enough to make a successful career in litigation. It is so hard because of all the reasons we discussed above. What if there was a solution that addressed this exact problem?

Oh yes, there is. That’s what we work on, all the time, for the last 8 years.

Would you like to benefit from our 8 years of work that can speed up your career in litigation and save years that would have gone into unsystematic, haphazard learning by trial and error?

We promise you, if it would otherwise take you 3 years to learn, we will ensure that in our LawSikho courses, provided you put in the time and effort, you learn those things in just a year. Imagine the rocket fuel this can add to your career. We are so confident that we have a 30-45 days refund policy.

Check out Litigation Library by LawSikho if you are a litigator, and your career will not be the same again. You can try it out risk free for a period of a month, and get a full refund if you do not like it. There are just a few seats left, and we are closing it by the end of this month, so hurry up if it is relevant to you.

Also, check out the courses that are closing for admission in the next few days:

Diploma

Diploma in Companies Act, Corporate Governance and SEBI Regulations 

Executive Certificate Courses

Certificate Course in Arbitration: Strategy, Procedure and Drafting

Certificate Course in Real Estate Law

The post Litigation is Harder than It should be – Because There is a Tremendous Lack of Resources appeared first on iPleaders.

Corporate Veil: All you should know!

$
0
0

This article is written by Dhruv Bhardwaj, a student of Amity Law School, Delhi. In this article, he has discussed the concept of Corporate Veil under the Companies Act, 2013, the need for introducing this concept and circumstances under which the Corporate Veil can be lifted.

Introduction

Once a business is incorporated according to the provisions laid out in the Companies Act of 2013, it becomes a separate legal entity. An incorporated company, unlike a partnership firm, which has no identity of its own, has a separate legal identity of its own which is independent of its shareholders and its members. This article will go over what this differentiation means, why this demarcation was brought about and how can the members be made personally liable for using the company as a vehicle for undesirable purposes. 

What does the term ‘Corporate Veil’ mean?

A company is composed of its members and is managed by its Board of Directors and its employees. When the company is incorporated, it is accorded the status of being a separate legal entity which demarcates the status of the company and the members or shareholders that it is composed of. This concept of differentiation is called a Corporate Veil which is also referred to as the ‘Veil of Incorporation’. 

Need for Introducing the Concept of Corporate Veil

The advantages of incorporation of a Company like Perpetual Succession, Transferable Shares, Capacity to Sue, Flexibility, Limited Liability and lastly the company being accorded the status of a Separate Legal Entity are by no means inconsiderable and, as compared with them, the disadvantages are, indeed very few. 

Yet some of them, which are in essence complications arising out of the privilege of trading with limited liability, deserve to be pointed out. The corporate veil protects the members and the shareholders from the ill-effects of the acts done in the name of the company. Let’s say a director of a company defaults in the name of the company, the liability will be incurred by the company and not the member of the company who had defaulted. If the company incurs any debts or contravenes any laws, the concept of Corporate Veil implies that the members of the company should not be held liable for these errors.

When can a Corporate Veil be Lifted?

Once a company is incorporated, it becomes a separate legal identity. An incorporated company, unlike a partnership firm which has no identity of its own, has a separate legal identity of its own which is independent of its shareholders and its members. 

The companies can thus own properties in their name, become signatories to contracts etc. According to Section 34(2) of the Companies Act, 2013, upon the issue of the certificate of incorporation, the subscribers to the memorandum and other persons, who may from time to time be the members of the company, shall be a body corporate capable of exercising all the functions of an incorporated company having perpetual succession. Thus the company becomes a body corporate which is capable of immediately functioning as an incorporated individual.

The central favourable position of Incorporation from which all others pursue is the distinct lawful substance of the organization. In all actuality, be that as it may, the matter of the legitimate individual is constantly carried on by, and to assist a few people. 

In a definitive examination, some people are the genuine recipients of the corporate focal points. What the milestone case Solomon v Solomon chooses is that “in inquiries of property and limit, of acts done and rights procured or liabilities accepted along these lines… the characters of the common people who are the organization’s corporators is to be disregarded”. 

https://lawsikho.com/course/diploma-companies-act-corporate-governance

Click Here

In Lee v Lee’s Air Farming Ltd, Lee fused an organization which he was the overseeing executive. In that limit, he named himself as a pilot of the organization. While on the matter of the organization he was lost in a flying mishap. His widow recouped remuneration under the Workmen’s Compensation Act. Essentially the enchantment of corporate character empowered him to be ace and hireling in the meantime. At times, the court dismisses the status of an organization as a different lawful substance if the individuals from the organization attempt to exploit this status. The aims of the people behind the cover are totally uncovered. They are made by and by obligated for utilizing the organization as a vehicle for unfortunate purposes.

Instances are not few in which the courts have resisted the temptation to break through the Corporate Veil. But the theory cannot be pushed to unnatural limits. Circumstances must occur which compels the court to identify a company with its members. A company cannot, for example, be convicted of conspiring with its sole director.  

The Corporate Veil can be lifted under the following circumstances:

For Determination of Character of the Company:

In plenty of cases, it ends up being important to check the character of an organization, to check whether it is a companion or a foe of the country the business is set up in. A milestone managing in this field was spread out in Daimler Co Ltd v Continental Tire and Rubber Co Ltd. The certainties of the case are referenced beneath: 

An organization was set up in England and it was set up to sell tires which were thus made by a German organization in Germany. Most of the control in the British organization was held by the German organization. The holders of the rest of the offers with the exception of one and every one of the chiefs were German, dwelling in Germany. In this way, the genuine control of the English organization was in German hands. During the First World War, the English organization started an activity to recuperate an exchange obligation. What’s more, the inquiry was whether the organization had turned into an adversary organization and should, accordingly, be banned from keeping up the activity. 

The House of Lords set out that an organization consolidated in the United Kingdom is a lawful element. It’s anything but a characteristic individual with brain or inner voice. It tends to be neither steadfast nor traitorous. It can neither be anyone’s companion nor for yet it might accept a foe character when people in ‘true’ control of its issues are inhabitants in any adversary nation or, any place the occupants are, are acting under the control of the foes. On the off chance that the activity had been permitted, the organization would have been utilized as hardware by which the motivation behind offering cash to the foe would be practised. 

That would be incredibly against the open arrangement. Be that as it may, it was additionally observed that where there is no peril to such open intrigue, the courts may decline to tear open the Corporate Veil. In People’s Pleasure Park Co v Rohleder, certain terrains were moved by one individual to another interminably ordering the transferee from offering the said property to hued people. He moved the property to an organization made only out of Negroes. 

An activity was started for dissolution of this movement on the ground that every one of the individuals from the organization being Negroes, the property had, in break of the confinement, go to the hands of the hued people. The court, be that as it may, rejected the contention and held that the individuals exclusively or all in all are not the partnership, which “has a particular presence a presence separate from that of its investors.

For Benefits of Revenue

The court has the ability to slight the corporate substance in the event that it is utilized for tax avoidance or to go around expense commitment. An unmistakable delineation of this situation is given in Dinshaw Maneckjee Petit, Re. The assessee was an affluent man getting a charge out of tremendous profit and intrigue pay. He shaped four privately owned businesses and concurred with each to hold a square of speculation as an operator for it. Pay got was credited in the records of the organization yet the organization gave back the sum to him as an imagined advance. 

Thusly he isolated his pay into four sections in an offer to lessen his assessment obligation. It was held that the organization was shaped by the assessee absolutely and basically as a method for maintaining a strategic distance from super-charge and the organization was just the assessee himself. It did no business however was made essentially as a legitimate substance to apparently get the profits and interests and to hand them over to the assessee as imagined credits.

Fraud or Improper Conduct

The corporate entity is wholly incapable of being strained to an illegal or fraudulent purpose. The courts will refuse to uphold the separate existence of the company where the sole reason of it being formed is to defeat law or to avoid legal obligations. Some companies are just set up simply to defraud their customers or to act in a way which is against the statutory guidelines. This was clearly illustrated in the landmark ruling Gilford Motor Co v Horne. The case of the facts are laid out below:

The litigant was selected as an overseeing chief of the offended party organization depending on the prerequisite that he will not whenever while he will hold the workplace of an overseeing executive or subsequently, request or allure away the clients of the organization. His work was resolved under an understanding. In the blink of an eye thereafter he started a business for the sake of his better half which requested the offended party’s clients. It was held that the organization was a simple shroud to empower the litigant to submit a break of his agreement against sales. 

Proof with regards to the development of the organization and with regards to the situation of its investors and executives prompts that deduction. The respondent organization was an insignificant channel utilized by Horne to empower him, for his very own advantage, to acquire the upside of the clients of the offended party organization, and that the litigant organization should be limited just as Horne. 

Where an individual obtained cash from an organization and put it in offers of three distinct organizations in all of which he and his child were the main individuals, the loaning organization was allowed to join the advantages of such organizations as they were made uniquely to dupe the loaning organization.

Government Companies.

An organization may some of the time be viewed as an operator or trustee of its individuals or of another organization and may, accordingly, be esteemed to have lost its distinction for its head. In India, this inquiry has regularly emerged regarding Governmental organizations. Countless privately owned businesses for business purposes have been enrolled under the Companies Act with the president and a couple of different officials as the investors. 

The undeniable preferred position of framing an administration organization is that it gives the exercises of the State “a tad bit of the opportunity which was appreciated by private partnerships and the legislature got away from the standards and standards which hampered activity when it was finished by an administration division rather than an administration enterprise. At the end of the day, it gave the administration a portion of the robes of the person”. 

So as to guarantee this opportunity, the Supreme Court has repeated in various cases that an administration organization isn’t an office or an augmentation of the state. It’s anything but a specialist of the State. As needs be, its representatives are not government workers and right writs can’t issue against it. In one of the cases, the court commented: 

“The organization being a non-statutory body and one consolidated under the Companies Act there was neither a statutory nor an open obligation forced on it by a resolution in regard of which requirement could be looked for by methods for the writ of Mandamus”.

The Madhya Pradesh High Court regarded a Government company to be a separate entity for the purpose of enabling a Development Authority to subject it to development tax. The assets of a Government company were held to be not exempt from payment of non-agricultural assessment under an AP legislation. The exemption enjoyed by the Central Government property from State taxation was not allowed to be claimed by a Government company. 

Conclusion

It is conspicuously clear that incorporation of the company does not cut off personal liability at all times and in all circumstances. The sanctity of a separate corporate entity is upheld only in so far as the entity is consonant with the underlying policies which give it life. 

The post Corporate Veil: All you should know! appeared first on iPleaders.

Winding Up of a Company

$
0
0

This article is written by Dhruv Bhardwaj, a student of Amity Law School, Delhi. In this article, he will discuss how the operations of a company are wound up as per the guidelines laid out in the Companies Act, 2013. 

Introduction

Winding Up of a Company means to bring an end to the life of the company. A distinct feature of a company is Perpetual Succession which means that the longevity of the company does not depend on its members or their financial status. Even if all the members of the company go bankrupt or all of them die, the company will not dissolve on its own unless it is made to dissolve on grounds which are laid out in the act. This article will go over how the operations of a Company are shut according to the provisions of the Companies Act.

Types of Winding Up

According to Section 425 of the Companies Act, 2013, there are 2 kinds of Winding Up. They are:

  1. Compulsory Winding Up under the order of the Court
  2. Voluntary Winding Up, which itself is of two kinds:
    1. Members’ Voluntary Winding Up
    2. Creditor’s Voluntary Winding Up

Winding Up by Court

A company may be wound up at an order of the Court. This is also called Compulsory Winding Up. The cases in which a company may be wound up are given in Section 433. They are as follows:

Special Resolution

In the event that the organization has, by unique goals, settled that it be ended up by the court. The court is, be that as it may, not bound to request Winding Up essentially in light of the fact that the organization has so settled. The power is optional and may not be practised where twisting up would be against the general population or the organization’s advantages.

Default in Holding Statutory Meeting

On the off chance that an organization has made a default in conveying the statutory report to the Registrar or in holding the statutory gathering, it might be requested to be Wound Up.

Failure to Commence Business or Suspension of Business

In the event that an organization does not initiate its business within a year from its joining or has suspended its business for an entire year, it might be requested to be twisted up. Here again, the power is optional and will be practised just when there is a reasonable sign that there is no aim to carry on business. In the event that the suspension is acceptably represented and has all the earmarks of being because of brief causes, the request might be declined.

Reduction in Membership

On the off chance that the quantity of individuals is decreased, on account of an open organization, underneath seven, and on account of a privately owned business, beneath two, the organization might be requested to be twisted up.

Inability to Pay Debts

An organization might be requested to be twisted up on the off chance that it is unfit to pay its obligations. Failure to pay obligations is clarified in Section 434. As indicated by this area, an organization will be esteemed to be unfit to pay its obligations in the accompanying three cases:

  1. Statutory Notice
  2. Decreed Debt
  3. Commercial Insolvency

Just and equitable

The final ground on which the court can arrange the ending up of an organization is the point at which “the court is of the assessment that the organization ought to be twisted up.” This gives the court a wide optional capacity to request twisting up at whatever point it seems, by all accounts, to be attractive. The court may give due weight to the enthusiasm of the organization, its representatives, loan bosses and investors and overall population ought to likewise be considered. The conditions wherein the courts have in the past broken down organizations on this ground can be settled into general classifications as pursues: 

Deadlock

Firstly, when there is a deadlock in the management of the company, it is just and equitable to order winding up. The well-known illustration is Yenidje Tobacco Co Ltd. The facts of the case are laid out as follows: 

W and R who exchanged independently as cigarette makers consented to amalgamate their business and shaped a private limited organization of which they were investors and the main chiefs. They had an equivalent casting of ballot rights and, in this manner, the articles gave that any contest would be settled by discretion, however, one of them disagreed from the honour. Both at that point turned out to be hostile to the point that neither of them would address the other aside from through the secretary.

Therefore there was a finished stop and thus the organization was requested to be twisted up in spite of the fact that its business was thriving. It must be noticed that the ‘Fair and Equitable’ statement ought not to be conjured in situations where the main trouble is the distinction of view between the greater part directorate and those speaking to the minority.

https://lawsikho.com/course/diploma-companies-act-corporate-governance

Click Here

Loss of Substratum

Also, it is simply and evenhanded to wrap up an organization when its fundamental article has neglected to appear or it has lost its substratum. A decent delineation is German Date Coffee Co. The realities of the case are spread out as pursues: 

An organization was shaped to make espresso from dates under a patent which was to be conceded by the Government of Germany and furthermore for working different licenses of comparable kind. The German patent was never allowed and the organization set out upon different licenses. Yet, on the request of an investor, it was held that “the substratum of the organization had fizzled, and it was difficult to do the items for which it was framed; and, subsequently, it was simple and fair that the organization ought to be twisted up.

Losses

Thirdly, it is viewed as just and fair to wrap up an organization when it can’t carry on business with the exception of at misfortunes. It will be unnecessary, in reality, for an organization to carry on business when there is no desire for accomplishing the object of exchanging at a benefit. Yet, simple anxiety with respect to certain investors that the benefits of the organization will be squandered and that misfortune rather than increase will result has been held to be no ground.

Oppression of Minority

It is simple and even-handed to wrap up an organization where the vital investors have embraced a forceful or onerous or pressing approach towards the minority. The choice of the Madras High Court in R. Sabapathi Rao v Sabapathi Press Ltd, is a representation in point. The court saw that where the executives of an organization had the option to practice an overwhelming effect on the administration of the organization and the overseeing chief had the option to outvote the minority of the investors and hold the benefits of the business between individuals from the family and there were a few objections that the investors did not get a duplicate of the asset report, nor was the inspector’s report perused at the general gathering, profits were not consistently paid and the rate was lessening, that established adequate ground for twisting up.

Fraudulent Purpose

It is simple and fair to wrap up an organization on the off chance that it has been imagined and delivered in misrepresentation or for an illicit reason.

Incorporated or Quasi Partnership

It has been seen that there is little in like manner between the goliath organization and the family or the one individual organization. To apply the equivalent legitimate prerequisites to such various associations is profitable of bother and bad form. So as to maintain a strategic distance from such “burden and unfairness” the Act treats them distinctively in a few regards. In any case, even in issues in which the Act treats them alike, the courts have needed to recognize them.

Voluntary Winding Up

A company may be wound up voluntarily in the following two ways, as discussed below:

By Ordinary Resolution

An organization might be twisted up willfully by passing an ordinary resolution when the period, assuming any, fixed for the span of the organization by the articles, has lapsed. Also, when the occasion, assuming any, has happened, on the event of which the articles give that the organization is to be broken down, the organization may, by passing a normal goal with that impact, start its willful twisting up.

By Special Resolution

A company may at any time pass a special resolution providing that the company be wound up voluntarily. Winding Up commences at the time when the resolution is passed. Within fourteen days of the passing of the resolution, the company shall give notice of the resolution by advertisement in the Official Gazette and also in some newspaper circulating in the district of the registered office of the company. The corporate state and powers of the company shall continue until the company is dissolved, but it shall stop its business, except so far as may be necessary for beneficial winding up. 

As discussed earlier in the article, Voluntary Winding Up is of two kinds:

  1. Members’ Voluntary Winding Up;
  2. Creditor’s Voluntary Winding Up

If a Declaration of Solvency is made in accordance with the provisions of the Act, it will be a Members’ Voluntary Winding Up and if it is not made, it becomes the Creditors’ Voluntary Winding Up. The declaration has to be made by a majority of the directors at the meeting of the board and verified by an affidavit. They have to declare that they have made a full inquiry into the affairs of the company and have formed the opinion that the company has no debts or that it will be able to pay its debts in full within a certain period, not exceeding three years, from the commencement of winding up.

The declaration, to be effective, must be made within the five weeks immediately before the date of the resolution and should be delivered to the Registrar for registration before that date. It should also be accompanied by a copy of the report of the auditors on the profit and loss account and the balance sheet of the company prepared up to the date of the declaration and should embody a statement of the company’s assets and liabilities as at that date.

There is a penalty for making the declarations without having reasonable grounds for the opinion that the company will be able to pay its debts within the specified period. If the company fails to pay the debts within that period, it will be presumed that reasonable grounds for making the declaration did not exist. The liquidator should forthwith call a meeting of the creditors because the winding up has then to proceed as if it were Creditors’ Winding Up.

Final Meeting and Dissolution

When the affairs of the company are fully wound up, the liquidator makes an account of the winding up showing how the winding up has been conducted and the property of the company disposed of. He then calls a general meeting of the company for the purpose of laying before it the accounts of winding up. The meeting is to be called by advertisement in the Official Gazette and a local newspaper specifying the time, place and object of the meeting. Within a week after the meeting, the liquidator sends a copy of the accounts and a return of the meeting to the Registrar and the Official Liquidator.

If no quorum was present at the meeting, he makes a return stating the fact. The Registrar, on receipt of the accounts and the return, registers the documents. The Official Liquidator, to whom also a copy of the accounts and return is sent, is required to make a scrutiny of the books and papers of the company. The liquidator of the company and it’s past and present officers are under a duty to give the Official Liquidator all reasonable facility for the purpose. 

The Official Liquidator reports to the Tribunal, the result of his scrutiny. If the report shows that the affairs of the company were not conducted in a manner prejudicial to the interest of its members or to the public interest, then from the date of the submission of the report to the Tribunal, the company shall be deemed to be dissolved. If the report reveals that the affairs were conducted in a manner prejudicial to the interests of the members or to the public interest, the court shall direct the Official Liquidator to make further investigations into the affairs of the company. The court may invest him with such powers as may be necessary for the purpose. When the court receives the report on further investigation, it may declare that the company stands dissolved or make such order as the circumstances discovered by the report may warrant. 

Conclusion

A company can be wound up for a lot of reasons but Winding Up of a Company is not as simple as closing the shutters of its headquarters or not turning up to work. Winding Up is an even more cumbersome process than the Incorporation itself.

References

  1. Company Law by Avatar Singh.

The post Winding Up of a Company appeared first on iPleaders.

Delegatus Non-Potest Delegare

$
0
0

This article is written by Dhruv Bhardwaj, a student of Amity Law School, Delhi. In this article, he has discussed the legal maxim ‘Delegatus Non-Potest Delegare’.

Introduction

In recent years, a very conspicuous trend that can be seen is that apart from the purely administrative function, the executive performs legislative functions as well. This article will go over what this trend is about, what makes it so popular and the limitations on the exercise of this power.

Delegated Legislation 

Because of various reasons, there is a fast development of authoritative enactment. A pattern especially in vogue today in every majority rule nation is that a decent arrangement of enactment happens in government division outside the House of Legislature. This sort of action is really called ‘Delegated Legislation’. 

By and large, what happens is that the assembly authorizes a law covering just the general standards and arrangements identifying with the topic being referred to and gives rule-production control on the legislature or some other regulatory organization. This is so in light of the fact that the immediate enactment of the Parliament isn’t finished. The Executive is offered the capacity to enhance the laws made by the Legislature.

The outcome is that the method of Delegated Legislation is so generally utilized in current occasions as a procedure of government that there is no rule gone by the Legislature which does not Delegate some intensity of enactment to the Executive. It is additionally said that Delegated Legislation is multitudinous to the point that any rule won’t just be deficient yet, in addition, be deluding except if it be perused alongside the appointed enactment which enhances and changes it.

Delegated Legislation is used in two senses. In one sense Delegated Legislation refers to the exercise of power of rule-making delegated to the Executive by the Legislature. In the other sense, it means the output of the exercise of that power. In the first sense, it means that the authority making the legislation is subordinate to the legislature.

The legislative powers are exercised by an authority other than the legislature in the exercise of powers delegated or conferred on them by the legislature itself. This is also known as “Subordinate Legislation” because the powers of the authority which makes it is limited by the statute which conferred power and consequently it is valid if at all it is kept within those limits.

In the second sense, Delegated Legislation refers to all law-making which is generally expressed as rules, regulations, bye-laws, orders, schemes, directions, circulars or notifications etc. 

Generally, Delegated Legislation means the law made by the Executive under the powers delegated to it by the Legislature.

Delegated Legislation as opposed to Administrative Power

Publication

If an order is legislative in character, it has to be published in a certain manner, but publication is not necessary if it is of an administrative nature. An administrative order refers to a particular individual and in this respect, it is required to be served only on the individual concerned.

Principles of Natural Justice

The Principles of Natural Justice entails 3 principles:

  • Rule Against Bias
  • Rules for Fair Hearing
  • Reasoned Decisions or Speaking Order

In the case of adjudication, the administration is required to follow the principles of natural justice, while in the case of legislation no such requirement is necessary. 

Grounds of Judicial Review

Administrative action may be challenged on the ground of mala fides but it is highly unlikely for such a challenge to prevail in case of delegated legislation. https://lawsikho.com/course/certificate-criminal-litigation-trial-advocacy

 

Click Here

Duty to Give Reasons

The requirement of duty to give reasons applies to administrative orders but not to legislative orders.

Factors Leading to the Growth of Delegated Legislation

Pressure Upon Parliamentary Time

As there is a marvellous increment in the functions of the state, the main part of enactment is great to the point that it isn’t feasible for the council to dedicate adequate time to examine every one of the issues in detail. Accordingly, the governing body passes skeleton enactment containing general approach and enables the executive to fill in the subtleties in this way giving fragile living creature and blood to the skeleton with the goal that it might live by making vital guidelines, guidelines, bye-laws and so forth.

Technicality

Sometimes the topic of enactment is of a specialized sort and requires meeting of specialists. Individuals from Parliament might be best legislators however they are not specialists to manage very specialized issues which are required to be taken care of by specialists. In such cases, the administrative power might be appointed to specialists to manage the specialized issues. Enactment concerning nuclear vitality, atomic vitality, gas, medications or power might be cited as delineations of such details. Some things are best handled by people who have great experience in their respective domains, not always can our politicians think like people who have been committed to their craft for a really long time.

Flexibility

Parliament does not work constantly. At the season of passing any administrative establishment, it is preposterous to expect to anticipate every one of the possibilities beforehand. In this manner, control is essentially required to be given to the Executive to meet the unanticipated possibilities. In this manner, control is fundamentally required to be given to the Executive to meet the unanticipated possibilities or to modify new conditions emerging often. While parliamentary procedure includes delays, assigned enactment offers quick apparatus for correction. Police guidelines and certain financial guidelines identifying with bank rate, imports and fares, outside trade and so on are cases of such circumstances.

Experimentation

Ordinary legislative process suffers from the limitation of lack of viability and experimentation. Delegated Legislation enables the executive to experiment. The method permits rapid utilisation of experience and implementation of necessary changes in the application of the provisions in the light of such experience. If the rules and regulations are found to be satisfactory, they can be implemented successfully. On the other hand if they are found to be defective, the defects can be cured immediately.

Emergency

In the midst of crisis, fast activity is required to be taken. A crisis may ascend by virtue of war, rebellion, floods, pandemics, financial downturn and preferences. Administrative procedure isn’t prepared to accommodate earnest answer for meeting the circumstance. It is, along these lines, that the official must have a control that might be utilized in a flash. Appointed Legislation is the main helpful cure.

Confidential Matters

In some situations, the public interest demands that the law must not be known to anybody until it comes into operation. Rationing schemes or imposition of import duty or exchange control are such matters.

Sub-Delegation

When a statute confers legislative powers on an administrative authority and that authority further delegates those powers to another subordinate authority or agency, it is called sub-delegation. Thus, what happens in sub-delegation is that a delegate further delegates. This process of sub-delegation may go through one stage to another stage. If the enabling Act is called the ‘Parent’ then the delegated and the sub-delegated act is called the Children.

Illustration

A good illustration of the process of sub-delegation is provided by the Essential Commodities Act, 1955. Section 3 of the Act confers rule-making power on the Central Government. This can be called as the first stage of Delegation. Under Section 5, the Central Government is empowered to delegate powers to its officers, the State Governments and their officers. Frequently under this provision, the powers are delegated to State Governments.

This may be regarded as the second stage of Delegation. When the power is further sub-delegated by the State Government to their officers, it may be characterised as the third stage of Delegation. The working of the process can be seen in the context of the Cotton Control Order, 1955, The order is made by the Central Government under Section 3 of the Act (this can be called the first stage of delegation).

Under the Order, the functions and powers are conferred on the Textile Commissioner (this can be called the second stage of delegation). Under clause 10, the Textile Commissioner is empowered to authorise any officer to exercise on his behalf all or any of his functions and powers under the Order (third stage of Delegation). 

Objects of Sub-Delegation 

The need of sub-delegation is sought to be supported on the basis of the following factors-

  • Power of delegation necessarily carries with it the power of further delegation and hence, the delegate has power to further delegate; and
  • Sub-delegation is ancillary to delegated legislation, and objection to such process is likely to subvert the authority which the legislature delegates to the Executive.

Delegatus Non-Potest Delegare

The legal maxim ‘Delegatus Non-Potest Delegare’ does not lay down a rule of law. It merely states a rule of construction of a statute. Generally, sub-delegation of legislative power is impermissible, yet it can be permitted either when such power is expressly conferred under the statute or can be inferred by necessary implication. This is so because there is a well-established principle that a sub-delegate cannot act beyond the scope of power delegated to him.

Express Power 

There is no difficulty as regards the validity of sub-delegation where the statute itself authorises the administrative agency to sub-delegate its powers because such a sub-delegation is within the terms of the statute itself.

Thus in Central Talkies v. Dwarka Prasad, under the U.P. Control of Rent and Eviction Act, 1947, it was provided that no suit shall be filed for the eviction of a tenant without the permission of either a District Magistrate or any Officer authorised by him to perform any of his functions under the Act. The Additional Magistrate to whom the powers were delegated made an order granting permission.

The Supreme Court held the order valid. But in Allingham v. Minister of Agriculture, under the Defence Regulations, 1939, the Committee was authorised by the Minister of Agriculture “to give such directions with respect to the cultivation, management or use of land for agricultural purposes as he thinks necessary.” The committee sub-delegated its power to its Subordinate Officer, who issued a direction, which was challenged. Holding the direction ultra vires, the Court ruled that the sub-delegation of power by the committee was not permissible.

Implied Power

The point is not clear as to what would be the position if there is no specific or express provision in the statute for sub-delegation of power. In Jackson v. Butterworth, it was held that the method of sub-delegating power to issue circulars to local authorities was convenient and desirable but the power to sub-delegate was absent. However, the other view is that although there is no provision enabling Act authorising sub-delegation of power by the delegate, the same may be inferred by necessary implication.

According to Griffith, “If the statute is so wisely phrased that two or more ‘tiers’ of sub-delegation are necessary to reduce it to specialised rules on which action can be based, then it may be that the Courts will imply the power to make the necessary sub-delegated legislation.” In States v. Bareno the enabling Act empowered the President to make regulations concerning exports and provided that unless otherwise directed the functions of President should be performed by the Board of Economic Welfare.

The Board sub-delegated the power to its Executive Director who further sub-delegated to his assistant, who in turn delegated it to some officials. All the sub-delegations were held valid by the Court. On the other hand, in State v. Amir Chand, the Punjab High Court held that the power of sub-delegation cannot be inferred.

Publication of sub-delegated legislation

There arises the question of the publication of sub-delegated legislation. It may, however, be pointed out that by the decision of the Supreme Court in Narendra Kumar v. Union of India, the publication of sub-delegated legislation has been declared to be necessary to give it legal force when the Parent statute contains the formula i.e requiring the notification of rules in Gazzette.

Conclusion

The practice of sub-delegation has been subjected to considerable criticism by jurists. The position is well established that the maxim ‘Delegatus Non-Potest Delegare’ applies in the area of delegated legislation also and sub-delegation of power is not permissible unless that power is conferred either expressly or impliedly.

The post Delegatus Non-Potest Delegare appeared first on iPleaders.

Rights and Liabilities of a Mortgagor

$
0
0

This article is written by Amandeep Kaur, a student of Symbiosis Law School, Pune. The author in this article has discussed the basic concepts of mortgagor and mortgagee and also the rights and liabilities of a mortgagor.  

Introduction

Nowadays mortgage is a very commonly used word. Every single person has the knowledge that if he wants a loan to be sanctioned, he has to pay some collateral and for that, he has to mortgage his property with a bank. Mortgagor and mortgagee are the parties who have an important role to play during mortgage of a property. Various statutes available in India deals with a mortgage. Following legislation deal with mortgage:

  1. The Transfer of Property Act, 1882– Sections 58-104, which are mentioned in Chapter IV deals with the significant part of mortgage.
  2. The Civil Procedure Code, 1908– The procedural part of mortgage of immovable property is dealt in Chapter XXXIV of CPC.
  3. Indian Contract Act, 1872– Any contract related to mortgage and its general principles are mentioned in the Indian Contract Act of 1872.

When do rights & liabilities of a mortgagor arise?

The rights and liabilities of a mortgagor arise during a mortgage. A loan may be secured or unsecured. Where a loan is given simply on the basis of debtor’s promise to pay (e.g. on promissory-note), such loans are called as unsecured loans. But, where the creditor takes security from the debtor for the repayment of his money, the loan is known as secured loans. One such way to secure loans is mortgage. Section-58(a) of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 has defined mortgage as the transfer of an interest in a specific immovable property for securing:

  • The payment of money given to him or to be given through loan, or
  • An existing or future debt, or
  • The performance of an engagement which may give rise to a pecuniary liability. 

Who is a mortgagor?

The person who has transferred the interest in a specific immovable property is known as mortgagor. For instance, A wants a loan from B. Now B wants his amount to be secured which he is going to loan A. A will transfer the interest in a specific immovable property to B and will give him the authority of selling it in case A is not able to repay B’s amount. Here A is the mortgagor.

Who is a mortgagee?

The transferee or person in whose favour the interest is being transferred is known as mortgagee. In the above-given example, the person who is lending money i.e. B is the mortgagee. 

What is mortgage-money?

The principal amount which is given as loan and the interest amount which mortgagor will pay to mortgagee along with the principal amount. Sum of both the principal amount and interest is known as mortgage-money. 

What is a mortgage deed?

It is an instrument by which the transfer of interest in a specific immovable property is affected. It is a kind of agreement which legally binds both the mortgagor and mortgagee. 

Different kinds of mortgage

There are six kinds of mortgage which are recognized under the Transfer of Property Act, 1882. They are discussed in the act from section 58(b)-58(g). Following are the different kinds of mortgage:

  1. Simple Mortgage [section-58(b)]
  2. Mortgage by conditional sale [section-58(c)]
  3. Usufructuary Mortgage [section-58(d)]
  4. English Mortgage [section-58(e)]
  5. Mortgage by deposit of title deeds [section-58(f)]
  6. Anomalous Mortgage [section-58(g)]

 

https://lawsikho.com/course/diploma-advanced-contract-drafting-negotiation-dispute-resolution

Click Here

Rights of Mortgagor

Every mortgage-deed leaves a right to the mortgagor and a corresponding liability for mortgagee and vice versa. Following are the rights given to a mortgagor given by the Transfer of Property Act, 1882:

  1. Right to redemption
  2. Right to transfer mortgaged property to a third party instead of retransferring
  3. Right of inspection and production of documents
  4. Right to accession
  5. Right to improvements
  6. Right to a renewed lease
  7. Right to grant a lease

Right to Redemption (section-60)

It is one of the most important rights of a mortgagor given under section of the Act. This right puts an end to mortgage by returning the property of mortgagor. The right to redeem further grants three rights to the mortgagor:

  1. Right to end mortgage deal
  2. Right to transfer mortgaged property to his name
  3. To take back possession of property in case of delivery of possession

In the case of Noakes & Co. vs. Rice (1902) AC 24, Rice was a dealer who mortgaged his property, premise and goodwill to N subject to the provision that if R paid back the whole amount, the property would be transferred back to his name or any other person’s. A covenant was attached that stated whether or not the amount is due, R would only sell Malt liquor by N in his premises. Because of this covenant, R had difficulty in redemption and it didn’t give him absolute right over his property. House of Lords held that anything which clogs this right is bad and they came up with the concept that ‘once a mortgage always a mortgage’ and said that mortgage could never be irreducible. 

This principle was added to protect the interest of a mortgagor. Any condition or provision which prevents a mortgagor from redeeming his mortgaged property is a clog on the right of redemption. The right to redemption continues even though the mortgagor fails to repay the loan amount to mortgagee. In the case of Stanley v. Wilde, (1899) 2 Ch 474, it was held that any provision mentioned in the mortgage-deed which has an effect of preventing or impeding the right to redemption is void as a clog on redemption.  

 

  • Exceptions to the right- The right to redeem has three exceptions. It can be extinguished under the following cases:
  • By the act of parties
  • By operation of law
  • By decree passed by the court

 

Obligation to transfer to the third party instead of transferring it to mortgagor (section-60A)

This right was added in the Act by Amendment Act of 1929. This right provides the mortgagor with authority to ask the mortgagee to assign the mortgage debt and transfer the property to a third person directed by him. The purpose of this right is to help the mortgagor to pay off the mortgagee by taking a loan from a third person on the same security.  

Right to inspection and production of documents (section-60B)

This section is also inserted by the Amendment Act of 1929. It is the right of mortgagor to ask mortgagee for the production of copies of documents of the mortgaged property in his possession for inspection on notice of reasonable time. The expenses incurred on production or copies of documents or travel expenses of a mortgagee are to be paid by the mortgagor. This right is available to the mortgagor only as long as his right to redeem exists. 

Right to Accession (section-63)

Basically, accession means any addition to property. According to this right mortgagor is entitled to such accession to his property which is in the custody of mortgagee. There are two types of accession:

  • Artificial accession- It is when mortgagor made some efforts and it increased the value of land. 
  • Natural accession- The name itself defines i.e. without any man-made efforts.

In case an accession is made to the property due to the efforts of mortgagee or at his expense and such accession is inseparable, mortgagor, in order to be entitled to such succession, needs to pay the mortgagee the expense of acquiring such accession. 

If such separate possession or enjoyment is not possible, the accession must be delivered with the property; it is the liability of mortgagor, in the case of an acquisition which is necessary to preserve the property from destruction, forfeiture or sale, or made with his assent, to pay the proper cost thereof, as an addition to the principal money, with interest at the same rate as is payable on the principal amount, or, where no such rate is fixed, at the rate of nine percent per annum. 

Right to Improvements (section-63A)

According to this right if the mortgaged property has been improved while it was in possession of mortgagee, then on redemption and in the absence of any contract to the contrary mortgagor is entitled to such improvement. The mortgagor is not liable to pay mortgagee unless:

  • Improvements made by the mortgagee were to protect the property or with the prior permission of mortgagor.
  • Improvements were made by the mortgagee with the permission of the public authority.   

Right to Renewed Lease (section-64)

If the mortgagor is entitled the mortgaged property is a leasehold property and during the duration of mortgage the lease gets renewed then, on redemption the mortgagor is entitled to have the benefit of the new lease. This right is available to the mortgagor unless he enters into any contract to the contrary with mortgagee.

Right to grant a Lease (section-65A)

This right was introduced by the Amendment Act of 1929. Prior to this right, the Transfer of Property Act did not allow a mortgagor to lease out the mortgaged property on his own but only with the permission of mortgagee. Now, a mortgagor has the right to lease out the mortgaged property while he is in lawful possession of that property, subject to the following conditions:

  • All conditions in the lease should be according to the local laws and customs to prevent any fraudulent transaction.
  • No rent or premium shall be paid in advance or promised by mortgagee.
  • The contract shall not contain any provision for the renewal of the lease.
  • Every such lease shall come into effect within a period of six months from the date of its execution. 
  • Where the mortgaged property is a building, the term of the lease should not exceed three years in total.

Duties/liabilities of a mortgagor

Along with the rights given to a mortgagor, the Transfer of Property Act has also conferred some duties on him. Following are the duties of a mortgagor:

  1. Duty to avoid waste
  2. Duty to indemnify for defective title
  3. Duty to compensate mortgagee
  4. Duty to direct rent of a lease to mortgagee

Duty to avoid waste (section-66)

This section imposes a duty on the mortgagor to not to commit any act which leads to the waste of property or any act which reduces the value of the mortgaged property. Waste is divided into two categories:

  • Permissive waste– A mortgagor who is in possession of the mortgaged property is not liable to the mortgagee for any minor waste.
  • Active waste– When an act is done which causes major waste of the property or leads to the reduction in the value of mortgaged property, then the mortgagor will be liable to the mortgagee.

Duty to indemnify for defective title

It is the duty of a mortgagor to compensate the mortgagee for a defective title in the mortgaged property. A defective title refers to a situation when a third party starts claiming or interferes with mortgaged property. It is a liability for the mortgagor to compensate for the expenses incurred by mortgagee for protecting the title of that property.

Duty to compensate mortgagee

If the mortgaged property is in possession of mortgagee who is paying all the taxes and other public charges, then it is the duty of mortgagor to compensate mortgagee for incurring such expenses. Similarly, when there is no delivery of possession i.e. the mortgaged property is still in possession of mortgagor, then it is his duty to pay all public charges and taxes levied on it. 

Duty to direct rent of a lease to mortgagee

Where the mortgaged property is leased by mortgagor then it is his duty to direct lessee to pay the rent, etc. to the mortgagee.  

Conclusion

A mortgage-deed comes up with many rights and liabilities for both the parties involved i..e. mortgagor and mortgagee. These rights and liabilities were created and included in the Transfer of Property Act in 1882 which is quite old and therefore is outdated. Though amendments were made in the Amendment Act of 1929, but no recent amendments have been made in the chapter of rights and liabilities of mortgagor. This has lead to various fraudulent transactions as both the mortgagor and mortgagee has found various new methods of deceiving each other. Therefore, the need of the hour is to amend the laws and make it more stringent so that no party attempts to enter in fraudulent transactions.    

The post Rights and Liabilities of a Mortgagor appeared first on iPleaders.

Women and related Social Changes

$
0
0

This article is written by Amandeep Kaur, a student of Symbiosis Law School, Pune. The author in this article has discussed the social changes made by law and society related to women.

Introduction and Background

Meaning

Social change refers to a shift in society arising from different types of group activities, from modified inter-personal and inter-class relationships and changed attitudes and approaches of people and government about governance, family and public life, economic processes and social outlook, as compared to their previous position.  Roger Cotterrell views, ”Social change is held to occur only when social structure- patterns of social relations, established social norms and social roles-changes” It involves, according to some scholars,” non-repetitive alteration in the established modes of behaviour in society.” 

Significance

Change is the basic rule of nature and everything might change except the law of change. Old order changes giving place to the new. Life itself is a constant change. But in the context of society, change does not occur on its own. It should be deliberately conceived, its contours should be designed and its scheme should be executed with accurate strategies.

Women and related Social Changes

It is a known fact that the majority of the families in India are male-dominated and their relationship is based on the male line of their respective family. The father takes all the decisions related to the life of a child. His mother, who gave birth to him, who has an immense significance in his life, does not have a say while making decisions for his life. Even while taking decisions of paramount importance, a woman is never asked about her opinion.

One can find many incidents which reflect that men are more visible and audible to society in comparison to women. If a woman is not earning and is doing near all the tasks within the home, then her that work will have no importance or will not be counted as ‘work’ in the eyes of a man. Even though while performing these tasks, a woman spent most of her time, energy; still, it will not be considered as work because there are no earnings involved.

It is an issue not only in India but is most of the western countries. Though India is one of the most unbalanced countries where the amount of household work a man does is the least in comparison to other countries along with Turkey, Mexico and Japan, it is not right there are no balanced countries as Norway, Sweden, Denmark and Finland are among the most balanced countries where both men and women share all the household chores. There is no reason why women are expected to do all these tasks, and no credit is given to them after doing such tiresome work.

There are various factors involved behind under-representation of work done by women such as self-perception of a woman, the attitude of employers towards them, traditional expectations of their role and position of women in the ancient period in rural and urban areas.

Domestic violence

It is unfortunate that home, the sweet home, the abode of rich and complex feelings and a place of retreat for a protective sphere of family life, could be a very dangerous place for women.  Instead of giving protective shade by being a sanctuary of tranquillity and harmony, a family has become in many situations breeding ground of violence against women in the hands of their own relations. Domestic violence being an incongruity in terms and gender neutral in words is frequently and privately inflicted on women. In Meacher v. Meacher, the Court of Appeals declined to uphold the husband’s right to assault his wife when she refused to obey his orders not to visit her relations. But in some cases in 1959 and 1975 support husband’s privilege so long as its effect was moderate.  Anyway, the traditional rule reflected the subordinate position of women in the family and other social institutions

Domestic violence in a wider sense includes all types of physical and mental cruelties and use of force upon any member of the family by its other members. In limited or technical knowledge, it means brutality against a female member of the family by other members. Undoubtedly, it involves human rights issue and is a serious obstruction to development. According to Poornima Advani,” It (domestic violence) is pernicious because it is directed against women who are supposed to carry the generations forward and goes against all canoes of civilized. It is insidious because it takes place within the closed walls of the home, which is supposed to be the safe sanctuary for its occupants.” 

The phenomenon of domestic violence is widely prevalent but has largely remained invisible in the public domain. In view of this and also realizing the serious inadequacies in the present law, in 1994 an Expert Committee on rules drafted the Domestic Violence to Women (Prevention) Bill. There was also widespread demand for comprehensive legislation on the subject by various women’s organizations. In 1997-98 the National Commission for Women forwarded its draft to the Union Government, which was tabled in Parliament as the Protection from Domestic Violence Bill, 2002. The Bill was referred to Standing Committee of the HRD, and the resultant draft was circulated amidst other ministries. In June 2005 the Union Cabinet decided to reintroduce the Bill in Parliament with certain refinements. A decade of development in public opinion and the interactive lawmaking process is quite encouraging and demonstrates the strength in public opinion to mould legal policy. In 2005 a fresh Bill with new features was introduced and was passed in Parliament. As a result, the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 has emerged. The Act intends to give effect to the rights of women under constitutional and international law and tries to provide civil law’s protection to women who are victims of violence occurring within the family.

https://lawsikho.com/course/certificate-criminal-litigation-trial-advocacy

Click Here

Dowry

When we speak of gender inequality in the nation, the dowry system can be considered the catalyst for this issue. According to the social infrastructure of the country, it is a common perception that a woman is a liability and is to be married off someday, with a dowry debt at disposal. Well, for the masses, the birth of a girl is inception to long-term plans to pay off the dowry along with the child. The dowry system is evil and which has also been a serious matter of concern for the country because of its increasing and never-decreasing proportions. 

Being widely practised across the nation, every other family faces the brunt of it. If demand is not met by the bride’s family, she suffers at the hands of her groom’s family leading to social imbalance and emotional breakdown. As early as in 1928 Gandhiji wrote emphasizing the need for voluntary collective action against the evil,” A strong public opinion should be created in condemnation of the degrading practice of dowry, and young men, who soil their fingers with such ill-gotten gold, should be excommunicated from society. Parents of girls should cease to be dazzled by English degrees, and should not hesitate to travel outside their little castes and provinces to secure true gallant young men for their daughters.” However, there was a voluntary practice of giving gifts to the bride by her parents or relatives that were recognized as stridhan of the bride. 

In view of the spread of the evil of dowry all over India, Parliament felt it as expedient to enact a central law under the Concurrent list subject to State Amendments with the approval by the President. In the framing of the Bill, States were also consulted. Joint Committee of Parliament discussed the subject in detail. It also referred to the ever increasing and disturbing proportion of the evil of dowry and grossly insensitive attitude of the youth that contributed to its perpetuation. Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru while piloting the Bill on 6 May 1961 observed,” Legislation cannot be itself normally solve deep-rooted social problems. One has to approach them in another way too, but legislation is necessary and essential, so that it may give that push and have that education factor as well as the legal sanctions behind it which help public opinion to be given a certain shape.” The law emerged, as a result, was the Dowry Prohibition Act, 1961. 

Sati

The practice of Sati-of burning or occasionally burying a widow alive with her deceased husband-is ancient evil grew through distortions of shastras and assertion of patriarchal controls. According to P.V. Kane, ”there is no Vedic passage which can be cited as incontrovertibly referring to widow burning as then-current nor is there any mantra which could be said to have been repeated in very ancient times at such burning or do the ancient grihyasutraa contain any direction prescribing the procedure of widow burning.” A.L. Basham refers to the symbolic duty of widow in Rigveda to pay last respect to her departed husband but not the practice of Sati. Permissibility of widow remarriage in this period rules out the practice of Sati.  

During the medieval period, some of the Muslim kings like Muhammad-bin-Tughlaq and Humayun took strong exception to this practice as inhuman and imposed hurdles to the practice by requiring royal assent for the same or strict proof about voluntary consent of the widows.  Akbar discouraged the practice of Sati and rescued some widows from the practice. He commented, ’It is a strange commentary on the magnanimity of men that they should see their deliverance through the self-sacrifice of their wives.’  Prohibition of involuntary Sati and requirement of prior position for voluntary Sati was the practice continued during the subsequent period until its ultimate abolition in 1829 by the British.

The British policy on Sati was initially obsessed by a sense of cultural superiority and white man’s assumed role of purging barbaric practices. While documentation of instances of Sati was helpful in creating public opinion in India and Britain against its practice, the political strategy was hesitant for decisive action for its abolition in 1805 in fear of alarm and dissatisfaction in the minds of Hindus. The Nizamat Adalat asked judicial officials to secure advance notice of occurrence of a Sati, then to appoint police officers to proceed personally to the site in order to ensure that Sati is performed voluntarily and not under the influence of drugs or intoxicants or coercion; and to establish that youth or the state of pregnancy of widow did not violate the norms. 

The British campaign against the practice of Sati culminated in big development. Sir William Bentinck, the then Governor General of India and liberal thinking reformer, on his own initiative and on the persuasive influence of Raja Ram Mohan Roy, initiated the law for the total abolition of the practice of Sati. The Regulation XVII promulgated in 1829 declared “the practice of suttee, or burning, or burying alive the widows of Hindus, illegal and punishable by the criminal courts.”

Analysis

For thousands of years, women were obedient to men. Most of the cultures generally follow the male line as their ancestry. Though there is no legislation or religion which says that but most of the families prefer it this way. If we look past in ancient India there was no discrimination on the basis of sex in the domain of education. Though people in the late 18th century started discriminating between a girl and a boy.  Only male members were allowed to avail the facility of education as according to their beliefs there was no use of educating a woman.

An enormous change can be seen in women of the 21st century. They are no more dependent on men and are not dominant to men. Improvement can be seen in the status of women of the 21st century. Several changes can be observed, some of them are below:

Constitutional and Legal Rights to Women

Many rights and safeguards have been enshrined in the constitution for women in India which includes equality in multiple fields, the prohibition of human trafficking, reservation at various posts. Legal rights like Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act (2005), Commission of Sati (Prevention) Act (1987) and Dowry Prohibition Act (1961) as stated above. 

Role of Women in Politics

The world witnessed whole new footage of women participating in politics as the number of women participating in politics is gradually increasing. India itself is a big example as the position of women in politics has completely changed from pre-independence to post-independence era due to various reforms and movements. 

Participation of Women in Socio-economic activities

The women in modern times are entering into certain new fields that were unknown to the woman’s sphere of role sets. The contemporary woman keenly desires to enter into a work career because of the pressing economic needs of the family. To fulfil the financial needs of the family and to achieve a higher standard of living the women participates in commercial activities.

Many more changes have emerged but as we know there always exists the other side of the coin which can be reflected as below:

Women equality is not universal

Women did achieve equality and status equal to men but it does not apply to all the countries of the world. Equality of a woman in the domains of education, employment and power is still a question in most of the countries. Majority of women are still exposed to inequality and inferior status to men. One of the reason is that there are not enough jobs for women, moreover, working women are not entirely protected from harassment at working place even after the implementation of the Sexual Harassment at WorkPlace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013.

Minor representation in State Assemblies

If we take the women’s participation in politics as one of the measurements of their emancipation, we find at present their number is very low as compared to men in State Assemblies and Parliament. It is only 11% i.e. 26 women in Rajya Sabha consisting of 245 members and 78 women in Lok Sabha.

Conclusion

Law has brought a lot of social changes in the field of women but as we know every coin has two sides, so there are still situations where reforms are needed to be brought. Law does not always contribute to the changes in society but sometimes society should take the initiative. Every woman desires to rise in their status and position in society as that of men. For such change, a healthy environment is needed which is still not available in our country. Though many structural and statutory changes for improving the environment of our country have been made with time. It can be observed that every woman is achieving independence, equality and status in the society, hence, breaking the traditional beliefs and status.

The post Women and related Social Changes appeared first on iPleaders.

Tax Planning – Everything You Need to Know

$
0
0

This Article has been edited by Mansi Bathija and written by Ayushi Yadav, a fourth-year law student from Banasthali Vidyapith, Rajasthan. She has discussed tax planning schemes and methods provided by taxation law in India.

Tax Planning – Introduction

As we all know, the Government has imposed tax liability on taxpayers. In the era of high tax rates, everyone wants to save their money for their future plans. To reduce that liability taxpayer do financial plans to save their taxes and future investments. For salaried individuals, it is essential to invest their money in the right way for fruitful consequences. In this article, we will discuss what is tax planning and tax management and how does it help the corporates and individuals.

Tax Planning Meaning

Tax planning is an activity to reduce tax liability. Tax planning is the basic and important part of the financial plan and helps to save our capital. There are many options that provide deduction in the tax liability of the taxpayer, from which Section 80C of the Income Tax Act, 1961 is the most suitable option for an individual to claim the tax deduction. There are many schemes under Sec.80C which provided eligible deduction like under life insurance, contract for a deferred annuity, contribution by an individual provident fund, contribution by an employee to a recognized provident fund and to an approved superannuation fund, contribution in pension fund, etc. but one should reduce his tax liabilities within the framework of law.

As in the case of McDowell & Co. Ltd. v. CTO (1985) 3 SCC 230, McDowell & Co. Ltd. was a licensed manufacturer of Indian liquor. Appellant paid sales tax to the sales tax authority on the basis of turnover but excluded excise duty. The question raised before the SC was that whether the excise duty which was payable by the appellant but had been paid by buyers was actually a part of turnover. Here appellant tried to reduce the burden of sales tax for which the duty burden was directly transferred to the buyers. 

SC held that “tax planning may be legitimate if it is within the framework of law, but the colorable device cannot be part of tax planning. It is wrong to say that it is honorable to avoid payment of tax by the dubious method. It is the obligation of every citizen to pay tax honestly without resorting to subterfuges.”  

Tax Planning Objective

  • Reduce Tax Liability.- The main purpose of tax planning is to reduce tax liability imposed on a person. Every individual wants to reduce their tax burden and save that money for their future plans. So an individual can do so by prior planning and can avail all the benefits to reduce his tax.
  • Minimization of litigation.- Taxpayers want to minimize his legal litigations. After consulting his legal advisor and adopting proper provisions of law for tax planning can minimize the litigation. This can save taxpayers from legal harassment.
  • Economic stability.- If a taxpayer paid all the taxes without legally due then it will create a more productive investment in the economy. Prior plans help taxpayers as well as the economy.
  • Productivity.- If a taxpayer is aware of all the tax compliance and does productive investment planning then it will create more tax saving options for him.
  • Financial Growth.- If tax planning is done in the right manner and is going in the right direction, it will help in financial growth with economic growth.   

Features of Tax Planning

  • Reduction in tax liability.-  one of the most important features of tax planning is to reduce tax liability. Every individual has done his financial plan so he can reduce his tax amount and can save for his future plans.
  • Advance planning.- one has to arrange his tax plans at the beginning of the financial year because no one can plan to reduce his tax liability day before filing an income tax return.
  • Investment in the right direction.- with the help of tax planning one can invest his money in the right direction by choosing the right policy. Investment in any assets or policy will not help in saving money from taxes, for this right investment should be done.
  • Dynamic in nature.- tax planning has to be done every year because of the new implementation of policies introduced by the government. One has to modify his tax plans at the beginning of every financial year.  

Areas of Tax Planning

For implementing tax planning one can use different ways to save his tax money. There are some areas where we can plan to reduce our tax liability-

    1. Reducing Taxable Income .- one can use government schemes and programs to reduce his taxable income, it will directly reduce his tax liability. One should try to minimize his taxable income to reduce his tax amount.
    2. Deduction planning.- there are many deductions provided by a taxation law. One should implement and plan those deductions. The major area of the deduction is available under Sec.80C where one can claim a deduction for life insurance, mutual funds, home loan interest and many more.
    3. Investment in tax planning.- assessee can invest in policy for future plans and save his money from tax.
    4. Year-end planning strategies.- one can reduce his tax liability for the next year by prepaying those expenses which will be imposed next year and can make a strategy before starting the new financial year. 

Tax Planning Examples

Tax planning is an arrangement to reduce tax liabilities. How can an individual reduce his tax liability by planning at the beginning of the financial year? Let’s take a look at some examples-

  1. Mr. W who is an individual of age 45 years, whose taxable income is rs.5,00,000 and except a premium of medical insurance of rs.10,000 he has invested no money in any scheme. After calculating all his income details and deduction his gross tax amount will be rs. 16,224.
  2. Mr. Y who is an individual of the same age as Mr. W and all the income details are similar to Mr. W. But Mr. Y invested his money in schemes offered by the government under Sec.80C, his gross tax amount will be rs.0.

This is how one can reduce his tax liability by investing in the right schemes and programs or otherwise has to pay high tax rates.

Tax planning and Tax Management

Tax planning helps in reducing tax liability, where tax management is to consider all the law provisions and work within those provisions. 

 

            Tax Planning

                   Tax Management

The purpose of tax planning is to save tax from reducing tax liability.

Tax management is to work within the provisions of law.

There is an involvement in tax management.

Tax management involves return file, audit, deduction etc.

Tax planning is done for future investments.

Tax management focuses on all the aspects whether for past, present or future.

Tax planning is optional and done for the long term and short term savings.

It is mandatory for all the assessee and focuses on avoiding interest, penalty, etc. 

Tax Planning and Tax Evasion

Tax Evasion is not a legal practice to avoid tax liabilities. To avoid tax in an illegal manner like giving untrue statement knowingly, submitting misleading documents, suppression of facts, misguided by not maintaining proper account of income earned will lead to punishment under relevant laws for tax evasion. In this context, The Court in the case of CIT v. Sri Abhayananda Rath Family Benefit Trust [2002] 123 Taxmann 81 (Ori.), said that ‘evasion’ necessarily means, ‘to try illegally to avoid paying tax’.

Let’s understand Tax Avoidance and Tax Evasion by an illustration –

In a state say, Punjab, the government has granted exemption from excise duty for five years to the industries with the purpose of increasing industrialization in these areas.

If a manufacturer sets up his industry in Punjab is Tax planning. But he brings an almost ready product to Punjab just for minor operations and sells it in Punjab. This is Tax Avoidance. Here the purpose of government was defeated. 

If a manufacturer manufactures the good somewhere else and dispatches it there but shows that product manufacture and sold in Punjab. This is a Tax Evasion. 

Tax Avoidance

Tax Avoidance is reducing tax liability in legal ways. Tax avoidance is done by taking advantage of loopholes of the law. Provisions of law interpreted in such a manner that it will avoid payment of tax. No element of mala fide motive present in tax avoidance. Even the Court in the support of the tax avoidance said that tax avoidance is not unlawful and the taxpayer can take its advantages. One can minimize his tax liability within the legal framework even by taking advantage of loopholes in the law.

Essential Features of Tax Avoidance are as follow-

  • Legitimate arrangements should be in such a manner that will minimize the tax liability. 
  • Tax avoidance is in respect of legal provisions and carries no public disgrace with it.

Difference between Tax Avoidance and Tax Evasion

Tax Avoidance and Tax Evasion both practices are done by taxpayers to avoid tax liabilities. But both the practice has different legal provisions.

                    Tax Avoidance

                      Tax Evasion

1. Any tax planning which is done to reduce tax liability by legally permissible ways is tax avoidance. 

1. All the illegal methods by which tax liabilities are avoided is tax evasion.

2. Tax avoidance takes into account of loopholes of the law.

2. Tax evasion is done by unfair means like fraud, suppression of facts, etc.

3. Tax avoidance is done within the legal framework.

3. Tax evasion is not legal and assessee who is guilty under evasion will be punished under the provisions of law.

4. Tax avoidance is intentional tax planning.

4. Tax evasion is the intentional avoidance of tax when the tax liability arises.

 

Need of Tax Planning

Tax planning is essential to point in a person’s life. As the Government imposed high tax rates so, to reduce that tax liability there is a requirement of tax planning. There are many schemes and offers provided in taxation law. One has to choose the right scheme where he can invest and avail the benefits of those schemes. Many Benefits are provided to assesses like-

  • Deduction under Section 80C
  • Deduction for HRA
  • Deduction on education loan
  • Investment in senior citizen scheme
  • Investment in mutual funds 
  • Investment in national saving schemes
  • Any many miscellaneous schemes.  

Tax Planning benefits

Tax planning should be done to reduce tax liability but what are other benefits of tax planning? Let’s discuss here, a very important factor of tax planning and every individual or company focus on this factor i.e, to save tax. The main purpose of tax planning is to save capital from taxes and use it for the more beneficial purposes like invest in some beneficial scheme. Better to save the money at the beginning of the year by planning better to spend it in paying tax. One should avail the offers as much as he can, so he can spend that money in any other way or save for his future plans.

Methods of Tax Planning

  • Short-Range Tax Planning.- short-range tax planning involves year to year planning to complete some specific and limited objects. In this type of tax planning, one can invest in PPF or NSCs within the prescribed limit of income.  
  • Long-Range Tax Planning.- unlike short range tax planning, long-range tax planning are those activities undertaken by an assessee, which does not pay off immediately. This starts at the beginning or the income year to be followed around the year. 
  • Permissive Tax Planning.- Permissive tax plannings are permissible under a taxation law. In India, there are many provisions of law which offers deduction, exemption, contribution and incentives. E.g. Sec. 80C of the Income Tax Act which offers deduction, contribution, subscription, etc.
  • Purposive Tax Planning.- Purposive tax planning refers to those plannings by which taxpayers can avail maximum benefits by applying provisions of law based on national priorities. Section 61 to 65 of the Income Tax Act talks about the income of another person included in the income of the assessee. So, the assessee can plan in such a manner that these provisions do not get attracted and it would increase disposable resources.  

Corporate Tax Planning 

Tax planning regarding Residential Status

Non- residents

Tax liabilities for non-residents under tax law-

  1. A non-resident person in India is one who has not completed the basic condition of being a resident of India. A Hindu Undivided family can also be non-resident of India as an individual. If a firm or an association of persons who are said to be resident in India, control or manage the affairs wholly outside India will also be non-resident.
  2. Foreign income is not taxable in the hands of non-resident in India.
  3. Under Sec.9 certain income is deemed to arise in India even if it may arise outside India.
  4. Tax paid on behalf of the non-resident/foreign companies in respect of other income shall not be taxable under Sec. 10(6B).

And many other provisions with respect to non-resident in India like- 115A, 115AB,44BBA, etc.

For non-resident government provide relief of Double Taxation. Double taxation is, the person is liable to pay taxes in two different countries, one is from where he earned and another one is where he is resident. So to avoid this double taxation Government of India has signed avoidance agreement with other countries under Sec. 90. And if there is no agreement exists between the two countries then double tax income governed by the provision of Sec.91.  

Residents

Section 6 of the Income Tax Act provides Residential status of Indian. As per Sec.6 if any person resident in India in the previous year for 182 days or more, and during the previous four years resident for 365 days or more.

The tax law has categorized the residents into two parts i.e.,

  • Resident and non-ordinarily resident (RNOR)
  • Resident and ordinarily resident (ROR)

For RNOR, the individual has been Non-Resident in India for at least 9 fiscal years out of 10. In the previous 7 years, he has been in India for 729 or fewer days.

Tax planning for New Business

Any person or company can do their financial planning to reduce their tax liability. An individual can plan his tax liability by contribution in government schemes, deduction, subscription or any other exemption provided by law. But how can be tax planning is done with reference to setting up of new business, financial management decision, employee remuneration, etc. we will discuss it here.

Setting up a new business

To set up a new business, one has to decide the following matters-

Location of the new undertaking

Many factors can affect the location of business for the purpose of better tax planning, there are some tax incentives provided by law-

  1. Free Trade Zone under Sec. 10A provides a deduction to newly established undertakings for which some conditions should be satisfied like- undertaking must begin manufacture/production in Free Trade Zone, the industrial undertaking should not be formed by the splitting up or reconstruction of a business already in existence except those undertakings which are referred under Sec. 33B.
  2. Hundred percent export-oriented undertakings under Sec. 10B 
  3. Deduction under Sec. 80-IB in respect of profits and gains from certain industrial undertakings like- business of an industrial undertaking, operation of a ship, hotels, industrial research, production of mineral oils, developing and building housing projects, convention theatre, etc.
  • Manufactured product under that undertaking

Many incentive Acts are provided by the law, in regard to the nature of the business on which deduction or exemption will be provided, are as follows-

  1. Newly established industrial undertakings in Free Trade Zone under Sec. 10A.
  2. Hundred percent export-oriented undertakings under Sec. 10B.
  3. Venture Capital Companies (VCC) under Sec. 10 (23FB).
  4. Infrastructure Capital Companies under Sec. 10 (23G)
  5. Tea/Coffee/rubber development account under Sec. 33AB
  6. Site restoration fund under Sec. 33ABA
  7. Amortization of telecom license fees Sec. 35ABB
  8. Deduction in respect of expenditure on specified business under Sec. 35AD
  9. Amortisation of preliminary expenses under Sec. 35D
  10. Amortisation of expenditure on prospecting of certain minerals under Sec. 35E
  11. Deduction under Sec. 36(1)(viii) by a financial corporation and a public company.
  12. Special tax provisions under Sections 42, 44BB, 44AD, 44AE, 44AF, 44B, 44BBA, 44BBB, 44D, 115A, 115AB, 115AC, 115AD, 115BBA and 115D.
  13. Deduction in respect of profits and gains from industrial undertakings engaged in infrastructure development etc. under Sec. 80-IA
  14. Profits and gains from industrial undertakings other than infrastructure development under Sec. 80-IB
  15. Profits and gains of undertakings in a certain special categories of states under Sec. 80-IC.
  16. Profits and gains from the business of collecting and processing of biodegradable waste under Sec. 80JJA
  17. Employment of new workmen under Sec. 80JJAA.
  • The legal form of Organisation

One can decide tax liabilities under different organization forms while comparing other factors and tax incentives like how a person can reduce his tax liability by availing tax incentives provided under the law.

Tax Planning With Reference To Financial Management decision

Many tax provisions affect financial management decision, some provisions are discussed here-

  • Capital Structure

Capital structure is the amount of debt or equity to fund the operation and finance assets of the company. By Capital structure shareholder’s return can be maximized. This structure is known as debt-to-equity or debt-to-capital ratio. 

Under taxation law, dividend on shares is not deductible, while the interest paid on interest borrowed capital is allowed as deduction. 

  • Dividend Policy

A dividend is part of a profit which is distributed among the shareholders of the company. Dividend from an Indian company is not taxable under law but dividend from a foreign company is taxable in the hands of shareholders. As per Sec. 194, no deduction shall be made in the case of a shareholder if- 

  1. The dividend is paid by an account payee cheque; 
  2. The aggregate amount of such dividend distribution of that financial year does not exceed two thousand five hundred rupees.
  • Inter- Corporate Dividend

Deduction on the inter-corporate dividend is given under Sec. 85A, where the total income of an assessee being a company includes any income by way of dividend received by it from an Indian company or a company within India shall be entitled to a deduction from the income tax.

  • Bonus Shares 

Tax consideration for equity shareholders and preference shareholders are as follow-

For equity shareholders, at the time of the issue of bonus share, there is no tax liability of the company as well as shareholders. But at the time of liquidation of the company bonus shares in the hands of the company will be treated as Dividend distribution and company has to pay dividend tax but that amount will be exempted in the hands of shareholders. 

In the case of preference shareholders, if the bonus shares issued before June 1, 1997, then there will be no tax liability for the company and for shareholders it will be deemed as dividend, and if bonus shares issued after June 1, 1997, then there will be no tax liability on shareholders and for the company it will be chargeable as dividend tax. At the time of redemption or liquidation, there will be no tax liability on the company and shareholders too. 

Tax Planning and Managerial Decision

Tax planning affects managerial decisions too, like-

  • Make or Buy- make or buy decision is based on the costing and non-costing considerations. A consideration which affects the decision is –
    • Utilization of capacity
    • Inadequacy of funds
    • Latest technology
    • The variable cost of manufacturing
    • Dependence upon supplier
    • Labour problemOther factors

Provisions under the law are available for the manufacturer to make the right decision. These sections are 10A, 10B,32, 50, 80-IA and 80-IB. 

  • Own or Lease.- if assessee obtains assets on lease then he can claim the lease rental as a deduction, but if he purchases that assets than he can claim depreciation on those assets under section 32.
  • Purchase by Instalment v. Hire.- if assets purchased by installment then the deduction can be claimed under section 32. If assets are hired then the deduction can be claimed on hire charges.
  • Renewal or Renovation.- before claiming a deduction for renewal, renovation, repair or replace, one should keep in mind whether the deduction for these considerations is available under section 30, 31, or 37(1). If the deduction for revenue expenditure is allowed then tax liability can be reduced.  

https://lawsikho.com/course/advanced-corporate-taxation-gaar-mat-tds-dtaa

 Click Here

Tax Planning With Reference To Employees Remuneration

In the case of remuneration planning one has to consider that while calculating an employer’s income, remuneration paid to the employees is deductible. If such expenditures are not deductible under the employer’s income then the tax bill of the employer will increase. Tax incentives for deduction of remuneration in the hands of an employer-

  1. Revenue expenditure incurred by an assessee who himself carries on scientific research in regard to business shall be deductible under Sec. 35(1).
  2. Any premium paid on the health of the employee is allowed as a deduction. But only if that premium paid under the scheme framed under this behalf by General Insurance Corporation of India under Sec. 36(1)(ib).
  3. A bonus or commission paid to an employee is deductible under Sec. 36(1)(ii) only if that bonus or commission shall not be payable to an employee as profit or dividend.
  4. Employees contribution to staff welfare schemes under Sec. 36(1)(va).
  5. If any expenditure incurred by the company for promoting family planning among its employees is allowable as a deduction under Sec.36(1)(ix).

Tax Planning With Reference To Amalgamation of companies

Amalgamation is defined under section 2(1B) of the Act, amalgamation is a merger of two or more companies to form a new company or merger of companies in an existing one. All the Tax liability after merging of companies is on the amalgamated companies. All the properties of amalgamating companies are transferred to the amalgamated company. Some Benefits available to companies after amalgamation are-

  • Exemption under section 47(vi) for capital gains of amalgamating companies;
  • Exemption under Section 47(vii) in the case of international restructuring;
  • Exemption under section 47 (vii) for any transfer by shareholders of a capital asset;
  • Section 72A which provide an exemption to amalgamated companies to carry forward and set off of an accumulated loss and unabsorbed depreciation allowance in amalgamation and demerger etc.  

Tax planning for Individuals 

Tax Planning Strategies

Tax planning strategies are a plan to reduce tax liability by availing the advantages of schemes and programs offered by the government to an individual or an organization. The motive of tax planning strategy is to use the schemes for the reduction of tax liability in the right direction and in a lawful manner. As we have discussed, there are many schemes and programs which are offered by the government. Let’s take a look 

  • Deduction under Section 80C.- section 80C covers a wide area for a tax deduction which offers a number of schemes and plans where one can invest his money and save it from tax.
  • Deduction for HRA.- house rent allowances given under Section 10(13A) where employees are exempted from paying tax who lives in a rented room/apartment.
  • Deduction on education loan.- under section 80E one can save his tax, as per this section deduction is allowed on the loan taken by an assessee for his higher education or for the higher education of his relative.
  • Rebate for home loan.- one can save his tax on home loan principal repayment or home loan interest payment. Under section 80C assessee can claim for principal repayment and section 24b for home loan interest.
  • Planning for Long term capital gain.- under long term capital gain, one can claim for deduction on the sale of long term capital assets. Here, long term capital assets mean by for 3years or more.
  • Donation exemptions.- donation exemption can be claimed under section 80G if the assessee has donated any amount for NGOs or for any political party. 

Tax Planning Salary

Before planning tax liabilities to reduce tax limit one should know how much salary is taxable and what allowances are not taxable. Just take a look –

  • Basic salary.- A basic salary is the fixed amount that is paid to the employee before adding any bonus or surplus charges or reduction in any investment.
  • House Rent Allowance.- house rent allowance is that amount which paid to those employees who live in a rented house or apartment for the employment purpose. House rent allowance is not taxable under income tax but if the employee who gets house rent allowance and live in his own house then that amount will be taxable.
  • Leave Travel Allowance.- leave travel allowances are exempted under income tax where it is provided that allowance will be claimed on short distance trips within India. Employees directly cannot claim this exemption.
  • Bonus.- bonus is the additional amount given by the employer to his employees. Bonus can be given on some occasion or can be based on the performance of employee whatever it is, will be completely taxable.
  • Provident Fund.- provident fund is a scheme started for the employees so they can contribute to this scheme and save money for their future. 12% of the basic salary contributed to the pension and provident fund of the employee.
  • Standard Deduction.- standard deduction is that amount which is not taxable and can reduce the tax liability. The employee can claim rs.50,000 as a standard deduction from his taxable income.
  • Professional Tax.- this is the tax imposed by the State government on a person. The maximum limit which the state government can levy on a person is rs.2,500 which is not taxable under income tax.

One can take help from these allowances and schemes to reduce his tax liability by reducing his salary. There will be a minimum tax on less salary. 

Tax planning for Salaried Employees

As we studied above, tax planning is a financial arrangement plan by a taxpayer to get the maximum benefit of their capital. Tax planning should not be confused with complete avoidance of tax, in any of the circumstances one cannot avoid his tax liability completely. Tax planning is a way by which an individual can minimize his tax liabilities and invest his capital for more fruitful results.

For a salaried individual, the tax planning approach should be in a proper manner so one can take advantage of Government Schemes. For taking advantage, firstly one should invest in saving schemes from his current year income to reduce tax liability.

And another is to plan some special measures to invest money in the pre-retirement stage for a post-retirement period. So there will be an assurance of proper and adequate flow of capital and one can enjoy his retirement period.

Tax Planning in Income Tax

To decide whether one should invest his salary in a particular scheme or not depends on what is a more suitable option for that person. To invest income in a particular income an assessee should have enough knowledge about schemes and investment under those schemes. As we have sub-categorized the options for tax planning available to the assessee,i.e.

  • Investment in government schemes

There are many tax provisions under which government provide benefit to assessees. So different assessee can choose different options as per their suitability. Like – some invest in life insurance corporation, some under pension fund according to their suitability. Now we will discuss government scheme one by one-

In all the government schemes Section 80C is the most tax-saving scheme under which people claim their taxes. Before the Assessment Year 2006-07, deduction under Sec.80C was provided under Sec.88, 88B, and 88C which has been now replaced. There are some schemes under Sec.80 where deduction allowed out of total income.

One can invest in a different category of schemes, like-

Tax-saving scheme.- there are some tax-saving schemes where contribution in those schemes will not be covered under taxable income and entitled to deduction under Sec.80C. These schemes are-

  • Life insurance policy
  • Contribution to Provident Funds
  • Contribution in Life Insurance Corporation or Mutual Funds
  • Investment in National Savings Certificate
  • Amount invested in Annuity Plans
  • The amount deposited in Pension Funds
  • Tuition fee  paid

Tax-free return scheme.- in tax-free return schemes, one can invest his capital under the following institutions-

  1. Post office.- one can invest in schemes offered by post office like- Post Office Saving Account Schemes and Public Provident Fund Schemes. 
  2. Life Insurance Corporation.- an individual can invest in different plans offered by LIC like- Whole Life Plan, Endowment Plans, Money Back Plan, Children Plan, etc.
  • Unit Trust of India.- Unit Trust of India governed by the Unit Trust of India Act which was formed to encourage assessee to invest their capital and to avail the benefits of the schemes provided by the government.
  • Public Companies and Corporation.- Public companies and corporations provide tax return benefit to an individual assessee under following schemes-
  1. Investment in equity shares
  2. Investment in bonds.

The return from the investment is totally exempted from Income Tax under Section 10. Investment in these schemes shall not provide tax liabilities but return from these investments shall be entitled to tax benefits.   

  • Deduction under other provisions

Number of Deductions provided under Section 80C to 80U of the Act. these deductions are allowed only to some specified assessee. Under these provisions, a deduction is allowed only when payment is made through the taxable income, and the total amount of the deduction shall not exceed the amount of Gross total income. Now, a deduction can be sub-categorized in two parts-

  • In respect of payment

Deduction in this category allowed only when there is a payment made by assessee falls under Sec.80C to Sec.80GGC, now we will discuss these provisions one by one for better understanding-

Deductions Under section 80C

This section covers a wider area for the assessee to avail the benefits of all the schemes and provisions. For most people, this is a suitable provision to invest their capital. The deduction limit under this Section is up to Rs. 1,00,000. Sec.80C says Deduction in respect of Life Insurance Premia, deferred annuity, contribution to provident funds, subscription to certain equity shares and debentures, etc. some major Schemes under this Section are-

  • Investment under Life Insurance Policy .- any person can contribute to a life insurance policy, where up to 20% deduction is allowed from the Gross total income of the assessee. For eligibility under this Section, one should pay the life insurance premium 
  1. On own life;
  2. On spouse’s life;
  3. On the life of all the dependent children minor or major;
  4. On joint life with any member discussed above. 
  • Contribution to Provident Funds.- Contribution by an employee to the Public Provident Fund or any other recognized provident fund by the government shall be deductible from his tax liability. 
  • Investment in National Saving Certificates.- Capital investment in the National Saving Certificate in the name of his own or his wife or children shall be deductible under Sec.80C. Interest other than investment shall also be deductible under Sec.80C.
  • Public Deposit Scheme.- contribution in any such pension fund which is set up by the National Housing Bank governed by Sec.3 of National Housing Bank, 1987. 
  • Investment in Annuity Plans.-  the amount paid by an individual under contract for deferred annuity payment on his own life, or spouse’s life or on the life of children or any other member of the Hindu Undivided Family shall be deductible.
  • Investment in Mutual Funds or pension funds.- amount paid as contribution in any pension fund scheme set up by mutual funds or Unit Trust of India shall be qualified for deduction under Sec.80C. 
  • Home loan Installment.- repayment of the Home loan borrowed by the assessee during the purchase or construction of residential house property then the principal component of EMI qualifies for the deduction under Sec.80C.
  • Tuition fee.- tuition fee paid by an individual to any university, college or school situated in India for full-time education of any of his two children shall be eligible for deduction under Sec.80C.   

Deductions Under section 80CCC

Section 80CCC talks about deduction in respect of contribution to certain pension funds. If an assessee paid or deposited any amount to the annuity plan of Life Insurance Corporation or to any other insurer in respect of receiving pension funds shall be eligible for deduction under Sec.80C but that amount should not exceed Rs.1,50,000 in the previous year.

Deductions Under section 80CCD

Deduction in respect of contribution to pension scheme of the Central Government. Where an assessee, being an individual employed by the Central Government or employee in any other case, as may be notified by the Central Government shall be eligible for deduction, but the amount he paid or deposited shall not exceed 10% of his salary in the case of an employee or in any other case shall not exceed 20% of his gross total income.

Deductions Under section 80D

Premium Amount paid by an assessee from his taxable income in respect of the health insurance for his own or his wife or his children health shall be deductible under this Sec. the amount should not exceed Rs.10,000 and Rs.15,000 in the case of a senior citizen. 

Deductions Under section 80GG

An assessee who is not in receipt of House Rent Allowance under Section 10(13A) shall be eligible for deduction in respect of house rent. For deduction under this Section, one should fulfill some conditions like-

  1. He shall be lived in a rented house due to his employment;
  2. He shall not get House Rent Allowances;
  3. He or his wife or his children should not have self-occupied houses in India.
  • In respect of receipt 

    These are the following provision under which deduction is qualified in respect of receipt-

  • Deductions Under section 80QQB

The deduction is allowed in the case of royalty income earned by the author, either whole of his income or three lakh rupees, whichever is less.

  • Deductions Under section 80R

Deduction in respect of remuneration from certain foreign sources in the case of professor, teacher etc. this section does not include remuneration in gross total income where remuneration received by assessee, outside India from any university or any other educational institution established outside India, for rendered his service as a professor, teacher or research worker.

This section provided that no deduction shall be allowed unless the assessee furnishes the certificate in a prescribed form along with the return of income.

  • Deductions Under section 80U

A deduction shall be allowed to a permanent physically disabled person. Assessee, whose earning capacity has been reduced because of disablement, then deduction of Rs. 50,000 in a year shall be allowed to him or in the case of severe disability Rs.75,000 in a year. Provided that assessee should provide a certificate from the medical authority in a prescribed form along with the return of income.

Other than these deduction provisions some other provisions under the Act are-

  1. Deduction in respect of certain donations for Scientific Research or rural development (Sec.80GGA);
  2. Deduction in respect of contribution given by any person to political parties(Sec.80GGC);
  3. Deduction in respect of loan taken for higher education(Sec.80E);
  4. Deduction in respect of loan taken for residential house property(Sec.80EE);
  5. Deduction in respect of interest on deposits in a savings account (Sec.80TTA);

Tax Planning Capital Gains

Capital gain is a profit arises from the sale of capital assets. Capital gain can be a long-term capital gain and short term capital gain. The capital gain exemption is provided under section 54 where capital gains tax rates divide by 0%, 15%, and 20%. In the 2019 amendment by the Finance Act under Section 54 where exemption provided for house property it is included that where the amount of capital gain does not exceed 2 crore rupees then assessee by his choice can purchase or construed two residential houses in India.

To avail, this benefit one needs to fulfill the following conditions provided under the Act-

  1. The time period of purchasing of new property shall be either before 1 year of selling the property or 2 years after selling that property.
  2. That capital gain should be invested in the construction of property which is necessarily completed within the 3 years of selling.

Other exemptions provided under taxation law are-

    • Section 54F provides Exemption for capital assets other than a house property. This section talks about long term capital gain.
    • Section 54EC in respect of capital gain not to be charged on investment in certain bonds, where the capital gain arises from the transfer of long term capital assets.
    • Section 54B provides that capital gain on transfer of land used for agricultural purposes not to be charged in certain cases.

Tax Planning Calculator

The tax planning calculator is an online tax calculating device so one can calculate his gross total income and the taxable amount and save his tax with the help of that calculator. One can access that calculator from anywhere, anytime. Generally, four steps include in tax saving calculator:-

  1. In the first step, one has to give his basic details about his age and financial year for which he wants to calculate his tax.
  2. Further, he has to provide his income details like how much income is taxable, interest on the home loan, etc.
  3. In next step details in regards to deduction under different schemes shall be provided;
  4. After calculating all the above details the tax saving calculator calculates the income that how much tax is payable.

Let’s understand this with an example-

An individual let’s say, Mr. S, the age of 35 years has to calculate his income of the financial year 2019-20. 

Particulars- 

His taxable income is rs.5,00,000 ;

Interest paid on a home loan is 12%;

Rental income received – rs. 10,000

Income from interest – rs. 50,000

Interest paid on loan- 8%

Deduction- 

Basic deduction – rs.30,000

Medical insurance – rs.20,000

Interest on educational loan- 8%

Interest from deposits – 8%

Donations to charity – rs. 3,000

After calculating the above details, the tax payable by Mr. S is rs.13,832. If we made some change in income details, let’s say income from interest is rs.10,000, then no amount will be taxable.   

Schemes Under Tax Planning

To save the capital and minimize the tax liability government provides numbers of the scheme under Income Tax, so one can make the right decision to invest his money with a low-cost investment and maximum benefit. There are some major schemes where an individual can invest his money for availing its maximum benefit.

  • Life Insurance Policy

One can claim the exemption for insurance policy under Section 80C of the Act. The interest rate of this plan is 0-6%. No limit of minimum and maximum investment is fixed. Under this policy, one has to pay the premium on his own life or spouse’s life or on children’s lives or any member in the case of HUF.

  • Health Insurance

Under Section 80D of the Act, one can claim an exemption for health insurance, where the assessee as an individual does not pay insurance on the health of the assessee or his family members or his parents on account of preventive health check-up to the Central government which exceeds the sum of twenty-five thousand rupees.

And in the case of medical expenditure incurred on the health of assessee or his family members or his parents, the amount does not exceed fifty thousand rupees. 

  • Public Provident Fund

One can invest his income under the Public Provident Fund and can claim an exemption under section 80C of the Act. The interest rate under PPF is 8% per annum, where minimum investment is Rs.500 and the maximum investment is Rs.1.5 lakh.

  • Equity Linked Saving Schemes (ELSS)

The major plans for saving tax liabilities are mentioned under section 80C. ELSS is one of the two equity mutual funds where its maximum investment limit is Rs. 1.5lakh per annum. One has to invest his capital for at least 3 years. Another equity mutual fund scheme is a Unit Linked Insurance plan.  

  • National Pension Schemes

The national pension scheme is an employer’s contribution towards employees NPS from his basic salary, which is up to 10% and deductible from tax liability. No maximum limit is fixed for investment and it is a low-cost investment scheme.

  • Senior Citizen Saving Schemes

Senior Citizen Saving Schemes is for those individuals who are of age 60 or above and in the case of age between 55-60, a person should be retired under superannuation or VRS rules. The interest rate of the scheme is 8.7% and the minimum investment amount is rs.1000 and the maximum limit is rs.15 lakh. The person who is a non-resident Indian or person of the Indian origin or member of the Hindu undivided family shall not be entitled to open his account under this scheme.     

  • National Saving Certificates

National Saving Certificate is an investment saving scheme offered by the government to every person who wants to secure his money. Assessee can invest by his own name or spouse’s name or on his children’s name or any member of the Hindu undivided family. The interest rate is 8% and this is a low-risk investment scheme, up to Rs.1.5lakh, which can be invested for a tax deduction under section 80C.

Tax Planning for Partnership Firm

A partnership firm is a business consists of two or more people who have a common goal and invest their money and assets for the accomplishment of that goal and share equal profit and liabilities.

Tax planning for a partnership firm is the most important issue for each and every partner. The primary focus to avoid tax levied by the government is to make proper tax planning. To maintain the growth of the business firm owners has to do arrangements to avail the benefits.

In a partnership firm, income tax is levied on all partners, so all the record and document of their income attached with partnership tax return form. Profit arises from sales of any assets that are taxable too.  

There are some exemptions or benefits provided in regards to the partnership firm, these are-

  • Section 40(b) talks about that amount which is not deductible in the case of
  1. Any payment of salary, bonus, commission or remuneration to any partner who is not a working partner;
  2. Any payment of remuneration to any partner who is a working partner but not authorized by the terms of partnership firm;

iii. Any payment of remuneration to any partner who is a working partner and authorized by the terms of partnership firm but the payment is for such period which is not authorized in any earlier partnership deed;

  1. Any payment of interest to any partner who is authorized by the terms of partnership deed and relates to any period falling after the date of such partnership deed for which amount calculated exceed by the rate of 12% simple interest per annum;
  2. Any remuneration to any partner who is a working partner and authorized by the terms of the partnership deed and relates to any period falling after the date of such partnership deed so far as the amount of payment to all the partners during the previous year exceeds the aggregate amount.
  • Section 10(38) provides that any income shall not be included in total income if that if that income arises from the transfer of long term capital asset, being an equity share in a company or a unit of an equity oriented or a unit of a business trust where further it is provided that  income by the transfer of long-term capital gain shall be taken in account of computing book profit and income tax payable under Section 115JB.
  • Deduction for Donation under Section 80G we have studied that no amount shall be included in total income if it is donated as a charity to any NGO or to any political party or to any charitable institution within India. No deduction shall be allowed if the amount exceeds rs. 2000 unless it is payable by any mode other than cash.
  • Section 44AD provides exemption on presumptive taxation for any business other than business related to plying, hiring or leasing goods carriages referred under section 44E or any business whose total turnover or gross receipts in the previous year does not exceed Rs. 2 crores.
  • Section 54E provides that capital gain not to be charged if the cost of long term specified assets is not less than capital gain arising from the transfer of original asset the whole of such capital shall not be chargeable under Section 45.

If the cost of long term specified assets is less than capital gain arising from the transfer of original asset, so much of the capital gain as bears to the whole of capital gain the same proportion as the cost of acquisition of the long-term specified asset bear to the whole of capital gain, shall not be charged under section 45

Zero Tax Planning

Zero tax planning is the way to reduce tax liability as much that the payable amount of tax will be zero. As we have studied all the provisions of the taxation law which provides deduction from tax liability. By planning and investment in the right schemes and programs, one can plan zero tax. There are many schemes like one can invest his money in mutual funds or claim deduction under Sec.80C up to 1.5lakh rupees and many more.   

Conclusion 

As we have discussed many tax incentives under the provision of law which focus and help in the reduction of tax liabilities. An individual or a corporate, who are taxable under the present tax regime can avail the benefits that arise out of these incentives. The income tax regime in India has evolved over time and has made it easier to plan and save their capital accordingly. It is suggested that one should avail of these benefits within the framework of the law.

The post Tax Planning – Everything You Need to Know appeared first on iPleaders.


GST: How To Register, File Returns And Claim Refunds?

$
0
0

 

This article has been edited by Mansi Bathija and written by Lakshay Kumar, a second-year B.A.LLB student of Delhi Metropolitan Education, Indraprastha University. In this article, he talks about the rules regarding registration. Refunds and Returns under Goods and Services Tax.

The indirect tax system in India is extremely complex. It has long been felt that the complexity of tax structure and the general legal framework dampen entrepreneurship and hinders the growth of businesses. India, in spite of being a single country, faces internal barriers to interstate trade, commerce, and business because of the prevailing multiplicity of tax structures. While the implementation of VAT helped in ironing out major tax rate differences yet the need for structural reforms continued to be felt. VAT implementation also helped in preparing the groundwork that is essential for bringing out the next level of tax reforms viz. the Goods and Services Tax (“GST”). In this article, we will focus on the compliances and procedure required to register under GST, claiming refunds and filing returns of tax paid.

Registration Rules Under Goods and Services Tax

Persons who have to Register 

Before understanding the concept of registration it is necessary that we must know who is liable to register under the Goods and Services Tax. Provisions regarding Registration are contained in Section 22 to Section 30 of the Central Gst Act, 2017.

According to Section 22 of the Act the following category of people have to register themselves under the Goods and Services Act.

  1. Every supplier who has an annual turnover of rupees twenty lakhs have to register themselves under the Goods and Services Act, 2017.
  2. In the case of a special category state severy supplier who has an annual turnover of rupees ten lakhs have to register themselves under the Gst Act.
  3. All the persons who were previously enrolled under different laws prior to the commencement of this act also have to get themselves registered.
  4. Any person who has taken over the business from the other person of the registered company also have to get themselves registered under this act.
  5. Section 22 clause 4 of the act says that in case the transfer of the company is pursuant to the sanction of the scheme, or it is related to the combining two or more companies or their is any demerger of a company or the orders of any High Court or any Tribunal, in that case the Transferee shall have to get himself registered under the GST Act.

Persons who do not have to register

The Central Government has also given exemptions under Section 23 of the act  to some category of people who do not have to get themselves registered namely:

  1. Any person who is involved in the supply of Goods and Services or both, and is exempted by law for not paying tax do not have to get themselves registered under the Goods and Services Act, 2017.
  2. Any agriculturist who is involved in the supply of the product which does not involve the cultivation of land.
  3. The government on the advice of the council from time to time through notices may specify the category of persons who may be exempted from getting themselves registered.

Compulsory Registration 

According to Section 24 of the Goods and Services Act, 2017 there is a certain category of people who have to get himself or herself registered, registration for them is compulsory, all these categories are mentioned below:

  1. Any person who is making an inter-state taxable supply is required to get himself registered.
  2. A casual taxable person making a taxable supply.
  3. Persons who are required to pay taxes under reverse charges.
  4. The non-resident taxable person making a taxable supply.
  5. Persons who make taxable supply of goods and services for other taxable people as an agent or otherwise are also required to get themselves registered.
  6. Input Service Distributor whether or not separately registered under this act or not.
  7. Every electronic commerce operator and every person who is supplying online information from outside India to any person living in India.
  8. Any other person who is notified by the government on the recommendations of the Gst Council.

Procedure for Registration

Section 25 of the Goods and Services Act, 2017 mentions the various provisions regarding the procedure of registration, some of the important provisions are mentioned below: 

  1. Every person who is liable to get himself registered under Section 22 and Section 24 has thirty days time to get himself registered from the date he becomes liable to registration. In the case of a casual taxable person or non-resident taxable person, the time for registration is five days from the date of the commencement of their business.
  2. A person would be granted single registration in a state or union territory, if a person has a different business in a single state or union territory then, in that case, he or she could be granted special registration subject to a certain condition as may be applied.
  3. Persons who are not required to get themselves registered can also get themselves registered voluntarily and all the provisions of the act shall apply to these persons.
  4. Persons who have obtained or required to obtain registration for an establishment in a union territory or a state and have a registration in the state or union territory then, then such registration would be treated as a distinct registration from the other registration.
  5. Another important requirement for the grant of registration is that every person must link their Permanent Account Number with the Income Tax Act, 1961 in order to be eligible for the grant of registration.
  6. If a person who is required to get himself registered fails to do that, a proper officer may take any action as may be prescribed under the Act, or may take action under any other law as may be acceptable.
  7. Apart from the category of people who fall under subclause 1 of Section 25, the Government may grant a Unique Identity Number, this Unique Identity Number may be granted to any specialized agency of the United Nations Organisations or any other consulate or embassy of the foreign country.

Deemed Registration

Section 26 of the Central Goods and Services Act, 2017 mentions situations when a grant for registration would be deemed to have been given.

According to Section 26 subclause 1 of the act if any person has obtained registration under the States Goods and Services Act, 2017, or under Union Territory Goods and Services Act, 2017, then in that case that registration would be deemed to have made registration under the Central Goods and Services Act, 2017.

Subclause 2 of Section 26 says that if any registration has been blocked under the State Goods and Services Act, 2017 or under Union Territory Goods and Services Act, 2017 then that rejection would be deemed to be rejected under this act also.

Amendment to Registration

According to Section 28 any person may inform the concerned officer to make some changes in the information presented to him at the time of registration or subsequent to it, through a proper procedure, the officer concerned shall have the power to either accept the changes or reject the changes but he can not reject the changes without giving the other person a chance to speak for himself.

Cancelation of Registration

Section 29 of the CGst Act, 2017 provides provisions regarding the cancelation of registrations some of the important points are highlighted below:

The officer in charge may at his own motion or through an application filed by the concerned person may cancel the registration as may be prescribed. However, the officer has to keep the following circumstances in mind :

  1. The business has been discontinued, transferred, amalgamated or demerged or disposed of as the situation may be.
  2. There has been a change in the constitution of the business.
  3. Or the taxable person is no longer liable to be registered under the act.

The officer can reject the application on the following grounds

  1. If the registered person has violated any of the provisions of the act as may be prescribed.
  2. A person who was supposed to pay tax has not filed his return for three consecutive periods.
  3. Any person who has voluntarily registered and has not started his business within six months from the date of registration.
  4. If the registration has been obtained by fraud, willful misstatement or any suppression of facts.

Certain important things to be kept in mind during the time of cancelation are that no cancelation shall happen before hearing the other side, second after cancelation the person concerned shall not be relieved of his liability to pay taxes due to him at the time of cancelation or after cancelation. The third cancelation of registration done under State Goods and Services Act, 2017 or Union Territory Goods and Services Act, 2017 shall be deemed to be cancelation under Central Goods and Service Act, 2017.

Revocation of Cancelation of Application

Section 30 of the act also gives a chance for revoking the application of cancelation either by the officer through his own motion or the concerned person may give notice for that effect to the officer within thirty days of the cancelation of the application.

The officer has the power to either accept the revocation application or reject it, but he can not reject it before giving a fair chance to the other person to speak. 

Refund rules under Goods and Service Tax

https://lawsikho.com/course/advanced-corporate-taxation-gaar-mat-tds-dtaa

 

Click Here

Refund of Tax

  1. As far as a refund of tax is concerned Section 54 of the Central Goods and Services Tax provides provision regarding the refund of tax. According to Section 54, any person who has paid off the tax or any interest shall apply for a refund through an application within two years of the relevant date.
  2. Section 54 also says that any agency of the United Nation Organisation or any consulate of the embassy refund under inward supply of goods and services can claim a refund by filing an application for refund within six months from the last day of the quarter from which supply was received. 
  3. Section 54 also mentions the list of documents which are required to be furnished with the application, the documents required are
  1. Any documentary evidence that may show that refund is due to the applicant.
  2. Any documentary evidence as the applicant may show that establishes that he is claiming a refund under the tax already paid or any interest on that already paid, and the incidence of such tax has not passed on to any other person.

Under Section 54 of the Central Goods and Services Act if any person claims refund, but has himself defaulted in furnishing any return then in that case the proper officer has the jurisdiction to either withhold the payment of such refund until the concerned person has paid off his due or filed his defaulted return or the officer may deduct the amount from refund to pay off any debt or penalty or return that was unpaid under this act or any such law.

Under Section 54 if the grant of refund is under an appeal or trial, and the commissioner thinks that granting the refund would affect the revenue in the said appeal or may cause fraud then the commissioner can withhold such refund as he may seem fit.

According to Section 55, the Government on the advice of the council may notify allowing any agency of the United Nations Organisation or any consulate of any embassy to claim a refund on the supply of goods or services or both.

According to Section 56 of the Goods and Services Act, 2017 if any refund which is to be refunded to any person is not given within 60 days then an interest not exceeding 6 percent shall be applicable on that interest from the date of the expiry of the refund period.

Consumer Welfare Fund and Utilisation

According to Section 57 of the Central Government Goods and Services Act, 2017 the Central Government is bound to establish a Welfare Fund that may include:

  1. Any income from the investment of the amount credited to the fund
  2. Any other money received by it. 

Section 58 of the act the consumer welfare fund would be utilized for the welfare of the consumers.

The welfare fund is required to maintain an annual account statement of its fund in consultation with the Comptroller and Auditor General of India.

Return rules under Goods and Services Act

According to Section 37 of the Central Goods and Service Act, 2017 every supplier except the input service distributor or non resident taxable person or any person who has been exempted from paying the tax, shall have to furnish electronically returns of the outward supply of goods and services affected during the tax period on or before tenth of the month succeeding the said tax period, as per Section 37, no return filed after the said date would be accepted as a valid return although the commissioner may accept the return filed after the said period only circumstances as he may seem fit.

According to Section 38 any supplier apart from the exceptions have a chance to delete, modify or verify the details pertaining to the outward supplies apart from that the supplier also has to furnish the returns of the inward supplies electronically as may be prescribed on tenth and not before 15 of the month succeeding the tax period of the said period.

If any person has filed a return and some error has been discovered, then the person concerned must rectify the error in time and then file the revised return and pay the interest which may be applicable.

One thing to be noted here is that no error would be rectified for the month of September after the end of the fiscal year to which such detail pertains or before furnishing the annual return whichever is earlier.

According to Section 39, every registered person has to furnish the return for every calendar month of every input and outward supply of goods and services by twenty of the month succeeding the tax period.

Similarly, any person paying a return of inward supply of goods and services or both quarterly has to pay the return electronically within ten of the end of such month.

Section 39 also permits the registered user to pay off the return of which he has not paid.

First Return

According to Section 40 of the Central Goods and Services Act, 2017 if any person who has made any outward supply of goods and services from the date till he is liable to registration till the date on which registration has been granted shall declare in the first registration furnished by him. 

According to Section 41, every registered person who has paid the return for the supply of goods and services shall be eligible for a credit on the input tax on a provisional basis to his electronic credit ledger.

Subsection 2 of Section 41 says that the input tax is eligible only on the payment of self-assessed output tax.

Matching, Reversal and reclaim of Input Tax Credit

According to Section 42 of the Act says that details of the inward supply furnished by the registered user will be matched for two things first with the outward supply furnished by the corresponding user and second with the integrated goods and services tax paid in respect to goods imported by him.

When the claims of credit of input tax have been matched with the outward supply and with the integrated goods and services tax paid in respect to goods imported by him then that claim of the input tax credit would be communicated to the registered user under a prescribed manner.

If some discrepancy under the claim of ITC if found would be communicated to the user and if the supplier is not able to clear the discrepancy then the amount of ITC would be added to the output tax liability of the registered user for the month in which such discrepancy was discovered.

Annual Return

Every registered person shall file the annual return electronically at the end of the financial year that is before thirty-first December. Every registered person who is required to get his accounts audited shall submit electronically the annual returns along with a copy of the audited account along with the value of supplies declared by them under the annual returns furnished by him.

Final Return

Every registered person who is required to furnish the final return and whose registration has been canceled shall furnish the annual returns within three months of the date of cancelation or the order of cancelation.

Notice to Return Defaulters

If a registered person who was bound to file the return fails to file the return under the prescribed period then, in that case, a notice would be issued upon him to file his return within fifteen days in the prescribed manner and form.

Levy of late fee

Every person who fails to file his inward and outward supplies that were due to him on time shall pay a fine of min hundred rupees every day and if the default still persists then a maximum of five thousand rupees has to be paid.

Conclusion 

The above article clearly shows how important it is to register under GST and after registration what all advantages a registered user can claim under the Goods and Services Act. sometimes it may be the case that instead of paying the requisite amount as the tax an individual ends up paying excess amount, under that situation the policy of refund under GST is present. Finally, every registered user to is registered has to file his return to the article also points out the various provisions as to how an individual can file a return and what are the penalties imposed if he is not able to file the return.

The post GST: How To Register, File Returns And Claim Refunds? appeared first on iPleaders.

Offences Against Women

$
0
0

This article is written by Neha Gururani, a student of Guru Gobind Singh Indraprastha University, New Delhi. In this article, she has discussed the provisions relating to the offences against women under the Indian Penal Code, 1860 with some landmark case laws.

Introduction

In the present scenario, the violence and the increasing crimes against women is witnessed by everyone across the world in some or the other manner. It indicates the enormity and pensiveness of the monstrosity perpetrated against women in recent years. The global crusade for the decimation of violence against women is a proof to this fact. The changes in the living standards, lifestyle, imbalance in the economic growth, changes in social ethos and meagre concern for the moral values contribute to a vicious outlook towards women due to which there is multiplication in crimes against women. Moreover, such incidents are a matter of grave concern and its structure is absolutely necessary so that the women of India could live with respect, honour, dignity, liberty and peace in an atmosphere free from atrocities, denigration and heinous crimes.

There are many legal provisions which punish the culprits committing offences against women. The Indian Penal Code though, provides provisions for women as a victim of many crimes such as murder, robbery, theft, etc. but there are certain crimes which are diametrically characterised against the women known as ‘Offences Against Women’. With the need of the hour, many new socio-economic offences have been enacted accompanied by various amendments in the existing laws with an objective to combat these crimes effectually. 

Classification of Laws related to Crime against Women

The laws associated with the crime against women may be classified into following two categories: Crimes against Women under the Special and Local Laws (SLL)

The crimes against women provided under the Special and Local Laws aim to obliterate the immoral and sinful practices and exploitation of women in the society. These laws are periodically reviewed and amended in order to bring off promptness with arising needs. Following are some acts comprising of special provisions to protect women and their interests-

Crimes against Women under the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC)

The Indian Penal Code, 1860,  lays down the provisions to penalise the culprit for the heinous offences against women. Various sections under IPC specifically deals with such crimes. 

  1. Acid Attack (Sections 326A and 326B)
  2. Rape (Sections 375, 376, 376A, 376B, 376C, 376D and 376E
  3. Attempt to commit rape (Section 376/511)
  4. Kidnapping and abduction for different purposes (Sections 363373)
  5. Murder, Dowry death, Abetment of Suicide, etc. (Sections 302, 304B and 306)
  6. Cruelty by husband or his relatives (Section 498A)
  7. Outraging the modesty of women (Section 354)
  8. Sexual harassment (Section 354A)
  9. Assault on women with intent to disrobe a woman (Section 354B)  
  10. Voyeurism (Section 354C)
  11. Stalking (Section 354D)
  12. Importation of girls upto 21 years of age (Section 366B)
  13. Word, gesture or act intended to insult the modesty of a woman (Section 509)

This article further scrutinizes and expounds some of these odious and punishable offences as mentioned under the Indian Penal Code, 1860.

Sexual Offences against Women

The Indian Penal Code mentions sexual offences against women under a separate head which encompasses the following offences with their respective sections-

Rape [Section 375 & 376]

Section 375, IPC defines rape. In simple terms, the offence of rape is the ravishment of a woman, without her consent, by force, fraud or fear. In other words, it is the carnal knowledge (penetration of any of the slightest degree of the male organ of reproduction) of any woman by force against her will. It is an obnoxious act of highest degree which violates the right to privacy and sanctity of a female. Apart from being a dehumanizing and perverted act, it is also an unlawful interference in the personal life of a woman which is an intense blow on the honor, dignity, reputation and self-esteem of a woman. This outrageous crime not only causes physical injury to the victim but also humiliates, degrades and leaves a scar on the most precious jewel of a woman i. e. her character and dignity.

Essential Ingredients of Rape

Section 375 has the following two essential ingredient-

  • Actus Reus: There must be sexual intercourse, as understood in terms of the provisions of Section 375 (a) to (d), with a woman by a man.
  • Mens Rea: The sexual intercourse must be under any of the seven circumstances as given under Section 375.

Punishment for Rape (Section 376)

Section 376 provides punishment for committing the heinous crime of rape. This section is divided into two sub-sections.

Section 376(1) provides a minimum sentence of seven years of imprisonment that may extend to life imprisonment and fine.

Section 376(2) provides punishment not less than ten years of imprisonment but may extend to imprisonment for life or death or fine. 

Gang Rape (Section 376D)

Section 376D lays down the punishment for gang rape. Where a woman is raped by more than one person acting in futhereance of a common intention, each of them shall be liable for the offence of rape and shall be ounished with rigourous imprisonment for not less than twenty years which may extend to lifetime imprisonment and fine.

Relevant Case Laws

Case: Priya Patel v. State of M.P.[1]

Facts: The prosecutrix was returning home after her sports meet and the husband of the appellant met her at the railway station and told her that her father has sent him to pick her. He took her to his house and raped. During the commission of rape, appellant (the wife) entered the room and prosecutrix asked for the help but instead of savinf her, the appellant slapped her and closed tthe door and left the place of the incident. The accused husband was charged under Section 376, IPC whereas the appellant wife was charged for commission of offence punishable under Section 376(2)(g), IPC. 

The appellant wife challenged the legality of the charge framed against her under Section 376(2)(g), IPC on the ground that since a woman cannot commit rape and so cannot be convicted for commission of ‘gang rape’.

Judgment: The court held that a woman cannot said to have an intention to commit rape. Therefore, the appellant cannot be prosecuted for alleged commission of an offence punishable under Section 376(2)(g).

Case: Tukaram v. State of Maharashtra[2]

Facts:  Mathura, a Harijan girl developed intimacy with a boy, Ashoka. Her brother lodged a report in the Police Station that Mathura had been kidnapped by Ashok. After sometime, Mathura was brought to the Police Station and statement was recorded. Since, it was late at night, so there were two constables (appellants) present at the police station at the time. The appellants asked Mathura to stay at the police station and asked her companions to wait outside. One of the appellants took her into the washroom and light a torch focusing on her private parts and thereafter dragged her and raped in spite of her protests. Then, the other appellant came and wanted to rape her but couldn’t as he was highly toxicated. Since, all the lights of the police station was off and nothing was visible, the companions of Mathura called her name and shortly afterwards, Mathura emerged out of the police station and alleged that one of the constables had raped her. The crowd became aggressive and so, her FIR was lodged on behalf of her statement. Doctor’s report stated that there was no injury on the body of Mathura. Her hymen revealed old ruptures. The appellants contended that since there was no direct evidence about the nature of the consent of the girl to the alleged act of sexual intercourse, it can be inferred from the available circumstances that she did this with her passive submission.

Judgment: The court held that no marks of injury was found on the body of the girl after the incident and this indicates that the intecourse was a peaceful affair and the story made by the girl was fictitious. Therefore, no offence is brought against the appellants. 

This case is popularly known as ‘Mathura Rape Case’.

After this case, it was interpreted by the Apex Court in many cases that  to constitute the offence of rape, it is not important that there must be some injury on the body of the victim.

Outraging the Modesty of Women [Section 354]

Section 354, IPC deals with the offence of molestation i.e. assault to woman with intent to outrage her modesty. This section aims to protect women against any sort of indecent or filthy behaviour by others which is derogatory to her modesty. This offence is not just against the individual but also against the society and public morality. Therefore, if any person uses criminal fore upon a woman with an intention to outrage the modesty of a woman, he is deemed to be punished with an imprisonment of not less than one year which may extend upto five years with fine.

It is not specifically defined under IPC that what constitutes an outrage to woman’s modesty. However, the court has interpreted it in various cases. According to the Supreme Court, modesty is an attribute associated with female human beings as a class. Modesty is said to be outraged by such an act of offender which shocks and recognizes as an insult to female decency and dignity. 

https://lawsikho.com/course/certificate-criminal-litigation-trial-advocacy
               Click Above

For example, slapping a woman on her butt, asking her for sexual favours, disrobing her etc. 

Essential Ingredients of Section 354

The following are the essential of the offence under Section 354, IPC-

  1. The person who has been a victim of assault must be a woman
  2. The accused must have used criminal force on her
  3. An intention to outrage the modesty of a woman must be there.

Relevant case laws

Case: Rupan Deol Bajaj v. K.P.S. Gill[3]

Facts: The petitioner was an IAS Officer and accused was DGP, Punjab. The petitioner was invited to a party where the accused was also present. The accused asked the petitioner to come and sit next to him and when she went to sit, he pulled the chair closer to him and the petitioner was surprised by this act and she pulled her chair back to original place and again he pulled the chair closed to him. The petitioner asked him to leave but he again asked petitioner to accompany him in a commanding voice. She got apprehended and frightened and immediately pulled her chair back and turned to get out. At this point, the accused slapped the butt of the petitioner in the presence of all the guests which was very embarrassing for her. She filed an FIR against him. 

Judgment: The High Court quashed the FIR and held that the act was covered under Section 95, IPC.

The Supreme Court disagreed with the High Court and held that quashing FIR is illegal and Section 95, IPC is not at all applicable. The court further added that when an offence relates to the modesty of  women, it could not be trivial under any circumstance. Therefore, the accused was held liable under Section 354, IPC.

Case: Raju Pandurang Mahale v. State of Maharashtra[4]

Facts: The accused brought the victim to the house of co-accused on a false pretext. They confined her in the house and brought liquor which she was forced to drink. The victim was then disrobed and her nude photographs were taken.

Judgment: The Supreme Court held that the accused was guilty under Section 354, IPC as their acts were affront on the normal sense of femanine decency.

Case: State of Punjab v. Major Singh[5]

Facts: In this case, the accused had caused injuries to the vagina of a seven and a half months old child by fingering.

Judgment: It was held that the accused was liable for outraging the modesty of the child under Section 354, IPC. The court further added that the essence of a woman’s modesty is her sex. Young-old, intelligent or imbecile, awake or sleeping; women possesses a modesty capable of being outraged. 

Insulting the Modesty of Women [Section 509]

An act which is done intending to insult the modesty of woman which may not necessarily involve any physical force is brought under the shade of this provision through Section 509. This section  intends to deter any kind of aggression into a woman’s modesty whether by any word, gesture or act or by intruding upon the privacy of such woman. This section is also referred as the ‘Eve Teasing Section’

Any person who commits an offence under Section 509 shall be punished with simple imprisonment for a term which may extend to three years with fine.

Essential Ingredients 

This section requires-

  1. An intention to insult the modesty of a woman;
  2. The insult must be caused either by intruding upon the privacy of a woman; or by making any gesture or sound, uttering any word or exhibiting any object.

New Offences relating to Women

The Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 2013 added many new sections in the IPC, keeping in view the various new forms of offensive activities against the safety and dignity of women. Some are discussed below-

Disrobing a Woman (Stripping) [Section 354B]

Section 354B penalises the offence of assaulting or using criminal force to a woman or abetting any such act with an intention to disrobe or compel her to be naked, with a punishment of not less than three years which may extend to seven years with a fine. It is a gender specific offence i.e. only a man can be punished under this section.

Ingredients 

  1. The accused must be man.
  2. Use of criminal force or assault or abetment of any such act must be there.
  3. There must be an intention to disrobe a woman or compel her to be naked.

Voyeurism [Section 354C]

This offence came into existence after Nirbhaya Rape Case, 2012. It is mentioned under Section 354C, IPC. The word ‘voyeurism’ means appeasement derived from observing the genital or sexual acts of others usually ssecretly. This provision is divided in two different parts. Firstly, when a person watches or captures image of a woman engaging in some private  act and secondly, when the person disseminate or spread such image. 

The first offence is punishable with imprisonment of not less than one year which may extend upto three years with fine. The second offence is punishable with imprisonment of not less than three years which may extend upto seven years with fine.  

Ingredients

  1. The accused must be a male.
  2. He must watch or capture the image.
  3. The woman whose images are captured must be engaged in some private act.
  4. The circumstances must be such that she has the expectations of not being. observed by the perpetrator; or
  5. The accused disseminates that image.

Stalking [Section 354D]

Section 354D, IPC talks about The term ‘stalking’ which generally means the act of following or trying to contact despite disinterest of woman. This section contains two offences. Firstly, where a man follows or contacts or attempts to contact a woman repeatedly despite her clear indication of disinterest and secondly, where a man monitors the use by a woman of the internet, email, or any other form of electronic communication. 

For the first conviction, the punishment prescribed is imprisonment for a term which may extend to three years with fine. The punishment for second conviction may extend up to five years of imprisonment with fine.

Ingredients:

  1. The accused must be a man and victim must be a woman.
  2. Follow or contact a woman or attempt to contact; or
  3. Monitors the use by the woman of the internet, email or any other electronic communication.
  4. Despite disinterest of woman.

What does not amount Stalking?

Section 354D has a proviso attached to it which carves out an exception to this offence. If a part of responsibility is imposed on a person by the State to prevent and detect any crime and such acts must be pursued by any law and in the particular circumstances such conduct of the person must be reasonable and justified then, it will not amount to stalking.

Acid Attack [Section 326A & 326B]

The Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 2013 incorporated Section 326A and 326B with an intend to make specific provision for punishment in the case of acid attack. 

Section 326A focuses on voluntarily causing grievous hurt by using acid. In the view of this section, whosoever causes permanent or partial damage or burns, disfigures or disables any part of the body of a person or causes grievous hurt by throwing or administering acid with an intention to cause such injury or hurt will be punished with imprisonment of at least ten years which may extend to life imprisonment with fine.

Section 326B has more legislative focus on the act of throwing or attempting to throw acid with the intention of causing grievous hurt. The punishment under this section is imprisonment of not less than five years with fine which may extend upto seven years.

Essential Ingredients of Acid Attack

The following are the requisites of an acid attack-

  1. permanent/partial damage/deformity/burn/idfigure/disable any part of the body of any person; or
  2. Grievous hurt by throwing acid; or
  3. By using any other means;
  4. There must be an intention to cause injury or hurt. 

Sexual Harassment [Section 354A]

This new provision was originated in a judgment of the Supreme Court dealing woth the issue of sexual harassment at workplace. Through the Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 2013, Section 354A was inserted in the IPC which defines the offence of ‘sexual harassment’ and set down punishment for it.

According to Section 354A, a person shall be guilty of the offence of sexual harassment against a woman in the following circumstances-

  1. If he makes physical contact and advance unwelcome and explicit sexual act;
  2. Demands or requests for sexual favours;
  3. Shows pornography against the will of a woman;
  4. Make sexually colored remarks.

The punishment for the offences specified under Section 354A (1) (i) to (iii) is the rigorous imprisonment for a term which may extend to three years or with fine or both and in the case of sub clause (iv), it is imprisonment for a term which may extend to one year or with fine or both.

In 2013, the Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act was enacted to provide protection to women against sexual harassemnt at workplace and for the prevention and redressal of complaints regarding the matter of sexual harassment or any such incident thereto. 

Offences related to Marriage

Cruelty by Husband or his Relatives [Section 498A]

A separate chapter of IPC deals with the issues of cruelty by a husband or his relatives under Section 498A, IPC. the objective behind the introduction of this provision was to punish the husband and his relatives who torture, ill-treat and harass a woman with a view to force her or any other person related to het to meet any unlawful demands. 

This section has given a new dimension to the concept of cruelty which is the essence of this section, for the purpose of matrimonial relief. Not every type of cruelty will attract Section 498A. It has been mentioned under the section that what kind of cruelty is included hereby. 

The punishment for this offence is imprisonment for a term which may extend to three years with fine.

Essential Ingredients

To constitute an offence under Section 498A, the following are the necessary conditions-

  1. The victim must be a married woman/widow.
  2. She has been subjected to cruelty by her husband or his relatives. 
  3. Such cruelty consisted of either-
  • Harassment of a woman with a view to coerce her meeting a demand of dowry; or
  • A wilful conduct by the husband or his relatives of such a nature as is likely to lead the lady to commit suicide or to cause grave injury to her life, limb or health 
  1. That such injury inflicted either physically or mentally.

Dowry Death [Section 304B]

Dowry deaths and bride burning are sinful act which are still prevailing in the Indian society. It is a symptom of a special social illness and are unfortunate developments of our society. For this serious matter, the special provision was inserted under IPC through Section 304B which deals with dowry deaths. 

Section 304B (1) defines dowry death whereas clause (2) lays down its punishment which is not less than seven years and may extend to life imprisonment.

Essential Ingredients of Dowry Death

The following ingredients of the offence need to be established-

  1. The death of a woman must be caused by burns or bodily injury or otherwise than under normal circumstances.
  2. Such death must occur within the period of seven years of marriage.
  3. The woman must have been subjected to cruelty by her husband or any other relative of her husband.
  4. Such cruelty must be in connection with demand of dowry.
  5. Such cruelty must be shown out soon before her death.

Conclusion

Notwithstanding the number of laws to protect and safeguard the rights and interest of the women, the rate of crime against women and victimization is mushrooming day by day. It is well said that it takes two to tango. It implies that only laws are not responsible to regulate and control the augmentation of the crimes against women in our society. The suppression of evil eyes on women and inculcation of social ethics, morals and values, respect and honor in every human being towards women is the need of the hour and is a supplement factor that can equally contribute in reducing the number of crimes against women. However, there is an exigency of more strict and stringent laws so that any person intending to commit such crimes couldn’t screw up the courage to act in furtherance of his intention. 

References 

  1. 2006(6) SCC 263
  2. AIR 1979 SC 185
  3. 2005(6) SCC 161
  4. 2004(2) SCR 287
  5. AIR 1967 SC 63
  6. The Indian Penal Code, 1860 (Bare Act)

 

 

The post Offences Against Women appeared first on iPleaders.

Who is Liable for Misstatements in Prospectus?

$
0
0

This article is written by Merin Sony Thampy, pursuing Certificate Course in Companies Act. She is currently working as Senior Associate – Legal at LegalEase Solutions Pvt. Ltd., Kochi, Kerala.

Introduction

The purpose of this article is to examine the liability for misstatements in the prospectus of a company. Before going to the details of liability, a brief overview of the meaning and significance of the prospectus would be helpful.

What is a prospectus?

Pursuant to section 2(70) of the Companies Act, 2013, prospectus is a document that invites offers from the public for the subscription or purchase of the securities of a company. The term ‘prospectus’ includes not only a document described or issued as prospectus but also notices, circulars and advertisements offering invitation to purchase or subscribe the securities. Likewise, any document that offers sale of shares of a company by its members will also be deemed to be a prospectus (sec. 28(2)). The prospectus must contain such information and reports on financial information specified by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) in consultation with the Central Government (sec. 26(1)). The date of publication of the prospectus is deemed to be the date indicated in the prospectus. The Central Government, the Tribunal or the Registrar can invoke all powers in matters related to prospectus (sec. 24 Explanation).

Sec. 26 of the Companies Act sets out the matters to be stated in the prospectus as well as the steps required to comply with its registration. Sec. 26(9) deals with the punishment for issuing prospectus in contravention of the said provisions.  A company issuing such a prospectus shall be punishable with a fine of minimum fifty thousand rupees and a maximum of three lakh rupees. Also, every person who has a knowledge of the issue of such prospectus shall be punishable with imprisonment that may extend to three years or with a minimum of fifty thousand rupees as fine. The fine may extend to three lakh rupees, and the person may be awarded both fine and imprisonment. (How do we determine the mental culpability of a person? As in, how do we determine that he had the knowledge that it is a prospectus in contravention? What is the standard and on whom does the burden of proof lie?)

Misstatements in the prospectus

 Since prospectus is relied on by the members of the public to subscribe or purchase the securities of a company, any misstatements on it invite penal consequences. Misstatement may occur when a statement which is untrue or misleading in form or context is included in the prospectus. Also, any inclusion or omission of any matter which is likely to mislead will also be considered as a misstatement (sec. 34). For e.g., a statement on the purpose of offering shares which is untrue, or statement on the locations of offices for a company which is misleading will amount to misstatement in the prospectus. 

Liability for misstatement in the prospectus

A person who has signed and given consent to the prospectus is liable for misstatement. Persons who had the management of the whole, or substantially whole of the affairs of the company can be held liable for misstatement in prospectus if they have signed the prospectus and had given consent for the same. Managers, Company Secretaries, and Directors will come under this category. However, the mere signing of the declarations in the prospectus will not result in liability for misstatement if the person signing is neither a manager of the company nor draw salary from the company. In the Matter of Sahara India Commercial Corporation Ltd., SEBI 31 Oct. 2018. Here, SEBI considered the submission of the Company Secretary that he signed the prospectus on behalf of the directors under their power of attorney and concluded that he was not liable for misstatement as the director of the company.

https://lawsikho.com/course/diploma-companies-act-corporate-governance

Click Here 

Likewise, in Hafez Rustom Dalal vs Registrar of Companies, the Gujarat High Court observed that while issuing notices, the respondent authority has to point out the statements in the Prospectus which they consider false or deliberate or made to induce the public for subscribing the shares of the Company.

A misstatement in the prospectus can invoke criminal (sec. 34) and civil liabilities (sec. 35). Misstatements can lead to punishment for fraud under Sec. 447. 

  • Criminal liability

A person who authorizes the issue of a prospectus which has untrue or misleading statements is liable for punishment under Sec. 34. Such a punishment is for fraud as set out in Sec. 447. “Fraud” under Sec. 447 includes an act, omission, concealment of any fact with an intent to deceive, gain undue advantage, or to injure the interests of the company or its shareholders or its creditors or any other person. It is not necessary that such an act involve any wrongful gain or wrongful loss. Abuse of position committed by a person is also considered fraud under this section. Sec. 447 further sets out the punishment for fraud:

  • If the fraud involves an amount of ten lakh rupees or more, or one per cent. of the turnover of the company (whichever is lower) the person who is found guilty of fraud shall be punishable with imprisonment for a minimum term of six months which may extend to ten years. Such a person shall also be liable to a fine of an amount not less than the amount involved in the fraud and the fine may extend to three times of such amount.
  • If the fraud involves an amount less than ten lakh rupees or one per cent. of the turnover of the company (whichever is lower) and does not involve public interest, the imprisonment may extend to five years or with fine which may extend to fifty lakh rupees or with both.
  • If the fraud in question involves public interest, the term of imprisonment shall not be less than three years.
  • Civil liability

Civil liability for misstatements in prospectus will arise when a person has sustained any loss or damage by subscribing securities of a company based on a misleading prospectus (sec. 35). In such instances the following persons shall be liable under sec 447 and will have to pay compensation to persons who have sustained such loss or damage:

  1. director of the company at the time of the issue of the prospectus;
  2. person who has agreed to be named as a director in the prospectus and is named as a director of the company, or has agreed to become such director;
  3. is a promoter of the company;
  4. has authorised the issue of the prospectus; and
  5. is an expert who has been engaged or interested in the formation or promotion or management of the company.

Prohibition of the Company and directors from dealing with securities following misstatement

In the Matter of Taksheel Solutions Limited, the SEBI (25 Oct. 2013) found that the Red Herring Prospectus/Prospectus had several missing vital pieces of information which resulted in misstatement. SEBI had earlier prohibited the company, its promoters/directors and independent directors from buying, selling, or dealing in securities in any manner. The Board noted that the company had the duty to make true and correct disclosures and statements in the Prospectus to help the applicants take an informed investment decision. The Board further observed that the Prospectus failed to disclose a related party transaction too. Therefore, the Board confirmed the interim order of prohibition on the Company and its Promoters/Directors in dealing with securities. However, the Board vacated the prohibition on the independent directors who had resigned from the Company and had undergone the restraint for more than twenty-one months.

Suspension of the auditor for false certificate attached to the Prospectus

In The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India v. Mukesh Gang, Chartered Accountant, Referred Case. No.2 of 2011, the High Court of Andhra Pradesh noted that the prospectus is a special document and a false certificate is issued by the auditor would amount to his failure to discharge his statutory duties. The court added that he must be presumed to be aware of the consequences that flow from such gross negligence of a false certification because the public subscribe to the shares based on the invitation (Prospectus). The court further observed that as per Section 65 of the Companies Act, 1956 untrue statements in the prospectus will result in liability for the loss or damage sustained by a person while subscribing for shares or debentures based on such statements in the Prospectus. Here, the court found that the certification by the statutory auditor has resulted in misleading the general public into subscribing to the shares of the company by placing faith on such a certificate. Therefore, the court suspended the respondent from practising as a Chartered Accountant for a period of three years under Section 21(5) of the Chartered Accountants Act, 1949.

Exceptions from liability for misstatements in Prospectus

A person shall not be criminally liable under sec. 34 if he proves that: the statement or omission was immaterial or 

  • he had reasonable grounds to believe that the statement was true or the inclusion or omission was necessary and believed in it up to the time of issue of the prospectus. 

Likewise, a person shall not be liable under sub-section (1) of sec. 35 (civil liability), if he proves that:

  • he withdrew his consent to become a director of the company before the issue of the prospectus, and that it was issued without his authority or consent; or
  • the prospectus was issued without his knowledge or consent, and 
  • on becoming aware of its issue, he gave a reasonable public notice that it was issued without his knowledge or consent.

A person may not be liable for a misleading statement made by an expert if:

  • the report is a correct and fair representation of the statement, or
  • a correct copy or a correct and fair extract of the report or valuation; and
  • he had reasonable ground to believe that such expert was competent to make the statement and had given the consent required by sub-section (5) of section 26 to the issue of the prospectus and had not withdrawn that consent before delivery of a copy of the prospectus for registration. (sec. 35(2)(c)).

Conclusion

The prospectus being an invitation to the public to subscribe to the securities of a company must be made with utmost care. The public rely on the statements and reports attached to the prospectus to take an investment decision. Therefore, the Companies Act provide for liabilities and punishments for persons who provide misleading and untrue statements in the prospectus.  


Students of Lawsikho courses regularly produce writing assignments and work on practical exercises as a part of their coursework and develop themselves in real-life practical skill.   

The post Who is Liable for Misstatements in Prospectus? appeared first on iPleaders.

Tender and its Requisites

$
0
0

This article is written by Sri Vaishnavi.M.N., a first-year student of Damodaram Sanjivayya National Law University, Vishakapatanam. In this article, she discusses tender and the requisites of a valid tender.

Introduction

A tender is an offer. It is something that invites and intends to invite, acceptance. Sometimes, in the case of large contracts, a list is prepared, tabulated and the names of all contractors who have tendered are displayed; and in front of each name, it indicates the total price offered and also the observations made by the contractor or a particular condition that the contractor wishes to regulate its execution of the work.

An estimate is a valuation or statement, in advance, of the amount for which a certain job will be performed or can be performed. An estimate may or may not amount to an offer or offer to do the job for that price. Whether an estimate is an offer or not is a matter of fact, and an offer is an offer because it is described as an “estimate”.

The offer made is an offer to meet a condition or obligation together with the current capacity of immediate execution, so if it were not for the refusal of cooperation of the party to which the offer is made, the condition or obligation would be met immediately. 

As the condition or obligation in question may require compliance, be it payment or transfer of ownership, the offer may be related to money or property. In the strict sense of the word, there can be no offer, no service or other performance that requires time. The offer of an unfinished amount of money is also, in the strict sense, impossible to perform.

The issuance of the bidding forms is an invitation to make an offer, and as the offer must be acceptable, must be in the lines provided by the buyer, it is necessary to ensure that the invitation to tender includes all the necessary information and the form Bidding. 

It is written in such a way that the conditions of the contract and other documents are incorporated effectively. If it is intended that there be a “formal” contract, whether or not it is sealed, it must be indicated in the invitation. In addition, copies of the contract conditions and the proposed agreement must be submitted with the bid form (along with the specification, drawings, etc.), or at least be available for inspection. 

When the offers are received, they must be examined carefully to see if they comply with the terms of the invitation. A well-written bidding form and the use of standard contract conditions will go a long way towards ensuring this. Any alteration of the terms by the tender must be considered with a view, first, to see if they are acceptable and, secondly, to investigate what effect, if any, is likely to have, in the law, on the Contract conditions.

Requisites of valid tender

A tender is an offer. It is something that you invited and communicated to notify acceptance. In general terms, the following are the requirements of a valid offer:

  1. It must be unconditional.
  2. It must be done in the right place.
  3. They must conform to the terms of the obligation.
  4. It must be done at the right time.
  5. It must be done in the proper way.
  6. The person making the bid must be able and willing to fulfil their obligation.
  7. There must be a reasonable opportunity for inspection.
  8. The tender must be made to the right person.
  9. It must be of the total amount.

The above-mentioned points are discussed in detail below:

It must be unconditional

It is the essence of a valid offer that it must be unconditional. If the offer is accompanied by a condition that prevents it from being perfect or complete in itself, it cannot be considered as an equivalent payment and the promisee is not obliged to accept it and in a Lahore case, the plaintiff sent a single check for two items, only one of which was due at that time and the other was not due for a few years. He argued that the check that is one and indivisible can be accepted as a whole or not at all. It is clear, therefore, that for this reason, the bidding was not unconditional and the defendants had the right to reject it. 

But an offer of money is not tainted simply by asking for a receipt. Neither a tender made under protest is bad in law. An offer is not conditioned by the mere fact that the debtor specifies the account in which the money is paid. A check until the cash is not a good offer in the absence of an agreement to that effect.

One of the requirements of a valid offer is that the party making the offer must always be ready to fulfil the obligation when requested; or, in other words, an offer to be valid must be maintained in good condition, in accordance with the requirements of law.

In the case of  Steel engineering works Agrico (M / s.), Bishramur v. Southeast field ltd.., clause 23(a)(V) of the N.IT. clearly states that the Joint Venture Agreements (JV Agreements) must meet the requirements contained in subclauses (i) to (x) of clause 23(a)(V) of the respondents in the previous clause that the Joint Venture Agreement, which is presented together with the technical offer, must legally bind all the partners and, individually, for the purposes of the proposed agreement. It should establish principles for constitution/operation/ responsibilities with respect to work and financial agreements, participation (percentage in total) and joint and several responsibilities with respect to each and every one of the firms in the Joint Venture, while. 

Clause 8 of the joint venture agreement submitted by the petitioner states responds to the previous clause “that the Joint Venture Agreement binds the parties jointly and severally to the proposed agreement, which must establish the principles of the constitution, operation, responsibilities with respect to work and “Participation in financial agreements and responsibilities (only for the first part), with respect to each and every one of the companies in the joint venture.” 

Given that the liabilities were declared as property of the first part, only the JV Agreement was not found correct and the previous decision was made The difference between the requirement of “joint and several liabilities” and the “first-party liability” are two different things and no substitute can be presumed to the other, if the requirement of the NIT was the agreement that bound all the parties jointly and separately, the declaration of the res The ability to be owned by a single party, therefore, would not meet the bidding requirement.

The bidding authority is required first to decide who are the people who satisfy the essential mandatory conditions that are the criteria of rotation and the criteria of experience and then only perform the evaluation of offers with reference to other parameters. In this case, it was not done. 

Although the bidding committee treated the rotation criteria as one of the three mandatory conditions, the experience criteria were treated as “other qualification conditions”. This in itself amounts to a bad direction in the law. It is not denied before the Superior Court that of the eight tenders received, one of the tenderers meets the prerequisites for eligibility under general conditions, that is, the experience in the management of canteens in the state and government establishments of Bhavans. 

The entire exercise, therefore, suffers from this incurable defect in the decision-making process. There is no doubt that the petitioner in itself does not satisfy this condition, but the petitioner, the second respondent, and others were offered a relaxation of this condition and also with respect to a special condition that is only a “desirable” criterion. 

The notice published in the newspapers never indicated that the government would grant the relaxation of the general and special conditions. If only such a condition were reported, there would have been better people/organizations with better qualifications who could have submitted an offer for the contract.

In Ramana Dayaram Shetty c. Authority of International Airports, the Supreme Court considered such aspect of the matter and, although it did not grant any relief to the appellant and did not invalidate the contract granted to the fourth respondent, nevertheless, it found fault in the procedure adopted the bidding authority. For the same reasons, the Superior Court could not approve the method adopted by the first respondent or the bid committee to grant a relaxation of the prior eligibility condition that all bidders must meet.

It must be made at the proper place

The tender must be made in the place stipulated in the compliance contract, or if a provision is not made, then in the place determined by law. There are special rules regarding negotiable paper, with respect to the transfer of personal property, and with respect to the payment of rent by a real estate tenant, but apart from these special rules, the general principle of customary law is that the debtor must search for the creditor and make offers wherever it is found, and even without reference to this principle, the place of residence of the creditor at the time the contract was made will often be considered by a just implication of fact, the place of contract. 

In bilateral contracts, each party is both a debtor and a creditor, and when the return is due at the same time from each one, it follows that any of the parties wishing to put the other in default must seek to do so. an offer, unless the contract, custom or the rule of law prescribes a place where both actions are performed.

It must conform to the terms of the obligation

The offer must conform to the terms of the obligation. The offer must be made in a complete and early manner exactly how the promisor has accepted. The matter can be initiated by Karsale (Harrow) Ltd v. Wallis, where the defendant inspected a Buick car that subsequently wanted to sell and found that it was in excellent condition. Subsequently, the defendant signed a contract of purchase and contracting with respect to C. 

The agreement contained an exception clause that included the following terms: 

  1. There is no condition or guarantee that the vehicle is fit to move or in terms of its age, condition or suitability for any purpose. 
  2. The owner in this document stated that after the date of the agreement, the car was left at night outside the premises of the defendant and in the inspection by the defendant the next morning it was found that he was in a deplorable condition and capable of self-propulsion. 

It was held that the car delivered was not the contracted object. Denning, L.J, said the lender should know, in the ordinary course of business, that the lessee is based on the faith of his inspection and on the understanding that the car will be delivered substantially under the same conditions: and it is an implied term of the contract that is pending delivery the automobile will be kept in the proper order and will be repaired for the purpose of the rescue … exemption clauses of this type, no matter how widely they are expressed, only make use of the part when he is carrying out his contract in all essential aspects.

You are not allowed to use them as a cover for misconduct or indifference or to allow you to turn a blind eye to your obligations. They do not take advantage of it when they are guilty of an infraction that goes to the root of the contract. Sometimes it is said that the principle is that the party cannot depend on an exemption clause when it delivers something different in its contracted class or has broken a ‘fundamental term’ or a fundamental contractual obligation.

https://lawsikho.com/course/diploma-entrepreneurship-administration-business-laws

Click Here

It can be affirmed that the offer must be of the totality of the debt, the quantity of the merchandise to be supplied, neither more nor less, and in accordance with the contracted specification. Although the amount owed is uncertain or the disputed payment of any amount agreed between the parties is a satisfaction of the liability. 

When a settled amount is owed, the payment of a lesser amount cannot be like the satisfaction of the whole debt, unless there is a consideration the waiver of the balance or the circumstances are such that the creditor cannot take advantage of the absence of consideration.

However, bidding made as a basis for a concurrent right of exchange of the party to which the bidding is made may be conditioned to the execution by the letter of its obligation. But an offer of the fulfilment of an absolute obligation must be unconditional since the obligation in itself is conditional. The offer cannot be effective if its acceptance would harm the rights of the promise. 

However, a promoter may, by making an absolute offer, protest that the performance claimed by the promise and that granted by him is excessive and indicates that his performance offer is not voluntary and, therefore, reserves the right to recover for your excessive performance.

It must be made at a proper time

The tender must be made in a timely manner. Therefore, it has been argued that an offer of debt before the due date is not an impediment and will not prevent interest from accruing on the debt.

In the present case, it is not disputed that, once the sealed bids were opened, it was determined that the fifth respondent was the selected bidder, and only after that, the petitioner approached the court in writing with this petition.

Just because there was a violation of the schedule mentioned in the notification notice, the appellate court should not interfere in the matter, when the petitioner has not demonstrated that for the violation in question, he suffered actual harm in any way.

It must be made in the proper form

To be valid, the tender must be in the proper form. The payment must be offered in what is called “legal tender”, in the currency of the country or in the currency of the tickets. An insured coverage cannot be legally offered by him treated as legal tender. I have tried it as legal tender. By offering to verify or offer any item of value, even if that item has a value greater than that of the debt, the debtor cannot claim to have offered to pay the debt. The creditor was not required to accept the insured’s coverage simply because he was insured for a sum greater than the debt.

A mortgage to ensure a given number of wealth marks is a mortgage to secure reimbursement of what may be a legal tender currency for reimbursement in the country where Reichsmark circulates. 

The debtor must not request a change but must have the exact amount owed, unless he is willing to leave the surplus with the creditor. When the offer made by the tenant does not correspond to the total amount owed and the name of the sender is not disclosed. the offer is adequate an offer by means of a check or a voucher is not required unless the other party accepts it or has requested payment by check. In general, the payment of the money by check or voucher does not have to be a valid offer and it can be received subject to be subsequently honoured by the bank or the treasury. 

But when the coupon was charged, but because of the error in the endorsement due to the lack of attention by the plaintiff (the creditor), it has been accepted by the creditor and presented to the treasury.

He argued that there was a legal course. When a check was delivered but returned due to insufficiency, and then it was determined that the amount of the street was deemed to be good. The defendants were the creditors of a company in Mauritius and, to pay certain creditors of Mauritius, including the plaintiffs, the defendants sent hawalas that were a form of sinking, to eight of their creditors in Mauritius and, at the same time, They sent a letter to the company informing them that these hawalas have been sent to meet with them in the presentation. 

But the creditor for his pains or for his own reasons did not present it for payment until the person to whom the hawala was delivered became insolvent. It was argued that the hawala operated as the satisfaction of the debt and that the creditor should be treated as if he had had the hawala in satisfaction of the debt and could not be allowed to recover the amount through a lawsuit.”

A mere publication offers to pay the amount owed or to execute a document is not valid for a performance offer. In the same way, an offer made by a promisor through his lawyer to pay a debt with interest due has been maintained with a valid offer. When it was not urged that the beneficiary accept to accept the payment to the third party as equivalent to the payment to himself, it was that there was no type of suitable offer.

In fact, the sworn statement with the tender is an affidavit printed in format (Format 2-8), in which the bidder must mention that it is not included in the blacklist by any government/organization/ semi-governmental corporation of any state and/or disabled by the Punjab PWD department (B and R). There is no other format of the affidavit in terms of Clause 4.5 of General Conditions that have been invoked by the petitioner.

If the affidavit had been drafted and the defendants No. 5 had been suppressed or avoided to disclose the information required in the affidavit, it could certainly have been a suppression case and suggest to be false, but since the department did not respond to that requirement, 5 was not required to provide the information mentioned by the petitioner in the written request.

Therefore, it cannot be said that the defendant has made a misleading or false representation in the forms presented by him. In addition, it is not clear in Clause 4.5 of the General Conditions if the breach is related to the department in question or could be with respect to any other Department / Semi-governmental Organization or the State.

Ability and willingness

Another essential requirement of a valid offer is that it must be done in such circumstances so that the person to whom it is made can have a reasonable opportunity to make sure that the person by whom it is done can and is willing to do so and there is the whole. of what he is bound by his promise to do. An offer made by a promisor through his attorney to pay a debt with interest due on the date of the offer does not by itself provide a reasonable opportunity to promise to verify that the promisor can and is willing to fulfil its promise. Where it happens that the promisor and the fiancé live on the same street is not a circumstance that can take the case to the scope of that section promise.

The promoter cannot reasonably expect the fiancé to attend the residence or the promoter’s place of business in order to ensure that the promoter can and is willing to carry out the offer he has made. The debtor is not obliged to take the risk of offering a payment to a person whose right to receive the debt may be non-existent. If you take a risk, it is difficult to understand why the offer you make should not be subject to the same conditions that you would have had to meet if you had made the original promise.

However, ready and willing to pay a party may have been a tender in the law, unless there is, after the offer outside the Court the unconditional deposit in the Court of the money owed. In the present case, it is evident that the petitioner’s offer, although it was the highest and that was also called to negotiate by the RFC, finally, it never culminated in the final acceptance since the offer of the petitioner was conditional and did not accept the terms and conditions. On the contrary, the bidding notice in its entirety, despite being the highest bidder, established its own terms and conditions that were within the competence, power, and option of the respondent-RFC to accept or reject it .

Therefore, it must be inferred that no contract has been created between the defendant and the petitioner, since the petitioner limited himself to making an offer and that was conditional in response to the defendant’s RFC tender notice and the terms and conditions established by the petitioner had not been accepted in full by the RPC since a letter of acceptance of their offer had not been issued.

When the creditor has died and the executors of the deceased have not obtained a succession, an offer by letter to pay the debt owed to the executors, in the event that the appropriate release is executed, a valid offer will be made as long as the debtor has been able to pay the debt. Debt and had money available for that purpose. The actual production of money is not necessary in such a case since there is no one with the right to receive payment in the law. 

In a later case, the High Court of Calcutta has now established that whenever a creditor dies, the debtor is in an unfortunate position, he must take the risk of submitting an offer to a person who is now entitled to receive the debt, and The subsequent claim by the executor or administrator of the deceased creditors or he must wait until someone obtains the letters of testamentary administration and incur the responsibility of paying additional interest in the meantime.

Regarding the need for strict compliance with the conditions that entitle a party to a relief of the repurchase production of a transaction, it was held that strict compliance would be deducted by the claimant from the amounts of consideration, but the conduct to be the creditor can be equivalent to a dispensation With the literal complaint of them, a notice is sent to him so that he does not send more products. similarly, in the case of a future share delivery contract, if the buyer before the expiration date notifies the seller that he will not accept the shares, the latter need not show that he was ready and willing to deliver the shares.

A reasonable opportunity for inspection

The seller is obliged to ask the buyer for a reasonable opportunity to examine the goods in order to determine if they are in accordance with the contract. The interested party could not make an inspection of the goods that do not comply with the requirements of the law. However, there is no authority for the proposition that a buyer has the right to continue inspecting and examining until the expiration of the delivery period. 

The law or thing that is offered is the thing that the promoter of the delivery. the law only requires that the fiancé has a reasonable opportunity to see what the promise of opportunity to fulfil is. The normal place of inspection is the place of delivery. The promisor has no obligation to prove the identity of the thing offered to promise satisfaction. The promoter does not have the obligation to take the delivery measures. The promisor is just giving him a chance.

Tender must be to the proper person

An offer to be effective must be made to the right person. At first glance, it is the fiancé who can demand payment and deliver a valid receipt, even though he may have been hired for the benefit of others. In a previous Bombay case, 11 where the debtor was ready with the full amount, but the executors of the deceased creditor did not take steps to obtain the succession, in order to give a valid acceptance, it was held that there had been an adequate tender. 

In a later case, the High Court of Calcutta expressed the view that a debtor must submit an offer to a legally constituted representative or risk submitting an offer to a person who is not entitled to receive the debt and a subsequent claim of the executor or administrator or wait until someone obtains the estate or management letters and incurs the responsibility to pay additional interest in the meantime.

According to the notice of the Supreme Court of Madras of the disposition and willingness to pay given to a person interested in the estate of a deceased, it is an adequate tender. In the case of joint promises, an offer for one of them is a good offer. The heirs of a single fiancé are, for the purpose of bidding, considered joint promises with the result that the bidding of one of them would meet the requirements of the law. If an offer is made to the heirs of a fiancé, it must be in the same conditions as those in which it could be made to the original fiancé.

Tender must be of the full amount

The offer must be of the total amount owed. An offer obstructed with the equipment that the money should be taken as an agreement is not valid. 

Conclusion

A tender may be considered as an open contract whomsoever wishes to fulfil the obligations of the tender may enter into the contract directly or indirectly and get the royalty or payment for the same. Every tender is accompanied by a quoted value and the acceptor or the contractor may get paid over or under or exactly that quoted value upon fulfilling contractual conditions of the tender.

Even all the countries’ money is called legal tender as the leader of the country or the national bank of the country promises to pay the bearer the indicated sum of money upon demand. All tenders are legally binding on both parties and can be enforced in a court of law. Tenders help the parties to execute long term contracts smoothly and soundly. Larger tenders may into sub tenders by the contractor or may consist of more than one contractor for the easier and faster execution of the tender.

Reference

  1. Law of contract M.J. Aslam’s.
  2. The law of contracts and tenders T.S. Venkatesa Iyer.
  3. Contract and specific relief Avtar Singh.
  4. Law relating to contract act of 1872, and tenders Sanjiva row.

The post Tender and its Requisites appeared first on iPleaders.

Protecting The Interest of Minorities From The Glass of Constitutional Armour 

$
0
0

This article is written by Yash Jain, a third-year student of Institute of Law, Nirma University. The article explores the status of “minority classes” from the ancient period to the current era. The article further provides a detailed account of constitutional provisions and cases for the protection of interest of minorities in the country. 

Minority rights have gained greater visibility and relevance all over the world. India being a multi-ethnic, multi-religious, multi-linguistic and multi-cultural society is also not an exception to it. India does not promote or encourage any particular religion and ethnicity. Brotherhood is the essence of its soul and hence India is called a secular country. Diversity is the heart of India and it is in this context that minority rights have added significance to the post-independence era. 

During the making of the Constitution, it was upon the constitutional framers that whatever wrong has been done to the people in the past should be rectified through the provisions of the new Constitution. The Constitution should provide safeguards for the minorities and special provisions for the upliftment of the minorities. The preservation of discrimination seeks to secure that everyone as individuals are treated on an equal basis and this is what the Constitutional framers aimed at. 

The Constitution has given recognition to a number of languages in the Eighth Schedule and there existed five religious groups which have been given the statutory status of National Minorities to the communities namely, Muslims, Sikhs, Buddhists, Parsees and Jains. Today, minority rights have introduced two new magnitudes into democracy. First, they have made the community a legitimate subject of political dialogue and second, they have placed the issue of inter-group equality on the agenda. 

The Constitution has to provide and promote safeguards so that the inter-group equality in the multi-ethnic society of India should come to an equal footing. The framers of the Constitution bestowed considerable thought and attention upon the minority problems in all its facets and provided constitutional and statutory safeguards. Yet the issue has invaded questions till today. The constitution framers took all steps and the provisions have been laid down in the Constitution of India still there are certain questions which have created a struggle between the majority and minority which still exists and even needs an answer.

Some fundamental questions that need to be pondered upon are: 

  • What status has the polity granted to its minorities?
  • What are the problems faced by the minorities especially in the context of inclusion and exclusion in stake building in post-colonial India?
  • What are the provisions granted to minorities?
  • If there are provisions made for the minorities whether they have been implemented properly?
  • What is the role of minorities in politics, socio-economic development?
  • What is the extent of prejudice and discrimination faced by them even today?

In order to answer and compensate the minorities for the wrongs done to them in the past, compensate the members of the discriminated group that are placed at a disadvantaged position Article 15(1) of the Constitution specifically debars the State from discriminating against any citizen of India on grounds only of religion, race, caste, sex, place of birth or any of them. 

Article 15 of the Constitution provides that The State shall not discriminate against any citizen on grounds only of religion, race, caste, sex, place of birth or any of them.” This means a very strict and stringent provision has been laid down in the Constitution of India to safeguard and protect the minority rights. 

Defining Minority 

Minority includes only those groups in the population which possess and wish to preserve ethnic, religious or linguistic traditions or characteristics different from those of the rest of the population. 

Sociologist Louis Wirth defined a minority as “a group of people who, because of their physical or cultural characteristics, are singled out from the others in the society in which they live for differential and unequal treatment, and who therefore regard themselves as objects of collective discrimination.”  

According to Francesco Capotorti, UN Special Rapporteur in his report laid down what constitutes a minority:

“A group numerically inferior to the rest of the population of a State, in a non-dominant position, whose members being nationals of the State possess ethnic, religious or linguistic characteristics differing from those of the rest of the population and show, if only implicitly, a sense of solidarity, directed towards preserving their culture, traditions, religion or language.”

Conceptualization of Schedule Caste and Backward Classes

The earliest reference to the caste system is found in the Rig Veda in which it is mentioned that there exist four castes which originated from Brahma, the supreme being. It was believed that the Brahmans came from the mouth, Kshatriyas from the arms, Vaishyas from the thighs and Shudras from his feet. Brahmans were considered as the instructors of mankind, Kshatriyas were the warrior class, Vaishyas and Shudras were treated as the agriculturists and servants respectively. 

From the time of Rig Veda, Shudras which in the present circumstances are called Schedule Class and Backward Classes, were not treated equally and were treated with inhumanity. The term “Schedule Class” was adopted for the first time in the year 1985, when the lowest ranking Hindu castes were enlisted in the schedule annexed to the Government of India Act for the purpose of statutory safeguards and other benefits that are provided to them. 

The Britishers played a dominant role in the awakening of India towards the plight of Schedule Castes. They ushered the principle of complete equality and justice irrespective of race, colour, caste, creed, religion, etc. and the same has been incorporated in Article 15(1) of the Constitution by the constitutional framers. Subsequently, after the independence of India with the coming of the Constitution, efforts were made to uplift the status of minorities in the country. 

The Constituent Assembly was very concerned about the issue of protection of minorities and other weaker sections of the country. The committee deliberated various matters related to security, preservation and position of women in the society into two sub-committees i.e. the fundamental right sub-committee and the minority sub-committee. Among the two, the minority sub-committee was primarily formed to look after the matters of minorities. 

Criteria for Identifying Backward Classes

The Central and State Governments can identify the Backward Classes based on the criteria recommended by Commission or Committee constituted under Article 340 of the Constitution of India.

Article 340 of the Constitution – Appointment of a Commission to investigate the conditions of backward classes

The President may, by order appoint a Commission consisting of such persons as he thinks fit to investigate the conditions of socially and educationally backward classes within the territory of India and the difficulties under which they labour and to make recommendations as to the steps that should be taken by the Union or any State to remove such difficulties and to improve their condition and as to the grants that should be made for the purpose by the Union or any State the conditions subject to which such grants should be made, and the order appointing such Commission shall define the procedure to be followed by the Commission.

The Kalelkar Commission (1955) and the Mandal Commission (1980) were accordingly constituted to look after the conditions of the Backward Classes in the country. No fixed criteria for identification of “Other Backward Classes” was provided by the Kalelkar Commission. Whereas, the Mandal Commission held that “socially and educationally backwards” are not necessarily “economically backward classes”. The Commission found that class backwardness was a phenomenon of low caste, hence, the criteria for deciding backwardness of a class has been fixed as follows: 

  • Low social position in the traditional caste hierarchy of the Hindu Society. 
  • Lack of general education opportunities for the major section of a backward class or community. 
  • Inadequate or no opportunities in the matters of public service.
  • Inadequate representation in trade, commerce and industry. 

Specific provisions are laid down in the Indian Constitution for protection of Schedule Caste and Backward Classes. Recognising the special needs for Scheduled Caste and Backward Classes, the Constitution of India not only guarantees them equality before the law under Article 14 but also enjoys the state to make special provisions in favour of Scheduled Caste, Scheduled Tribes and Backward Classes for their upliftment in the society under Article 15(4). It also empowers the State to make provisions for reservations in appointments and promotions in favour of any backward classes under Article 16(4). In the Constitution, the provisions guaranteeing the protection of Schedule Caste and Backward Classes can be studied under 3 heads i.e. 

  1. Protection of Social Interest 
  2. Protection of Economic Interest
  3. Protection of Political Interest

Protection of Social Interest

The protection of the social interest of the minorities is laid down under Article 14 which talks about equality before the law. It means that no one should be discriminated on the basis of caste, colour, sex, creed etc. further, Article 15(4) talks about the protection of social interest by laying down that special provisions for the advancement of any socially and educationally backward classes including SCs and STs should be made. Article 16 protects the interest of minorities by granting abolition of untouchability and its protection in any form. Article 30 administers All minorities, whether based on religion or language, to have the right to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice. Article 341 and Article 342 also lays down various provisions for minorities to protect their social interest.

Protection of Economic Interest

Protection of Economic Interest has been laid in Article 46 of the Constitution which states that the State shall promote with special care, the educational and economic interests of the weaker sections of the people, and, in particular, of the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes, and shall protect them from social injustice and all forms of exploitation. Special Financial Assistance Fund is charged from the Consolidated Fund of India each year as grant-in-aid for promoting the welfare of STs and the development of Scheduled Areas [Article 275(1)]. Article 335 laid down provisions for the claims of the members of the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes shall be taken into consideration, consistently with the maintenance of efficiency of administration, in the making of appointments to services and posts in connection with the affairs of the Union or of a State. 

Protection of Political Interest

A number of Constitutional Provisions exist for the protection and promotion of the interests of the socially disadvantageous groups. Article 244 and 329 govern the administration of the Scheduled Areas and Scheduled Tribes in any area. Article 330 and 332 provides for reservation of seats for SCs and STs in the House of People and Legislative Assemblies of the States. 

Role of Indian Judiciary

The Indian Judiciary has played a pivotal role in the protection and promotion of minority rights through a series of landmark judgments. The Indian Judiciary has safeguarded the rights of 49% of people who are in minority and who are in a disadvantageous position.

https://lawsikho.com/course/diploma-entrepreneurship-administration-business-laws
 Click Above 

State of Madras v. Champakam Dorairajan [1]

This case is considered as a milestone judgement for the protection and promotion of minorities. 

Facts of the Case 

The case was regarding the admission of students to the Engineering and Medical College of the State. The province of Madras has issued an order (known as Communal G.O.) ordering that seats should be filled in the selection committee strictly on the following basis i.e. out of every 14 seats, 6 were to be allowed to Non-Brahmins (Hindus), 2 to Backward Hindus, 2 to Brahmins, 2 to Harijans, 1 to Anglo Indians and Indian Christians and 1 to Muslims. 

Ratio of the Judgement  

The court held that Communal G.O violated the fundamental rights guaranteed to the citizens of India by Article 20(2) of the Constitution, namely that “no citizen shall be denied admission to any educational institution maintained by the state or receiving aid out of State funds on grounds only of religion, race, caste, language or any of them and was therefore void under Article 13 of the Constitution. 

The Directive Principles of State Policy laid down in Part IV of the Constitution cannot be in any way override or abridge the fundamental rights guaranteed by Part III. On the other hand, they have to conform to and run as subsidiary to the fundamental rights laid down in Part III. 

Jagwant Kaur v. State of Bombay [2]

Facts of the Case

In this case, an order of the collector of Poona under Section 5 of the Bombay Land Requisition Act for requisitioning some land in Poona for the establishment of a Harijan Camp was challenged as a violation of Article 15(1). The basis of the challenge was that a colony intended for the benefit only for the Harijans was discriminatory under the above Constitutional provision. 

Ratio of the Judgement

It was held that Article 46 of the Constitution could not override a fundamental right. Consequently, the order was declared void.  

1st Amendment of the Indian Constitution

The decision of the 1st Amendment had not come into effect until the time of the case Champakam Dorairajan and Jagwant Kumar. After the amendment, it was possible for the state to establish a Harijan colony to advance the interests of the backward classes. But till the amendment was not enacted as Article 15 stood, it was not competent for the state to discriminate in favour of any caste or community. Thus, these two decisions played a massive role which led to an amendment in Article 15. 

The 1st Amendment incorporated Clause IV in Article 15 that empowers the State to make special provisions for the advancement of any socially educationally backward classes of citizens or for the Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribes despite having Article 15(1) and Clause 2 of Article 29

The object of the 1st constitutional amendment was to bring Article 15 and 29 in line with Article 16(4) which empowers explicitly the State to make special provisions for the backward classes in matters of public employment. The addition of Clause IV in Article 15 opened doors for several petitions before the court and the court has waived several petitions by interpreting Article 15 Clause IV.  

Balaji v. State of Mysore [3]

It was held that the reservation could not be more than 50%. The classification of backward and more backward is invalid and caste cannot be the only criteria for a reservation because Article 15(4) talks about class and class is not synonymous with caste. So, other factors such as poverty should also be considered. 

Devadasan v. Union of India [4]

The Supreme Court held that the “Carry Forward Rule” is unconstitutional. As per the carry forward rule posts that could be filled due to lack of candidates in backward classes would be filled by regular candidates but the same number of additional posts would be reserved in the next year. This caused the amount of reservation to go above 50%. Supreme Court held that the power of Article 16(4) could not be used to deny equality of opportunity for non-backwards people. 

Indira Sawhney v. Union of India [5]

The judgement came in a 6:3 ratio, where minority opinion held that the Mandal Commission is unconstitutional because there is no limit set to implement the reservation policy. 

The Majority opinion held that the Mandal Commission is constitutional and does not violate any provision of the constitution. The Supreme Court held that it was mandated that reservation ordinarily should not exceed 50%. The Supreme Court upheld the carry forward rule subject to the overall ceiling of 50%. It was submitted that this view is correct as the reservation is an exception to the general principle of equality as such an exception cannot exceed the main principle. The Supreme Court after considering the various aspects of reservation in a series of cases analysed, examined and reviewed the constitutionality of the reservation system under Article 15(4), Article 16(4) and Article 340 of the Indian Constitution. 

In this case, the Supreme Court had answered several constitutional questions on the reservation. These questions are:

  1. Whether the term “any provision” in Article 16(4) must necessarily be made by the Parliament or Legislature?

The Supreme Court held that the very use of the word “any provision” in Article 16(4) is significant in nature. Article 16(4) uses the word ‘any provision’ for regulations of services, conditions by orders and rules made by the executive. Here, the Parliament or Executive can make the law only for those sections of the society who are not adequately represented. The Parliament or Legislature are not bound in affirmative to make provisions for equal representation in public employment. 

2. Whether Article 16(4) is an exception to Article 16(1)?

The Supreme Court held that Article 16(4) is not an exception to Article 16(1), but is merely a way to do justice with Article 16(1). It is an extension of the Right to Equality.

3. Whether the concept of the creamy layer should be taken into account while implementing Article 16(4)?

8 out of 9 judges, in this case, held that the creamy layer must be excluded from the reservation made for OBCs. They gave the following reasons:

  • For a group to be eligible for reservation, it must constitute a class. In order to be a class, the group must be homogenous. If the variations within it are vast, then it loses its character as a class. 
  • Unless the privileged within the class were excluded, they would never reap the benefits. 
  • Retaining groups who had transcended backwardness within a backward class would tantamount to treated unequal and violate Article 15.  
  1. Whether the carry forward rule is constitutional or unconstitutional?

The Supreme Court held that the “Carry Forward Rule” is constitutional till the time it provides reservation up to 50%. Once the reservations exceed 50%, the rule becomes unconstitutional. 

  1. Whether children of MPs and MLAs are excluded from the creamy layer?

Supreme Court held that it is the discretion of the State to examine the condition of children of MPs and MLAs. In pursuance to this Ramnandan Committee was formed. The committee held that the children of the present and former MPs and MLAs are excluded from the category of creamy layer and will come under the category of ‘Other Backward Class’ under Article 16(4).

  1. Whether the concept of reservation is anti-merit?

Supreme Court held that reservation is not about putting meritorious students behind instead it makes more of an egalitarian society. There are certain positions were the vacancies should be filled by merit only like a scientist, pilots, defence services, etc. Therefore, it cannot be said that the reservation is anti-merit.

  1. Whether the concept of the creamy layer should be applied to Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes?

The Supreme Court was believed that the concept of Creamy Layer is applicable only to “Other Backward Classes”. The Schedule Caste has suffered the practice of untouchability more than other backward class and they are the more underprivileged class in comparison to other backward class.

  1. Whether the adequacy of representation in services under the state is subject to judicial scrutiny?

The Supreme Court held that the adequacy of representation of a particular class in the services under the state is a matter within the subjective satisfaction of the appropriate government. The judicial scrutiny in that is the same as in other matters within the personal satisfaction of an authority. 

  1. Whether the backwardness in Article 16(4) should be both social and educational?

The Supreme Court held that the backwardness enshrined under Article 16(4) need not be both social and educational as in the case of Article 15(4). Article 16(4) is of a broader scope and social backwardness includes many other backwardnesses like economic backwardness, caste, etc.  

K.C Vasant Kumar v. State of Karnataka [6]

The bench of Supreme Court consisting of Justice Chandrachud, Justice Desai, Justice Chinnappa Reddy, Justice Sen and other Justices held that reservations in favour of Scheduled Caste, Scheduled Tribes and Backward Classes must continue in the present form and for a period not exceeding 15 years. But the policy of reservation in the sectors of employment, education and legislative institutions should be reviewed after every five years or so.

The criteria to judge the Backwardness should be the Economic Backwardness and the reservations should not cross a reasonable limit of preference and discrimination. 

Dr Fazal Ghafoor v. Union of India [7]

The Supreme Court held that there should not be any reservation in the field of Speciality. If therefore preference has to be given, it should not exceed 35% of the total quota. 

Conclusion

Upon the analysis of all the cases stated above, it can be observed that the comparison of “socially and educationally backward classes” with the Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribes in Article 15(4) were to be construed as including such backward classes as the President may by order specify on the receipt of the report of the Commission appointed under Article 340(1) of the Indian Constitution. 

The concept of backward classes is not relative in the sense that any class which is backward in relation to the most advanced class in the community must be included in it.

Hence, by a series of cases and constitutional provisions, it can be concluded that minority rights in post-independent India have been safeguarded, promoted and have been encouraged not only by the framers of the constitution but also by the present administrators, the legislators and the Judiciary.  

References  

  1. AIR 1951 SC 226.
  2. AIR 1952 Bom 461.
  3. AIR 1963 SC 649.
  4. AIR 1964 SC 179.
  5. AIR 1993 SC 477.
  6. AIR 1985 SC 1495.
  7. AIR 1988 SC 2288.

 

The post Protecting The Interest of Minorities From The Glass of Constitutional Armour  appeared first on iPleaders.

Viewing all 14289 articles
Browse latest View live


<script src="https://jsc.adskeeper.com/r/s/rssing.com.1596347.js" async> </script>